Alice's Adventures Under Ground review – brilliant in every surreal detail

Royal Opera House, London
The dizzying world of Lewis Carroll is brought to wonderful and touching life, and Gerald Barry’s intense score is marshalled with panache by Thomas Adès

When Alice’s Adventures Under Ground received its European premiere at the Barbican three years ago, it seemed more likely to find a permanent home in the concert hall rather than the opera house. Gerald Barry’s gleeful, picaresque romp through Lewis Carroll’s two Alice books seemed to have produced a work that was more cantata than viable, stageable opera – events and characters almost lifted haphazardly from the texts without much sense of a linear narrative and crammed into a score that lasted a breathless 50 minutes. How could any stage production cope with a piece that zigzagged from one scene to another at such dizzying speed?

Yet Antony McDonald has succeeded in doing just that in a spectacularly successful way. It was McDonald who first released the full operatic potential of Barry’s whirlwind The Importance of Being Earnest with his 2013 production for Northern Ireland Opera, and he applies the same, unfailingly light touch to his staging of Alice for the Royal Opera, with witty designs and pinpoint stagecraft that never puts a foot wrong. The speed at which everything happens doesn’t appear to faze him: within seconds of the very start, as the White Rabbit announces his lateness, Alice has tumbled down the rabbit hole with a torrent of coloratura arpeggios, and encountered the all-male chorus of four “Drink me” bottles that swiftly transform into “Eat me” cakes.

Claudia Boyle (Alice), centre, in Alice’s Adventures Under Ground by Gerald Barry.
Eat me … Claudia Boyle, centre, in Alice’s Adventures Under Ground by Gerald Barry. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

And so it continues. A 19th-century toy theatre provides the frame, and at one point a cardboard cutout of Queen Victoria and her family is whisked across the stage. The four men in the cast of seven become choruses of babies and oysters, as well as taking on solo roles (an average of 10 different parts per singer). Barry’s selection of scenes seems to be weighted slightly towards Carroll’s second book, Through the Looking Glass, with its persistent allusions to chess, though the White Rabbit, the Duchess, the Cook, the King and Queen of Hearts and the Tea Party all appear from Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. Wherever they’re from, McDonald finds hilariously charming representations for them all, and adds another twist with a trio of dancers (Lukas Hunt, Bianca Hopkins and Eloise Hymas) who represent Carroll himself and the historical Alice’s sisters, Lorina and Edith Liddell.

Barry’s music adds its own extra surreal layer, whether it’s the machine-gun delivery of much of the text, the outrageously high soprano writing he inflicts on Alice, or the way in which he seems to embed a whole bundle of musical traditions and references in his score – the use of It’s a Long Way to Tipperary in his setting (in Russian and French) of Jabberwocky; Humpty Dumpty’s melancholy appropriation of Beethoven’s Ode to Joy; or the strangely touching chorale sung by the White Rabbit to end the opera. Meanwhile, the orchestral writing, marshalled with tremendous panache by Thomas Adès, hurls everything at the audience with manic intensity, whether it’s jagged brass, tipsy, tumbling woodwind lines or the wind machines cranked up in the final moments.

Alice with Peter Tantsits as the March Hare, Hilary Summers as the Dormouse and Sam Furness as the Mad Hatter.
Party time … Alice with Peter Tantsits as the March Hare, Hilary Summers as the Dormouse and Sam Furness as the Mad Hatter. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

The show is double-cast for its short run. Both lineups are uniformly excellent: Claudia Boyle and Jennifer France are the Alices, coping fearlessly with Barry’s outrageous demands on their vocal agility, Boyle marginally more feisty as a stage presence, France perhaps getting more of her words across. It’s almost invidious to pick out other names from either cast in what is such a brilliantly executed ensemble piece, but Hilary Summers is a formidable White Queen and Joshua Bloom a wonderfully lugubrious Humpty, while having Nicky Spence and Robert Murray as the two tenors in the second cast is luxury indeed. It’s altogether wonderfully realised, bringing Barry’s surreal world to life more successfully than anyone could possibly have imagined.

• At the Royal Opera House, London, until 9 February.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Alice's Adventures Under Ground review – Barry's breathless and brilliant raid on Lewis Carroll
Gerald Barry’s challenging and ingenious new opera was superbly delivered in concert by the Britten Sinfonia under Thomas Adès and a fine cast of singers

Andrew Clements

29, Nov, 2016 @3:21 PM

Article image
Behind the scenes at Alice's Adventures Under Ground – a photo essay
How do you bring Lewis Carroll’s surreally anarchic books to musical life? Photographer Tristram Kenton went to watch the Royal Opera House’s fast and furious new production of Gerald Barry’s opera take shape

Tristram Kenton, Mee-Lai Stone and Imogen Tilden

31, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Curiouser and curiouser: Thomas Adès on Gerald Barry's Wonderland
Gerald Barry’s new opera based on Alice in Wonderland is as breathless and surreal as Carroll’s novel. The conductor explains how Ode to Joy, a Russian Jabberwocky and wind machines all make perfect nonsense.

Thomas Adès

02, Feb, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
The week in classical: Alice’s Adventures Under Ground; Beethoven Weekender – review
Gerald Barry brilliantly makes Lewis Carroll his own. And the Barbican delivers two unforgettable days of wall-to-wall Beethoven

Fiona Maddocks

08, Feb, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
Das Rheingold review - thrilling start to Warner's steampunk surreal Ring
High drama and slapstick comedy blend perfectly under Antonio Pappano’s pacey conducting for the first instalment of Wagner’s epic cycle

Flora Willson

25, Sep, 2018 @12:50 PM

Article image
The best classical music works of the 21st century
Over the coming week, the Guardian will select the greatest culture since 2000, carefully compiled by critics and editors. We begin with a countdown of defining classical music compositions, from X-rated opera to high-tech string quartets

Andrew Clements, Fiona Maddocks. John Lewis, Kate Molleson, Tom Service, Erica Jeal and Tim Ashley

12, Sep, 2019 @4:20 PM

Article image
The Intelligence Park review – brilliantly played but Barry's opera still bewilders
This witty production of Gerald Barry’s demanding opera about a composer with writer’s block features fine singing and brilliant playing

Erica Jeal

26, Sep, 2019 @11:01 AM

Article image
Fidelio review – Davidsen approaches greatness in uneven production
Tobias Kratzer’s new staging rips Beethoven’s only opera in two to bring contemporary resonance but little of the composer’s original vision, but the singing is superb

Tim Ashley

02, Mar, 2020 @11:17 AM

Article image
Kát’a Kabanová review – angry and compelling, and musically faultless
Amanda Majeski brings unflinching veracity to Janáček’s tragic heroine, while Edward Gardner - in the pit - is magnificent

Tim Ashley

05, Feb, 2019 @11:38 AM

Article image
La Bohème review – exuberant and persuasive revival performed with elan
Conductor Emmanuel Villaume brings drive and intensity to Richard Jones’s detailed but inconsistent production of Puccini’s brilliantly written opera

Martin Kettle

13, Jan, 2020 @3:51 PM