‘More trafficking victims to be held in detention under UK rule change’

Rights groups warn many more survivors face being locked up after MPs back Home Office change

More victims of trafficking will be locked up in detention and forcibly removed from the UK after MPs approved a change in Home Office rules relating to this vulnerable group, campaigners have warned.

MPs recently confirmed what is known as a statutory instrument. This change in rules relating to the detention of trafficking victims comes into force on 25 May and will require them to provide a higher standard of proof that they should not be detained.

Lawyers and human rights campaigners say the imminent changes will lead to many more victims of trafficking being locked up.

Nearly 3,000 people identified as potential victims of trafficking have been detained since 2019 due to their immigration status. These numbers are expected to increase. In law, detention may be used only when there is the intention to remove a person from the UK.

A freedom of information response obtained by the Scottish Refugee Council showed that between April 2017 and December 2020, of 5,088 recognised victims of trafficking from outside the EEA, only 260 were granted discretionary leave to remain, while 3,443 were not granted discretionary leave and 1,385 decisions were pending. It is possible that another form of leave has been granted to some victims but many acknowledged trafficking victims do not qualify for other forms of leave.

Home Office figures on victims of trafficking considered for discretionary leave
Home Office figures on victims of trafficking considered for discretionary leave

Under the new rules, potential victims of trafficking who are locked up in immigration detention are likely to have to provide medical evidence of future harm for officials to consider releasing them from detention – the same rules that apply to others who are detained. At the moment there is greater recognition of the vulnerability of this group when they are detained.

In previous years, even with better safeguards, there have been many concerning cases. A Latvian victim of trafficking won £15,000 in damages for false imprisonment after she was detained between March and May 2019.

She had been forced into trafficking drugs in her home country after borrowing money when she got into debt following cancer treatment. She was suspected of being tortured by her traffickers and was at risk of being retrafficked had the Home Office forcibly removed her.

In a second case, a Vietnamese victim of trafficking was detained between 17 July and 25 September 2018. He was forced to work in a house in Birmingham used as a cannabis farm. He was arrested during a raid and sentenced to 10 months in prison for production of a class B drug.

He was served with a deportation order on 21 March 2018 and his detention under immigration powers was authorised on 30 May 2018. Although he was identified as a potential victim of trafficking, he was not released until legal action was launched. The Home Office has agreed to pay him £22,000 in damages for false imprisonment.

These two cases illustrate the importance of potential victims of trafficking having access to legal representation while detained.

Concerns were expressed that on a recent Home Office charter flight to Vietnam, a country that is a major source of trafficking, not everyone on the flight had adequate access to legal advice before removal after it emerged that six of 14 people forcibly removed on the flight did not spend five days prior to departure in immigration detention centres, which lawyers say is recommended under Home Office guidelines.

The Home Office denied that anyone on the flight did not have full access to legal advice. Home Office sources told the Guardian that there was no legal requirement for individuals to be detained in immigration removal centres for five days prior to removal.

Sign for Colnbrook immigration removal centre, near Heathrow airport.
Colnbrook immigration removal centre, near Heathrow airport. Under the new rules, potential victims of trafficking will have to prove future harm to be considered for release. Photograph: Alamy

Graham O’Neill, policy manager at the Scottish Refugee Council, accused the Home Office of systemic failure to provide the leave to remain to trafficking victims. “The Home Office must recognise this and desist from removals of survivors,” he said.

Ahmed Aydeed, a solicitor at Duncan Lewis, who represents many victims of trafficking, said: “The home secretary is, on a regular basis, compelled to accept her wrongdoing of falsely imprisoning survivors of trafficking and modern slavery. She is regularly compelled to pay damages for her wrongdoing, but yet continues to detain thousands of survivors every year for administrative convenience.

“The home secretary now plans to further downgrade protection against administrative detention for survivors of trafficking, which will lead to even more victims being detained. She recognises the likely harmful consequences imprisonment has on survivors’ physical and mental health, but continues to push for these changes.”

A Home Office spokesperson said: “The government’s generous safeguards for victims are open to abuse by failed asylum seekers or foreign criminals who have no right to be here. Attempts to cheat the system diverts resources away from genuine victims of trafficking, persecution and serious harm.

“The UK has led the world in protecting the victims of modern slavery and we will continue to support those who have suffered intolerable abuse at the hands of criminals and traffickers so they can rebuild their lives, while preventing the exploitation of the system.

“We are fixing an anomaly in the system to make sure that those who we believe may have been a victim of modern slavery are treated consistently with all other vulnerable people in immigration detention, such as those with serious physical disabilities.”

• This article was amended on 7 May 2021. An earlier version said “many” potential victims of trafficking held in detention are subsequently deported. Government figures are unavailable for all outcomes, and this sentence has been replaced with one describing the purpose of detention. A reference to detainees needing medical evidence of future harm has been amended to say this is “likely” rather than required; self-declaration is given “limited weight” under the rules. The headline was replaced to emphasise campaigners’ warning over a rise in detentions.


Diane Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK accused of stranding vulnerable refugees after Brexit
Exclusive: Torture survivors and lone children stuck in Greece and Italy after Home Office ‘deliberately’ ends cooperation on family reunions

Harriet Grant and Katy Fallon

27, Apr, 2021 @11:25 AM

Article image
‘We thank your government for our full pockets’ – Calais smugglers speak
As the UK pours millions into security measures, migrants say the gangs who control the Channel just get more powerful

Mathilda Mallinson

10, May, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Home Office condemned for forcing migrants on bail to wear GPS tags
Round-the-clock tracking condemned as ‘Trojan horse’ giving government vast surveillance powers that violate human rights

Mathilda Mallinson

14, Jun, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Thousands of potential trafficking victims held in immigration centres, data shows
UK’s ‘detain first, ask later’ approach is hampering state’s ability to identify victims, say charities

Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

18, Oct, 2021 @7:26 AM

Article image
Italy using anti-mafia laws to scapegoat migrant boat drivers, report finds
A decades-long policy of criminalising asylum seekers is filling prisons with innocent men, according to analysis by rights groups

Lorenzo Tondo

15, Oct, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Home Office sued by asylum seeker over baby’s death
Woman claims asylum housing staff ignored pleas for help when she was in pain while 35 weeks pregnant

Nicola Kelly

23, Apr, 2021 @6:30 AM

Article image
Lockdown gives asylum seekers reprieve and hope for change in policy
After lockdown pauses threat of detention and deportation, campaigners call for ethink on UK immigration

Clare Considine

25, May, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Home Office planned speedy removal of Vietnamese trafficking victims
Documents seen by Guardian refer to fast-track system not intended to be used in trafficking cases

Diane Taylor

27, Sep, 2021 @9:55 AM

Article image
Uncovered: the brutal secrets of UK deportation flight Esparto 11
On 12 August 2020 at 7.48am the first of a series of Home Office flights carrying asylum seekers left Stansted. This is the harrowing story of the hours before it took off and the anguish of those on board

Aaron Walawalkar, Jessica Purkiss, Eleanor Rose and Mark Townsend

29, May, 2021 @4:51 PM

Article image
Pauline Latham MP picks up bill to end child marriage in England and Wales
MP to take over private member’s bill proposed by Sajid Javid to raise legal age to 18, after his promotion to health secretary

Hannah Summers

30, Jun, 2021 @11:22 AM