The East review – war is hell … for the bloodthirsty imperialists

Jim Taihuttu’s story of Dutch soldiers in Indonesia is as short-sighted as the old-fashioned colonialists it is trying to criticise

The canonisation of Apocalypse Now has resulted in a cinematic template for the psychological war epic where the battlefields on which indigenous people are brutalised are essentially a backdrop for white soldiers’ internal crisis. Covering the Indonesian war of independence through the viewpoint of the occupier, The East is yet another pale addition to the format, rehashing empty metaphors that are barren of emotional complexity, historical poignancy or visual ingenuity.

The basic history is this: as the second world war draws to an end, the Netherlands sends more troops to Indonesia, hoping to regain their colonial footing as the Japanese occupation of the islands loses steam. Among these fresh-faced recruits is the angelic-looking Johan de Vries (Martijn Lakemeier); unlike the other crass soldiers, De Vries is the “nice guy”, whose goodness manifests in maudlin details like giving biscuits to local kids. His sense of righteousness is driven by guilt; back home, his father is imprisoned as a Nazi collaborator. Still, De Vries will soon be corrupted by an authoritarian superior whose sadism only magnifies the horrors of war.

Ostensibly a critique of imperialism, The East inadvertently commits the same sins as the old empire once did, as Indonesian characters are no more than window dressing. During the bloated running time, indigenous people appear on screen only to be violated and massacred, their screams a mere decorative sound effect. As the film clumsily pairs scenes from De Vries’ life both during and after the war, he is given a degree of multidimensionality that is withheld from the Indonesian characters, who are invariably victims or barbaric aggressors. To travel all the way there only to make a tiresome Heart of Darkness pastiche is a waste.

• The East is released on 4 October on digital platforms.

Contributor

Phuong Le

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Battle at Lake Changjin review – China’s rabble-rousing propaganda war epic
China’s costliest film ever is a sporadically thrilling, historically dubious account of a Korean war standoff, with all the subtlety of a rocket launcher

Phil Hoad

19, Nov, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Final Stand review – old-fashioned flag-waving for Mother Russia
Thousands of green military cadets march into the firing line as the Red Army resists Nazi invasion in Vadim Shmelyov’s cliche-ridden historical epic

Cath Clarke

03, Mar, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Into the Darkness review – a Danish family at war as the Nazis roll in
In Anders Refn’s sweeping second world war saga, a wealthy clan is ripped apart after choosing several different sides in the conflict

Leslie Felperin

03, Mar, 2021 @6:00 PM

Article image
The Eight Hundred review – ear-rattling, breathtaking battle for 'Chinese Alamo'
One regiment’s symbolic and often suicidal defence of a warehouse in bombed-out Shanghai is the subject of this tub-thumping war epic

Cath Clarke

16, Sep, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
The Warrior Queen of Jhansi review – Indian rebellion epic gets feminist retelling
Devika Bhise as the widowed monarch Rani Lakshmibai shows the Victorian Brits, including Rupert Everett, what she’s capable of in this impressive drama

Leslie Felperin

11, Dec, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Battle of the Bulge: Winter War review – a fight until the bitter end
Lush cinematography can’t save this dated second world war drama, let down by comic accents, cliched dialogue and confusing action

Leslie Felperin

16, Jun, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Recon review – GIs on a mission to nowhere
Second world war soldiers in Italy march warily towards a possible trap in a disappointingly flat adaptation of Richard Bausch’s much-lauded novel

Ellen E Jones

13, Jan, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
Outlaw King review – bold, watchable portrait of Robert the Bruce
Chris Pine pulls off a decent Scottish accent as the great 14th-century insurrectionary in David Mackezie’s brisk retelling

Peter Bradshaw

09, Nov, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society review – an outbreak of world war twee
Populated by Downtown Abbey graduates, this glutinous postwar rom-dram is a load of cobblers

Peter Bradshaw

20, Apr, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Painted Bird review – gruelling descent into war's deepest horror | Peter Bradshaw's film of the week
The story of a young Jewish boy’s odyssey through occupied Poland during the second world war is filled with almost unimaginable horror

Peter Bradshaw

11, Sep, 2020 @6:00 AM