Nature positive and 30x30 – just soundbites or the foundations of a Cop15 deal?

As participants arrive in Montreal to negotiate this decade’s targets for protecting biodiversity, two themes are getting the lion’s share of attention

After more than two years of delays, Cop15, the once-in-decade global biodiversity summit, is about to begin. More than 10,000 participants from across the planet will start arriving in Montreal at the weekend to negotiate crucial goals for protecting biodiversity.

There has been a coordinated push behind some targets, namely from a group of countries that want to protect 30% of land and sea for nature (30x30) by the end of the decade. The idea of “nature positive” is another theme being promoted in the pre-Cop15 rhetoric from NGOs and governments.

I view both as an effort for biodiversity to find a north star, akin to the 1.5C target in the Paris agreement that masks a devilishly complicated legal text.

EO Wilson’s argument that for the good of humanity half the surface of the Earth should be set aside for nature is compelling, and 30x30 could be a step in the right direction – but we must be sure it covers the right areas. Expanding protected areas in deserts and degraded lands with few species will have little impact on the nature crisis.

Much of the remaining variety of life on our planet is found in smaller ecosystem fragments such as forest patches and mangroves along tropical coastlines, many of which are under huge pressure from agriculture. These are the areas that humanity must resolve to protect if we are to stop the decline. The agreement must recognise the ecological difference between a beautiful old growth forest, such as the Białowieża forest in Poland and Belarus, and a plantation of Canadian sitka spruce in Wales. The former has massive value for nature, the latter does not.

Many governments still fail to recognise the difference, and if the protected area target does not commit countries to conserving rare and fragile ecosystems while also upholding human rights, the 30x30 target will be nothing more than a soundbite. Equally important is to ensure funding is available for the effective management of existing and new protected areas. The rights of Indigenous peoples must be respected, or 30x30 could turn into one of the biggest corporate land grabs ever.

I am more sympathetic to the idea of nature positive and a big group of businesses is pushing for mandatory nature disclosures to be included in the final agreement at Cop15 – something that could have a real impact if we get it right.

We must learn the lessons of problems with carbon offsetting standards and so-called nature-based solutions. Companies cannot be allowed to destroy ecosystems with a high biodiversity value in wetlands and the tropics and theoretically compensate for the damage they have caused in areas with a much smaller nature value.

Substance, along with money, as I have written before, will be key to a successful final agreement in Montreal. It will be even more important for effective implementation afterwards.

I have been heartened by the coordination between China and Canada in arranging the summit and hope this continues. Canada has long been an active participant in the UN biodiversity process and could play an important role in resolving outstanding issues in the closing days.

But this is still China’s meeting – they hold the presidency of a major international environmental agreement for the first time, hosted part one of Cop15 in Kunming in 2021, and set the theme of Ecological Civilisation: Building a Shared Future for All Life on Earth. Now it’s up to them – and all of us – to make Cop15 a success.

  • In a series of dispatches ahead of the Cop15 UN biodiversity conference in Montreal in December, we will be hearing from a secret negotiator who is from a developing country involved in the post-2020 global biodiversity framework negotiations.


The Secret Negotiator

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cause for optimism at Cop15 – but could Bolsonaro scupper the deal for nature?
There are many reasons to suggest a deal to save the natural world is possible in Montreal, if division can be overcome and the Brazilian president doesn’t cause problems

The Secret Negotiator

28, Sep, 2022 @5:30 AM

Article image
Lula’s victory in Brazil is a relief but it won’t solve the problem of globalised greed | The Secret Negotiator
It’s great the new president is on the side of nature but no leader can succeed unless the Cop15 deal is right on the money

The Secret Negotiator

05, Nov, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
Cop15 was meant to be nature’s Paris moment, but Greta Thunberg’s ‘blah, blah, blah’ cry is proving right | The Secret Negotiator
In Montreal, progress on biodiversity issues has been slow. We cannot go on like this

The Secret Negotiator

14, Dec, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
‘Paris agreement’ for nature imperative at Cop15, architects of climate deal say
Leaders say December biodiversity summit in Montreal is ‘unprecedented’ chance to turn tide on nature loss

Patrick Greenfield in Sharm el-Sheikh

16, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Cop15 is an opportunity to save nature. We can’t afford another decade of failure | Phoebe Weston
Ahead of the UN biodiversity conference, our reporter reflects on lessons of hope and change in three years reporting with the Guardian’s age of extinction team

Phoebe Weston

01, Oct, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
It is 100 days until Cop15 – and the omens are good for a global plan to protect nature | John Vidal
Despite many challenges, December’s crucial biodiversity talks in Montreal may set a new path for humans to live with nature

John Vidal

30, Aug, 2022 @8:30 AM

Article image
Pressure grows for deal to save nature at crunch talks in Geneva
Campaigners warn time running out for governments to halt and reverse the destruction of wildlife and ecosystems that support the planet

Patrick Greenfield

23, Mar, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Cop15: ‘World leaders might have to invite themselves’ to summit
In its role as president, China has sent invitations only to ministers and NGO heads, raising fears it is downplaying the crucial talks

Patrick Greenfield

06, Oct, 2022 @2:35 PM

Article image
What is Cop15 and why does it matter for all life on Earth?
Once-in-a-decade plans to protect the natural world and halt its destruction will be decided in Canada in December

Patrick Greenfield and Phoebe Weston

24, Oct, 2022 @2:26 PM

Article image
‘Point of no return’: Chris Packham leads calls for Rishi Sunak to attend Cop15
Conservationist says if world leaders do not go to the summit a strong deal to halt and reverse nature loss is at risk

Phoebe Weston

25, Nov, 2022 @12:01 AM