Electric planes sound like a fantasy but they may be the future for short-haul in Australia

With net zero technologies for long-haul flights still far in the future, opportunities may lie with smaller operators

In late September the first fixed-wing passenger electric passenger aircraft took off from Grant County international airport in the US state of Washington. The nine-seater charter plane – known as Alice – soared to 1,000 metres (3,500 feet) for eight minutes.

Less than two months later Northern Territory Air Services, a scheduled airline and charter operator, put in an order to bring 20 of the aircraft to Australia with plans to fly passengers from Darwin to Uluru and Mount Isa.

Side shot of Alice mid-air
The first flight of Alice, the first fixed-wing passenger electric aircraft. Photograph: Eviation

It’s a small sign that the winds may be changing for zero-emissions aviation in Australia, one of the most flight-dependent countries in the world.

Until recently there was no industry body making the case for change and even the Royal Flying Doctor Service, which operates the largest air fleet in the country and has traditionally been a hotbed of innovation, has no plans to acquire or develop electric aircraft.

Aircraft and hangars owned by the Royal Flying Doctor Service at Alice Springs airport
Aircraft and hangars owned by the Royal Flying Doctor Service at Alice Springs airport. Photograph: Fotofritz/Alamy

Yet away from the spotlight, a small crop of startups and aviation companies have been working on electric flight.

Among them is the charter company Sydney Seaplanes, which is planning to become the first all-electric airline in the country, and Bader Aero, a company developing a two-seater electric aircraft for use in pilot training and whose co-founder Barrie Rodgers set a record for the longest journey by electric aircraft – a seven-day, 18-stop flight across South Australia in June 2021.

In July the US company Wisk announced a memorandum of understanding with the Queensland Council of Mayors to help clear the way for its four-seater driverless eVTOLs (electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing aircraft) to operate as “safe, sustainable and scalable” air taxis in Brisbane by 2032, when the city hosts the Olympics.

Wisk’s sixth-generation aircraft looks like a scaled-up drone and will have a range of 144km, a cruising speed of up to 120 knots and can be charged in 15 minutes. Its wingspan stretches 15m and it has six propellors mounted on each wing. Once aloft it flies like a small plane.

The Brazilian company EmbraerX is also planning to bring air taxis to Australia, this time by 2026 in Melbourne, in a partnership with Airservices Australia.

Whether these plans will come to fruition remains to be seen. Aside from questions about whether services such as air taxis are desirable, authorities need to hammer out the regulations, insurance and infrastructure needed to make them work.

But the proposals show that at least the conversation about electrifying aviation has begun.

Huge emissions challenge

According to the International Energy Agency the global aviation industry accounted for about 2% of energy-related CO2 emissions in 2021. In Australia domestic aviation represented 8% of transport emissions in 2019.

The nation’s largest airline, Qantas, has increasingly begun talking about its plans to reach net zero emissions, beyond the usual carbon offset it offers its passengers.

Passengers at the Qantas domestic terminal in Sydney
Passengers at the Qantas domestic terminal in Sydney. Photograph: Lisa Maree Williams/Getty Images

The Qantas fleet burned 4.9bn litres of jet fuel in 2019, the last year before the pandemic temporarily curtailed its operations, and generated 12.4m tonnes of CO2.

At the launch of the company’s climate action plan in April, its chief executive, Alan Joyce, stressed that “hydrogen- or electric-powered aircraft are several decades away” and the airline wanted to focus on “technology that is within reach today”.

Qantas has since announced it will begin to replace its domestic fleet from late 2023 to enable the introduction of sustainable aviation fuels. Qantas plans to fuel its planes with 10% SAF – made with biological waste products or renewable materials – by 2030 and about 60% by 2050.

Australia has no SAF refining capacity but a spokesperson said Qantas had helped create a $200m fund to develop the industry.

“Zero emission technology like electric aircraft or green hydrogen are still a very long way off for aviation, and even further away for long-haul flights like London to Australia,” they said. “SAF and high quality carbon offsetting are therefore critical on the path to net zero.”

A photo from 1885 of the La France, a large airship that resembles a hydrogen balloon with a cabin below
The La France, the aircraft that took the world’s first round trip in 1885 – that is, it landed at the same airstrip from which it launched. Photograph: Wikimedia

The price of SAF fuels is expected to fall but it is expected to remain more expensive than those derived from fossil fuels. Despite claims by Qantas that SAF fuels are a “stepping stone” to net zero, there are concerns its investment will create a new refining industry that may hinder the adoption of technologies that eliminate the need to burn fuel at all.

Its biggest competitor, Virgin Australia, has a commitment to net zero carbon emissions by 2050 but a spokesperson said the company was held back by a lack of domestic refining for SAF and “electric aviation isn’t something we’re actively looking at for the time being”.

The main obstacle for long-haul operators is weight. Two decades before the Wright brothers’ first flight in 1903, a two-man crew took the airship La France on the first round trip by an aerial vehicle.It carried a 435kg zinc-chlorine battery on its 8km journey – the equivalent of hauling around a grand piano.

A modern battery this massive would still provide only a fraction of the power required for a commercial passenger aircraft with 150 or more seats.

In January Carnegie Mellon University’s Prof Venkat Viswanathan wrote an article for Nature on the future of batteries in aviation which has become a call-to-arms for engineers in the industry. Viswanathan and his coauthors concluded that it was possible to make significant gains in battery chemistry for use in aviation by 2030 – but only if everything went right along the way. And even then, they would still not be capable of powering the largest passenger aircraft.

This means the future of electric aviation in Australia largely rests with short-haul operators.

An artist’s interpretation of a twin-engine fixed wing plane soaring in a blue sky above purple clouds
A render of the Beechcraft King Air, a twin-engine electric aircraft. Illustration: Dovetail Electric Aviation

David Doral, the chief executive and founder of Dovetail Electric Aviation, says the current generation of batteries are not a good solution and green hydrogen technology is not far enough along in its development to power flights even by light aircraft.

“[For planes] it has to be hydrogen,” he says. “Only with batteries? You’re not going to fly very far.”

Doral says Australia will be “flying at two speeds” on zero-carbon aviation.

“On the one hand, for long-distance flying, we don’t have any good solution. From that side of the industry, I think, the future is a little bleak,” Doral says. “On the other hand, we have short haul-aviation – that is a very different story. We think there’s going to be a renaissance of smaller operators flying short distances.”

Rethinking air networks

Australia’s first passenger services developed after the first world war along mail routes such as Sydney to Brisbane, Charleville to Cloncurry and Geraldton to Derby. Greg Bamber, a professor at Monash University, says modern Australia wouldn’t exist without cheap, commercial passenger air travel enabled by the jet engine.

“It radically changed many things,” Bamber says. “[Aviation] became very important to Australia. We’re a big country, sparsely populated. No decent railways or even intercity motorways for that matter. We’re also a long way from the rest of the world.

David Doral posing next to a plane
David Doral says Australia will be ‘flying at two speeds’ on zero-carbon aviation. Photograph: Carly Earl/The Guardian

“The jet age facilitated the movement of large numbers of people, which was until then very expensive and difficult to do when people had to travel for six weeks on an ocean liner.”

Bamber says that as Australia confronts the reality of climate change, electric flight promises to change how people move and where they live, create new industries and force a rethink of how cities are designed.

“We’re not going to wake up tomorrow and have electric planes,” Bamber says. “But there is massive potential there. If we do have electric aircraft and if it’s coupled with vertical take off and landing, we may see airports much closer to city centres, making travel easier, and we’re going to see people work from more remote locations.”

If there is anyone who believes in the potential for short-haul electric flight to break the hub-and-spoke model between the major cities and regional areas, it’s John Sharp, the deputy chairman of Rex Airlines.

In August the company announced it planned a 2024 test flight in partnership with Dovetail. The test will involved retrofitting one of its existing Saab 340 aircraft with electric MagniX engines and a battery pack.

Should it go ahead, the flight will prove commercial electric flight is possible and prepare the ground for the regulatory steps needed to establish the industry.

“There’s the future of the whole concept of electrically powered aircraft at stake,” Sharp says. “If we can’t make this work, it’ll be a setback for people who hope to convert reasonably large aircraft to electric power.”

Success would be a “game-changer”, according to Sharp. As electric motors have fewer parts, they need less maintenance, make less noise and are less likely to go wrong.

Sharp says an airline like Rex could open more routes if it didn’t have to pay for fuel. “It makes the unviable, viable,” he says. “We’ll be at the bleeding edge worldwide on this. There’s a lot of hope, and a lot of expectations at risk – and clearly quite a bit of money.

“At the end of the day it’s all worthwhile, because the world’s calling on airlines to reduce their carbon emissions and we have to try and do something to meet that call.”


Royce Kurmelovs

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tax perks driving surge in number of SUVs and larger vehicles on Australian roads
Calls to tackle rise in SUVs, utes and 4WDs by reducing tax incentives and building narrow lanes and parking spots exclusively for small cars

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

22, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Rise of ‘fuel-guzzling’ SUVs costing Australians $13bn extra at the pump per year, report finds
Exclusive: Thinktank says popularity of ‘big, dumb’ cars is turbocharging emissions and does not make sense in such an urbanised country

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

28, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Planes, trains and automobiles: comparing cost, speed and emissions of Sydney-Melbourne travel
With fuel prices at record highs and carbon emissions more important than ever, we look at the ups and downs of ways of getting around locally

Elias Visontay

09, Dec, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Australia has a steep hill to climb on electric cars – but if ever there was a time, it’s now | Adam Morton
Consumers say yes, the numbers add up, industry is largely on board and Labor has no policy hang-ups. This week could be the turning point

Adam Morton

14, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Expanding electric vehicle charging network requires more government funding, advocates say
‘It covers most of Australia but lots of locations only have one or two chargers,’ BP Pulse business development manager says, as others call for greater public spending to reduce queues

Henry Belot

16, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Etihad accused of misleading customers with greenwashing in ‘net zero’ ads
Complaint made to ACCC says airline’s claims of net zero by 2050 are not feasible and company intends to increase absolute CO2 emissions

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

22, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Number of electric vehicles on Australian roads soars as demand exceeds supply
Australia’s total of EVs almost doubled in 2022, growing from 44,000 to more than 83,000, sales data shows

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

06, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Twenty hours on a Qantas plane: is this the future of aviation or a fresh hell in economy?
Airline’s ultra long-haul flights are slated to begin in late 2025, but questions remain over the carbon footprint, price and effect on passengers’ bodies

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

11, Mar, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
China takes great leap forward in Australia’s car market with EVs leading the charge
Exclusive: Sales of Chinese-made vehicles increased 61% in 2022 with one industry expert saying companies are ‘innovating faster’

Peter Hannam Economics correspondent

18, Jan, 2023 @12:06 AM

Article image
Electric vehicles: four things that will help Australia shift gears after a ‘decade of denial’
Here’s what we learned from the first national EV summit

Peter Hannam

19, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM