Refereeing controversies will not go away but Jenas should know better | Paul MacInnes

BBC pundit’s criticism of Rob Jones was a mistake – though the handball rule continues to confuse fans and managers alike

Embarrassing. After another weekend of controversial VAR decisions, it would seem the only appropriate word. Yes, expectations are unduly high. Yes, everyone makes mistakes. But at the end of the day it’s not brain surgery: when Jermaine Jenas got his phone out to call the referee Rob Jones a “sh**house”, he should have taken a deep breath, counted to 10, then walked away.

Jenas, the BBC pundit and pre-season face of – you couldn’t write it – an Football Association campaign to promote respect for referees, has made himself look permanently stupid. Just another weekend in the Barclays, you might say. But Jenas’s error-strewn social media message (full text: “Complete sh**house off a referee! They’re all ruining the our game!”) is hardly atypical. People are losing their stuff at refereeing decisions on a weekly basis.

The central controversy this week affected Tottenham, Jenas’s former side, who conceded a penalty to Arsenal in the north London derby after Cristian Romero blocked a goal-bound shot from Ben White. Initially, Jones chose not to give the spot-kick but, after lengthy consideration by the VAR Paul Tierney, Jones was advised to visit his monitor, where he duly overturned his decision, allowing Arsenal to take a 2-1 lead which they held on to for all of a minute.

Speaking after the match the Spurs manager, Ange Postecoglou, offered up a view of the decision that was a degree more measured than Jenas’s, but still critical. “I couldn’t see it but I’ve got no idea about the handball rule,” he said. “I really don’t. It just seems if it hits your hand it’s a penalty, and then other times if it hits your hand, it isn’t a penalty. It is the one rule in the game I just don’t understand. Unless we start developing armless defenders I don’t know how you are supposed to block things and be in a natural position.”

With those last two words Postecoglou gets to the heart of what’s heating people up about handball decisions. Under Law 12 of the game, a player can be penalised for handling if the ball hits their arm in a position where it is judged to have made the player’s body shape “unnaturally bigger”. That’s a difficult concept to get your head around. What is naturally big after all? And does the definition of bigness change if the body is falling? Or leaping? Or simply standing still?

The law says that it does. A body can be unnaturally big if its size is not “a consequence of, or justifiable by, the player’s body movement for that specific situation”. Furthermore, guidance on the application of the rule, shared with Premier League officials by the referees body Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) at the start of the season said that “unnaturally bigger” was also something influenced by whether the player “takes a risk” in putting their arm where it might be hit.

These are all factors a referee has to take into consideration, in pretty much a split-second, before making a call that could drive any number of ex-pro pundits doolally. There’s more to consider, too: according to the PGMOL guidance, the proximity of the player to the shot should be taken into account, as should the subsequent trajectory of the ball after it has hit the arm.

All of these considerations are subjective. A referee is going to form an opinion that is their own and they will only be asked to reconsider it if the VAR believes they have made a “clear and obvious” error. That VAR call is subjective, too, even if PGMOL demands a high bar for intervention (this is one of the reasons it takes time to make an overturn call, the VAR has to be as sure as they can be that an error has been made).

On Romero’s block the decision was taken by Tierney that the defender’s body shape was bigger, it was not justifiable by his position, that he was not close enough for proximity to be a mitigation and that the ball had been sent in a new direction by the Argentine’s intervention. Inside PGMOL on Monday there were no doubts that, ultimately, a penalty was the correct decision.

Controversy over VAR and refereeing decisions will not go away. Even in instances that are not subjective, such as whether a player is offside or not, there will be strong opinions. To call for supporters and pundits to remember that officials are human beings with challenging jobs and that mistakes are inevitable would seem like howling into the wind at this point. But as Jenas apologised on Monday for letting his “emotions get the better of me”, it’s worth noting that it’s not just referees who make mistakes now and again.


Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Raising the VAR: officials hope lighter touch will help stop controversies | Paul MacInnes
Fans hate video assistant referees but they are here to stay and the Euros offered encouragement for the new season

Paul MacInnes

09, Aug, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Jara’s elbow shows video referees need practice to end controversies | Simon Burnton
Officials say poor call in Confederations Cup final was part of a learning curve and the more VAR is used the fewer mistakes will be made

Simon Burnton

03, Jul, 2017 @7:32 PM

Article image
‘I can’t do anything’: world of VAR removes power of rational thought
Audio from Stockley Park shows the officials’ confusion for Liverpool’s ‘goal’ and confirms the referee’s job has been made harder

John Brewin

04, Oct, 2023 @2:03 PM

Article image
‘That’s 365 a year’: Ange Postecoglou cautions against replays after mistakes
The Tottenham manager has said replaying game against Liverpool would set a dangerous precedent and believes VAR should be scrapped

Jacob Steinberg

06, Oct, 2023 @9:30 PM

Article image
Mauricio Pochettino calls for VAR in Premier League to be postponed
The Totttenham manager said he feared the new VAR system is ill-suited to the ‘dynamic’ English game

David Hytner

23, Jan, 2019 @10:30 PM

Article image
VAR furore at Tottenham and Atlético a sign of what football has lost | Luke McLaughlin
In obsessing over the minutiae of refereeing, the game has sacrificed its spontaneity, narrative coherence and sense of fun

Luke McLaughlin

27, Oct, 2022 @2:32 PM

Article image
To be seen and not heard is keeping fans and viewers in the dark over VAR | Barry Glendenning
The marathon wait for a VAR check at Arsenal could have been tolerable if we could have listened in

Barry Glendenning

25, Apr, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘I am absolutely sick’: Roy Hodgson rails at state of laws and refereeing
Roy Hodgson said games such as the 2-1 defeat by Liverpool made him realise ‘I won’t be missing anything’ about football when he retires

Jonathan Liew at Selhurst Park

09, Dec, 2023 @5:45 PM

Article image
VAR is getting it right despite football's wider mood of suspicion and distrust | Sean Ingle
New studies have revealed that the accuracy of ‘match-changing decisions’ has increased significantly with VAR and it has had hardly any effect on the way games are played

Sean Ingle

21, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Liverpool ask Premier League to review VAR decisions in draw at Everton
Liverpool have asked the Premier League to review the use of VAR in their controversial 2-2 draw at Everton in the Merseyside derby

Andy Hunter at Goodison Park

17, Oct, 2020 @5:10 PM