BTS: Love Yourself: Tear review – K-pop's biggest band keep ploughing on

There’s nothing in the boyband’s third album to upset the formula, with hook-heavy synth anthems and breathy ballads delivered to precision-engineered perfection

In January, the BBC News website ran a story about a 23-year-old called Stephanie Fairfield, who had uprooted her life in Scotland and moved 5,000 miles to Seoul in order to be closer to the K-pop boyband BTS. It was news that seemed to startle even BTS’s seven members, presumably no strangers to the attentions of obsessive fans: in South Korea, they’re so popular that their fan club apparently has a waiting list, prospective members being required to buy a certain amount of merchandise before they’re allowed to join.

Western audiences are traditionally resistant to K-pop, with its lyrics in Korean and Japanese, and its customs as mysterious as some of BTS’s translated song titles: Blanket Kick, Spine Breaker, Dimple and the thought-provoking War of Hormone. Moreover, the traditional reaction of western media to K-pop has been to recoil, muttering that there’s something faintly creepy about it: its antiseptic cuteness, the battery farming of young performers tied to “slave” contracts, with everything from their diets to their sex lives strictly controlled by companies so ruthlessly exploitative of artists and fans alike they make Simon Cowell’s Syco corporation look like Crass’s anarchist commune in Epping Forest.

The artwork for Love Yourself: Tear
The artwork for Love Yourself: Tear Photograph: PR

Not any more: Fairfield was an admittedly extreme example of how BTS have quietly broken into the affections of British and American fans. Their last album went gold in the US – unprecedented for a K-pop band – while their next London shows involve two nights at the 20,000-capacity O2 Arena, which everyone expects to sell out, even with the cheapest tickets at £62 a pop. Europe’s biggest venue will be packed with fans singing along phonetically to songs in a language they largely don’t understand.

The question of how this has happened is easily answered. No other genre has so successfully harnessed the power of fans on social media to spread the word. BTS were the most tweeted-about celebrities in 2017. No aspect of their career is too minor for fans to vlog about: on YouTube, there are people posting reaction videos to the fact that BTS changed their logo. In the US, meanwhile, K-pop fans have repeatedly used their own money to take out adverts for artists on the electronic billboards in New York’s Times Square, at a cost of $30,000 a go, which sounds less like something that would happen in real life than a particularly lurid dream had by a venal record company boss.

BTS: Fake Love – video

The question of why is more complex. The reasons traditionally given for BTS’s success back home – their lyrics are, by K-pop’s germ-free standards, pretty raffish and controversial – don’t hold here: you can’t imagine British teenagers are that desperate to hear youthful criticism of societal conventions in South Korea. So theories abound, ranging from the prosaic – they’re filling a vacuum in the market created by One Direction’s split – to the philosophical: if boyband fandom is all about projecting your fantasies on to the performers, then perhaps a group whose lyrics you don’t understand represent an appealingly blank screen.

Listening to BTS’s new album – 43 minutes of music available in five different CD editions, each priced between £20 and £25 – you do wonder how much it has to do with the music. At least part of K-pop’s appeal is that it seems different to British or American manufactured pop. It’s hard to imagine a UK boyband looking like BTS, with their hair styled in matching bushy bowl cuts and dyed neon colours, and it’s hard to think of a western act that dances with the weirdly thrilling, millimetre-perfect synchronicity favoured by K-pop choreographers. There are conventions and customs surrounding K-pop that seem very alien to western pop, from the special attention focused on the maknae, or youngest member of each band, to the bags of rice fans are encouraged to collect for charity.

But there’s nothing about Love Yourself: Tear that sounds particularly alien to British ears, beyond the fact that they’re singing in Korean, with the odd English phrase thrown in: “I still want you”; “So show me, I’ll show you”. It leans a little more heavily on rapping than a western boyband would perhaps dare, but otherwise, with its autotuned vocals, its big EDM synths on Magic Shop and its appropriation of the post-Despacito trend for Latin-flavoured pop on Airplane Pt 2 (“We’re going from Mexico City to Paris!” they sing. “Mariachi! Mariachi! Mariachi!”), it sounds almost exactly like a mainstream British pop album would, with all the good and bad that entails.

On the plus side, they’re very good at ballads, performing them with a breathy intensity that’s genuinely affecting and powerful. There are some very well-turned songs here, not least So What, which offers a pretty flavoursome brand of bubblegum pop house: fizzy synthesizers, a hook that pounds its way into your brain. And there are also some lovely, intriguing production touches: the jazzy guitar and flute that snakes around 134340; the ghostly, reverb-drenched opening to Outro: Tear; the canny way Intro: Singularity, probably the best song here and blessed with a particularly haunting tune, pitches its sound somewhere between vintage 70s soul and a latter-day R&B slow jam.

But there is also stuff that you struggle to recall the second it finishes: in one ear and out the other it goes, leaving no recognisable trace. It’s not that it’s overly saccharine, which is the charge regularly levelled at K-pop; it’s just commonplace. Ampanman and Paradise are the kind of ho-hum pop-R&B tracks with which albums are padded out the world over.

So the phenomenon of BTS seems more interesting than the music at its centre, although Love Yourself: Tear is certainly good enough to keep the phenomenon moving smoothly. Indeed, the phenomenon is currently moving at such a pace, it feels pretty redundant reviewing it: a month before it was released, Love Yourself: Tear had already amassed advanced orders of 1.4m copies. The fans have already decided it’s a masterpiece and a must-have. Its actual contents are almost beside the point.


Alexis Petridis

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Map of the soul: how BTS rewrote the western pop rulebook
Contrary to their dismissive framing as manufactured robots, South Korea’s BTS use social media, documentary and storytelling to make themselves into profoundly human stars

Katie Hawthorne

18, Nov, 2020 @3:31 PM

Article image
Love Yourself more: K-pop band BTS take 'extended break' to 'enjoy life'
Fans send best wishes as hugely successful Korean group say they want to ‘recharge and refresh’

Justin McCurry

12, Aug, 2019 @6:01 AM

Article image
BTS condemn anti-Asian racism: 'We feel grief and anger'
Following the Atlanta shootings, the K-pop group shared their experiences of discrimination and called for respect and solidarity

Laura Snapes

30, Mar, 2021 @9:40 AM

Article image
From tuna fishing to teen love: the producer behind K-pop’s biggest stars
Bumzu is one of the most influential people in K-pop, helping shape South Korea’s multibillion-dollar global music business

Raphael Rashid in Seoul

24, Feb, 2022 @1:00 AM

Article image
K-everything: the rise and rise of Korean culture
From music to film, technology to food, the world has fallen in love with everything South Korean. Tim Adams visits Seoul in search of the origins of hallyu – the Korean wave

Tim Adams

04, Sep, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
BTS review – warmth and wonder from world's biggest boyband
Despite Jungkook’s heel injury, the Korean septet create a powerful communion with devoted fans at their UK debut

Caroline Sullivan

10, Oct, 2018 @12:13 PM

Article image
BTS review – charisma and confidence from the world’s biggest pop group
How do you perform a stadium-sized show without an audience? Over eight years’ worth of milestone singles, the K-pop stars show how it’s done

Katie Hawthorne

25, Oct, 2021 @9:28 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Korean soft power: harder than it looks | Editorial
Editorial: Pop music and TV shows might not sound like a serious business, but public diplomacy matters – whatever form it comes in


28, Oct, 2022 @5:25 PM

Article image
Why I love being a BTS fangirl in my 30s: ‘I’ve seen Suga perform seven times in six weeks’ | Sophia Cai
When I started listening to the K-pop band in 2019, I couldn’t have imagined their music would take me across the world – but being a member of Army has been a life-changing passion

Sophia Cai

18, Jun, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
K-Pop band BTS scores huge hit on South Korea stock market in management firm's IPO
Investors scramble to buy shares in Big Hit Entertainment amid speculation that the boy band members could be allowed to defer military service

Justin McCurry in Tokyo and Martin Farrer

15, Oct, 2020 @2:45 AM