Family’s death at US-Canada border underscores desperate journeys of migrants

Perilous conditions along remote stretch of Manitoba have ambushed border crossers for years

The death of four members of an Indian family at the US-Canada border has once again highlighted the dangerous journeys families are willing to risk for a better life – and the groups that profit from their desperation.

Police in Canada announced on Thursday that the victims, who included a baby and young boy, probably froze to death while attempting to cross into the United States during a blizzard. Seven others survived and were intercepted by police.

“It was an absolutely mind-blowing story. It’s so tragic to see a family die like that, victims of human traffickers … and of people who took advantage of their desire to build a better life,” Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau told reporters on Friday. “This is why we are doing all we can to discourage people from crossing the border in an irregular or illicit manner. We know there are great risks in doing so.”

India’s high commissioner to Canada, Ajay Bisaria, described the deaths as a “grave tragedy”, and announced that a consular team was travelling to Manitoba to aid in the investigation. India’s ambassador to the United States said staff from the Chicago consulate were also heading to Minnesota.

US officials announced the arrest of Steve Shand, who faces charges of human smuggling. Shand, 47, is due to appear in court on 24 January.

“The investigation into the death of the four individuals in Canada is ongoing along with an investigation into a larger human smuggling operation of which Shand is suspected of being a part,” said John Stanley, a special agent with Homeland Security Investigations, in court documents.

On Wednesday, investigators from the US Department of Homeland Security acted on a tip from a snowplow driver, who spotted Shand’s van stuck in a ditch during the blizzard, according to court documents. The driver helped Shand free the vehicle, and Shand said he was bound for Winnipeg to visit relatives. Authorities say it was the second time he had been in the area.

Map

When the officers stopped the car, near the border crossing at Pembina, North Dakota, they found two Indian nationals with Shand and later intercepted a group of five. All spoke Gujarati, a language from the western region of the country. One told officials he spent a large amount of money to come to Canada under a fake student visa and planned to visit an uncle in Chicago.

In preparation for their journey, the group were wearing brand-new winter clothing, including parkas, boots and gloves. They, along with Shand, had black balaclavas. Officers also found evidence to suggest a baby was travelling with the group, but when they couldn’t find the child, they notified Canadian police.

While the prairie landscape the group traversed is largely flat, the sprawling grain fields are deceptively dangerous in the winter. Cold winds whip relentlessly and blowing snow dramatically reduces visibility. Deep snow drifts make movement slow and tedious. All these difficulties are compounded in the dark, when the family is believed to have made their crossing attempt.

Court documents in the United States also provided a glimpse into the brutal cold the survivors endured. One woman stopped breathing while she was transported by border officials, and required the partial amputation of her hand due to frostbite. Another was also treated for frostbite.

“Smugglers only care about the money they are going to make and have zero regard for lives lost,” Anthony Good, a sector chief border patrol agent in Grand Forks, said in a statement.

The deaths have rattled the community of Emerson, a rural farming town of less than 700 people.

“You just try to figure out why there would be that kind of desperation to cross the border in such terrible weather conditions. Crossing the border in the best of times, you know, is dangerous,” Dave Carlson, a local official for the Emerson-Franklin municipality in Manitoba told a local radio station.

The region has been the site of numerous crossings in recent years – although most were coming from the United States into Canada after the election of former president Donald Trump.

In December 2016, two men lost their fingers to severe frostbite after struggling through waist-deep snow during a blizzard as they crossed into Manitoba. A few months later, a woman died of hypothermia near the border on the American side. Three years ago, a pregnant woman was rescued near the border after she became trapped in a snowbank and went into labor.

The tragic deaths this week serve as a reminder of the risks families are willing to take, Rema Jamous Imseis, the Canadian representative for UNHCR, said in a statement.

“Whatever the circumstances, no one should ever have to choose such a perilous journey.”

Contributor

Leyland Cecco in Toronto

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mexico’s vow to tighten border fails to deter US-bound migrants
As the Biden administration enlists its neighbours in attempts to slow the flow of people, families seeking a future free from hunger and violence journey on

David Agren in Frontera Corozal

14, Apr, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Woman seeking asylum in Canada dies of hypothermia near US border
Body of 57-year-old Mavis Otuteye, who authorities said was trying to cross into Canada, was found in Minnesota near border with Manitoba

Julien Gignac in Toronto

31, May, 2017 @6:35 PM

Article image
Manhunt for people-smuggling suspect after eight drown at US-Canada border
The Akwesasne Mohawk police service continue a search for resident Casey Oakes as new details of victims emerge

Leyland Cecco in Toronto

03, Apr, 2023 @5:00 PM

Article image
Central American migrants desperate to reach US risk new dangers at sea
As US-driven immigration crackdown forces many to find alternative routes through Mexico, activists along the coast fear trafficking and drownings will rise

Nina Lakhani in Pesquería de Gloria, Chiapas

15, Sep, 2016 @10:00 AM

Article image
Jogger accidentally crosses US border from Canada and is held for two weeks
Cedella Roman was visiting mother and studying English but evening run along beach led to two-week detention nightmare

Ashifa Kassam in Toronto

22, Jun, 2018 @7:18 PM

Article image
Why did 10 migrants die in this truck in Texas?
Their deaths, after being crammed into an uncooled trailer amid scorching summer heat, expose the callousness of smuggling along the US-Mexico border

David Agren in Calvillo, Tom Dart in San Antonio and Nina Lakhani in Mexico City

30, Jul, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Canada pension fund quietly divests from US migrant detention firms
CPPIB pulls investments in CoreCivic and Geo Group in unannounced move that follows Guardian report on holdings

Tracey Lindeman in Ottawa

05, Jul, 2019 @3:59 PM

Article image
Revealed: Canada uses secretive anti-terrorist database run by US
Tuscan is effectively a second Canadian no-fly list with 680,000 names, despite problems with the official list

Justin Ling in Toronto

21, Jun, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Trudeau to announce US-Canada asylum deal after Biden talks
Move following meetings in Ottawa with the US president will in effect close a controversial border crossing

Leyland Cecco in Toronto

24, Mar, 2023 @9:41 PM

Article image
Canada to offer temporary residence to those stranded by Trump travel ban
Immigration minister Ahmed Hussen offers help to people stuck in the country thanks to the ban, though it is unclear how many people are affected

Ashifa Kassam in Québec City

31, Jan, 2017 @3:59 PM