Stoush over electric vehicle tax nears Australian high court hearing

With a hearing expected later in the year, the outcome could have far-reaching consequences for revenue raising from electric vehicles, lawyers say

A stoush between the commonwealth and states over electric vehicle taxes has moved closer to a high court hearing in a process carrying wide-ranging implications for revenue raising, lawyers say.

In September 2021, two drivers of electric cars launched a high court challenge that argued the imposition of a tax of 2-2.5 cents per kilometre by the Victorian government was unconstitutional because the state does not have the constitutional power to impose such fees.

A special case on the matter was filed on Monday with a hearing expected late this year or early in 2023, Jack McLean, an associate of Equity Generation Lawyers that filed the original challenge, said.

New South Wales became the first to intervene on the side of the Victorian government two months ago, with all states and territories signing up by July. In that month, the commonwealth government intervened on the side of the Melbourne-based plaintiffs, engineering consultant Kathleen Davies and nurse manager Chris Vanderstock.

“The case has potentially broad legal implications for the ability of state governments to impose similar taxes,” McLean said.

The right of governments other than the commonwealth to raise revenue has frequently been tested in the high court. Australia has a relatively high degree of vertical fiscal imbalance, where most of the revenue-raising is done by the federal government but much of the spending is done by states and territories.

When introduced in April 2021, the Victorian tax was pilloried by some as the “worst EV policy in the world”, an issue the plaintiffs hope to highlight.

“Our clients want to see sensible and effective policy that drives the energy transition, not a new clunky new tax that punishes Victorian families who have decided to make the switch to cleaner cars that are better for the environment and better for our children’s health,” McLean said.

“By making electric vehicles more expensive, this tax disincentivises Victorians from making the switch to cleaner cars that cut emissions and improve air quality,” he said. “In short, it’s bad for the climate, it’s bad for Victorians, and it may be unconstitutional.”

A spokesperson for the federal attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, agreed that the case may carry “implications for longstanding constitutional principles in relation to revenue and economic policy”.

“The commonwealth’s interest in the case concerns these constitutional principles,” the spokesperson said.

Anne Twomey, a University of Sydney professor specialising in constitutional law, said the issue will come down to definitions over how the tax is being applied under section 90 of the constitution.

“States cannot impose excises – being taxes on goods,” Twomey said. “An excise has until now been defined as a tax on a step from production/manufacture of the goods to its point of sale to the consumer.”

“Once the consumer owns the goods, however, a tax on them is not an excise, but rather a consumption tax, which has been treated as not being prohibited by the constitution,” she said. “A tax upon the usage of EVs, after they have already passed into the hands of consumers, calculated by reference to their usage, would be a classic consumption tax.”

“It would be a significant departure from precedent if the high court held that such a consumption tax now also fell within the category of an excise,” Twomey said, citing decisions such as the Dickenson’s Arcade case in 1974.

For its part, Victoria has sought to highlight its effort to apply a road-user fee for EV owners who have no or limited exposure to the fuel excise that the federal government collects.

“The road-user charge for zero and low-emission vehicles ensures a fair and sustainable revenue base to fund investments in the road network,” a Victorian government spokesperson said.

“We’re backing the switch to electric vehicles with a $100m package of incentives and support for motorists and industry, made possible by the road user charge,” he said.

McLean said the two original plaintiffs in the case had also been motivated by the fact the tax applied to use on public roads by those with a Victorian registration even if they were driving outside the state.

“The fact that Victorian electric vehicle drivers are taxed for driving on roads in other states and territories only adds to the sense of frustration felt by our clients about this tax,” he said.

The Albanese government said it wanted to cooperate with states and territories to develop policies on electric vehicles. Data from the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries out on Monday showed EVs made up a record high 4.4% of car sales for August.

“Unlike the former government, the Albanese government knows that EVs reduce running costs as well as emissions,” the spokesperson for Dreyfus said.


Peter Hannam

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Victoria’s electric vehicle tax faces high court challenge
Case, launched by two Melbourne EV drivers, will argue the levy is unconstitutional and ‘similar to the GST which is a commonwealth tax’

Lisa Cox

16, Sep, 2021 @10:53 AM

Article image
E-scooter safety: Australian states and territories under pressure after spate of fatal crashes
After three riders died in September and injuries rise, doctors are pushing for better helmet compliance and a rethink on regulations

Cait Kelly

22, Oct, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Cash claims IR law will lead to ‘chaos and confusion’ – as it happened
This blog is now closed

Lisa Cox and Royce Kurmelovs (earlier)

27, Nov, 2022 @6:48 AM

Article image
Murray-Darling Basin plan: Victoria will struggle to meet water delivery obligations by deadline
Water minister says state will only consider additional 450GL efficiency projects if they do not negatively affect farmers or towns

Anne Davies

22, Sep, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Electric cars averaged more travel than petrol vehicles in Australia in past year
Expert says claims that EVs will ‘end the weekend can be put to bed’ by new figures

Royce Kurmelovs

26, Nov, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Labor faces electric vehicle roadblock over inclusion of hybrid cars
Greens and David Pocock say government bill amounts to a fossil fuel subsidy and will slow uptake of zero emission vehicles

Amy Remeikis

20, Sep, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Civil liberties concerns over Australian police powers to issue fines for coronavirus rule breaches
Most states say police will use discretion over potential social distancing violations, but rights advocates argue public messaging on new laws can be unclear

Matilda Boseley, Paul Karp and Ben Smee

31, Mar, 2020 @2:39 AM

Article image
147 new Australian Covid-19 cases – as it happened
Confusion over NSW-Victoria border closure as the state’s northern border closes for the first time in a century. This blog is now closed

Elias Visontay and Amy Remeikis

08, Jul, 2020 @9:34 AM

Article image
Australian Covid-19 death toll reaches 313 – as it happened
Australia’s coronavirus death toll passes 300. Queensland goes a week without a community coronavirus case. This blog is now closed

Michael McGowan (now) and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

10, Aug, 2020 @8:47 AM

Article image
Australian state governments declare public health emergencies to contain coronavirus
Leaders outline penalties for people who fail to self-isolate or cancel mass gatherings

Paul Karp

16, Mar, 2020 @12:18 AM