Just Stop Oil protesters guilty of criminal damage to Van Gogh frame

Activists caused permanent harm to frame holding Peach Trees in Blossom at a London art gallery, judge finds

Two Just Stop Oil activists have been found guilty of causing criminal damage after glueing themselves to the frame of a Vincent van Gogh painting at a London art gallery.

Emily Brocklebank, 24, and Louis McKechnie, 22, caused just under £2,000 of damage at the Courtauld Gallery when they attached themselves to the 1889 work Peach Trees in Blossom, their trial heard on Tuesday.

The 18th-century frame, which is older than the painting itself, had been permanently damaged, District Judge Neeta Minhas told Westminster magistrates court.

“It is not in a state where it can return to its original state,” she added as she delivered her verdict. “The painting has significant, historical and art value and I consider the damage to be substantial. It is not minor, insignificant, temporary or trivial.”

A lawyer for the activists, who are part of a group waging disruptive protests until the government agrees to halt all new oil and gas projects, had asked a curator for the gallery if the action may have increased the value of the painting.

“Say the institute was to sell it on in 20 to 30 years, is it possible its value would now increase?” Francesca Cociani, defending, asked Karen Serres, a curator at the gallery.

Serres, who was the sole witness in the trial, replied: “Absolutely not,” adding that a work so famous as one by Van Gogh would not increase in value as a result.

Such works, which were owned by a trust which held items displayed at the gallery, could also not be sold and were intended for public display, she added.

CCTV footage was played to the court showing the activists walking into the building at about 3.30pm on 30 June after buying tickets for an exhibition. They then took off their jackets to reveal orange Just Stop Oil T-shirts and attached themselves to the artwork.

Brocklebank, a student from Yeadon, Leeds, received a 21-day sentence, suspended for six months, but is subject to an electronically monitored six-week curfew. McKechnie was jailed for three weeks.

She told the court earlier: “When it comes to protesting, just speaking does not get a platform. By gluing, it gives a story which the media chooses to follow.”

“I didn’t think I would cause much damage. Glue comes off.”

She said the painting’s owner would have “consented” to the protest, adding: “Any good human would agree with trying to sustain life on Earth.”

Jonathan Bryan, prosecuting, said that the defendants had claimed they were expressing their rights, under the European convention, to freedom of expression and of assembly, but he added that these were qualified rights rather than absolute ones.

Serres told the court earlier that it took three hours for the activists to be removed, adding: “There were concerns over how much of the glue had seeped into the frame and the painting itself.”

There were also worries about the solvent used by police to remove the activists, the court heard.

Xavier Gonzales-Trimmer, 21, originally faced the same charges after being accused of “distracting the guards” – but they were dropped. However, he was fined for failing to appear at the court for a first hearing.


Ben Quinn

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Just Stop Oil protesters blockade central London petrol stations
Environmental activists stage sit-down protests, blocking entrances and gluing themselves to pumps

Damien Gayle

26, Aug, 2022 @8:19 AM

Article image
Environmental protesters block central London for seventh day
Supporters of Just Stop Oil displayed banners and glued themselves to roads leading to Vauxhall Bridge

Damien Gayle

07, Oct, 2022 @2:18 PM

Article image
Just Stop Oil protesters scale fuel tanker in west London to block M4 access
Rush hour chaos at Chiswick roundabout as environmental activists vow to ‘stop the flow of oil in London’

Damien Gayle

14, Apr, 2022 @3:04 PM

Article image
Climate protesters told to pay National Gallery £1,000 for damaging painting
Just Stop Oil’s Hannah Hunt and Eden Lazarus found guilty after glueing themselves to Constable’s The Hay Wain

Damien Gayle

06, Dec, 2022 @6:19 PM

Article image
Hertfordshire police promise inquiry into arrests of journalists covering climate protests
Chief constable responds after minister condemns arrest of LBC reporter covering climate action

Damien Gayle and Pippa Crerar

09, Nov, 2022 @6:22 PM

Article image
Protesters continue to block UK oil terminals despite more than 100 arrests
Just Stop Oil activists have been climbing on to tankers and glueing themselves to roads since Friday

Clea Skopeliti

02, Apr, 2022 @5:03 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn unites with direct action group Just Stop Oil
Former Labour leader’s Peace and Justice Project to be part of new climate and social justice movement

Matthew Taylor

16, Jun, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Just Stop Oil protesters vow to continue until ‘all are jailed’
Extinction Rebellion close Lloyd’s of London as activist groups continue their direct action

Damien Gayle

12, Apr, 2022 @1:56 PM

Article image
Just Stop Oil activists face new penalties if they obstruct M25 motorway
National Highways has obtained an injunction to ‘prevent unlawful protests’ until November 2023

Joe Middleton and agencies

28, Nov, 2022 @10:16 PM

Article image
The plastic polluters won 2019 – and we're running out of time to stop them
Further steps have been taken to clean up beaches and seas in 2019 – but much more needs to be done

John Vidal

02, Jan, 2020 @12:46 PM