Weak controls failing to stop illegal seafood landing on EU plates, investigation shows

EU financial watchdog blames small fines and feeble controls in some states for amount of illegal seafood

Illegally fished seafood continues to end up on the plates of EU citizens due to weak controls and insignificant fines in some member states, auditors have found.

The European Union, the world’s largest importer of fishery products, requires member states to take action against fishing vessels and EU nationals engaged in illegal fishing activities anywhere in the world.

However, a special investigation [pdf], by the European Court of Auditors (ECA), the EU’s financial watchdog, into systems aimed at preventing products derived from illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing reaching EU consumers, found them to be only “partially effective”.

“We need to tighten the net to illegal fishing within the EU,” Eva Lindström, the ECA member who led the audit, said Monday. She urged member states to step up the fight against IUU fishing, one of the greatest threats to marine ecosystems.

The EU and its member states had put in place control measures to keep illegal fishing in check, she said. “But in spite of those measures, these products keep ending up on EU citizens’ plates,” said Lindström. “One key reason is that checks and sanctions are applied unevenly by member states.”

National checks often detected instances of illegal fishing, the auditors found. But overfishing and underreporting of catches persist, due to weak controls in some states. Misreporting of catches is the most common infringement by the EU fleet, followed by fishing in closed areas or with no quota allocation, and using illegal gear.

While auditors found the vast majority of serious fishing infringements led to an investigation or prosecution, the sanctions applied in some states were insufficient to deter illegal fishing. There was also no level playing field across states, they said. The average fine imposed for infringements ranged from €200 (£180) in Cyprus, Lithuania and Estonia, to €7,000 in Spain.

A catch-certification scheme, introduced by the EU in 2008 to guarantee the legality of imported fish products, had improved traceability and reinforced import controls, they found. But differences in the scope and quality of checks in states risked undermining its effectiveness.

The auditors report recommended the European Commission ensure member states reinforce their control systems to prevent the import of illegal fishery products. The ECA was asked by the European parliament to report on the issue in 2021.

The investigation follows a 2020 report from the same auditors, which concluded that the EU’s efforts to protect the marine environment had resulted in measurable progress in the Atlantic, but the Mediterranean remained significantly overfished.

From 2015 to 2019, member states conducted more than 300,000 inspections; 13% identified at least one suspected infringement and 6% at least one suspected serious infringement. In total, 69,400 infringements were reported during this period, with more than 76% detected by just four countries: Italy (46%), the UK (12%), Greece (11%) and Spain (8%).

Approximately 94% of global fish populations are either exploited or fully exploited, according to the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation. Worldwide, illegal unreported and unregulated fishing is estimated to represent between 11% and 19% of catches, worth $10bn–$23bn (£9bn–£21bn).


Karen McVeigh

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
World leaders descend on France for ocean summit as Macron puts spotlight on seas
As One Ocean event in Brest aims to deliver ‘blue diplomacy’ in areas from pollution to overfishing, activists warn against ‘bluewashing’

Jon Henley

08, Feb, 2022 @1:09 PM

Article image
UK fishing licences could be unlawful, says Oceana
Permits for UK and EU vessels will hinder efforts to protect marine life and may break habitats directive, conservation group warns

Karen McVeigh

17, Dec, 2021 @6:20 AM

Article image
Cutting the food chain? The controversial plan to turn zooplankton into fish oil
A budding industry that aims to catch zooplankton for health supplements and fish food has scientists fearing that its effects on marine ecosystems could be devastating

Regin Winther Poulsen in Tórshavn

19, Jan, 2022 @6:45 AM

Article image
Licence to krill: the destructive demand for a ‘better’ fish oil
Industrial fishing of the tiny crustacea in a dietary supplements gold rush is threatening the Antarctic food chain – and even the climate

Richa Syal

07, Sep, 2021 @5:01 AM

Article image
EU accused of ‘neocolonial’ plundering of tuna in Indian Ocean
Indian Ocean states say EU pushing weakest conservation efforts for yellowfin tuna while EU ‘distant fleet’ hoovers up the most fish

Karen McVeigh

05, Mar, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Sylvia Earle: ‘We are on the brink – a million species may be lost’
We are a species that is superb at killing, says veteran oceanographer, who calls for us to stop treating fish like crops and give them the respect they deserve

Chris Michael in Vancouver

09, Feb, 2023 @5:42 PM

Article image
‘An invisible killer’: how fishing gear became the deadliest marine plastic
Plastic in the depths: as ‘ghost gear’ chokes the ocean, campaigners call for mandatory measures including buy-back schemes and recycling

Emma Bryce

07, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Millions of tonnes of dead animals: the growing scandal of fish waste
Dumped at sea, lost on land or left to rot in shops and fridges, the global catch of fish is being wasted like never before – hurting not only the oceans but the nutrition of billions of people. Can it be reversed?

Emma Bryce

09, May, 2022 @5:15 AM

Article image
Tiny Pacific island nation declares bold plan to protect 100% of its ocean
Niue is creating a marine park to protect its waters, an area the size of Vietnam, from illegal fishing

Claire Turrell

30, May, 2022 @6:15 AM

Article image
Lab lobster: Corsican institute hopes breeding can solve overfishing
Researchers at Stella Mare believe they have cracked the secret of captive breeding – and can save the island’s artisanal fisheries

Peter Yeung

17, Nov, 2021 @8:00 AM