Downing Street to oppose raw sewage amendment in standoff with Lords

Government to maintain resistance to tougher action against water companies despite backlash

Plans to take tougher action against water companies for pumping sewage into rivers and the sea will once again be opposed by the government, Downing Street has announced.

The prime minister’s spokesperson confirmed the government would retain its resistance to adopting an amendment to the environment bill tabled by the Duke of Wellington, which was passed by the Lords earlier this month but subsequently rejected by the Commons.

A standoff is expected to resume on Tuesday when peers vote again on the amendment and are likely to pass it, triggering parliamentary “ping-pong” between the upper and lower chambers.

Ministers are wary of the huge public backlash to their stance, and there are suggestions some form of compromise solution could be offered if the Lords passes the amendment for a second time.

A total of 22 Tory MPs rebelled to support it last week, and some of them expect that figure to rise at the next Commons vote given that many more abstained. One Conservative said the government was “shitting themselves” about the furore.

On Tuesday, Boris Johnson’s spokesperson criticised the current “failure of water companies to adequately reduce sewage discharges is unacceptable” and said it sympathised with the intentions of the amendment.

However, he said the cost of forcing water companies to “take all reasonable steps to ensure untreated sewage is not discharged from storm overflows” had not been estimated – warning it could be up to £150bn.

He added: “That would mean that individuals, every one of us, taxpayers, paying potentially thousands of pounds each as a result so it’s not right to sign a blank check on behalf of customers without understanding the trade-offs and the bills that would be involved.”

After a photographer released footage of untreated sewage being released into a harbour in Hampshire for 49 hours straight, Labour said the government was to blame for letting water companies get away with it and urged ministers to support the amendment.

“People are right to be upset at the dreadful state of England’s rivers,” said Luke Pollard, the shadow environment secretary. “Not one English river is in a healthy condition and there has been zero improvement since 2016.”

He added: “The Conservatives should urgently U-turn on their decision to block the environment bill amendment so that water companies are forced to reduce the amount of sewage they pump into our rivers and seas. The millions which go to shareholders do nothing to help with cleaning up our rivers and seas.”

The environment department said that completely eliminating sewage disposal resulting from storm overflows would be extremely challenging given “the age of our sewerage systems”.

It added there would be new duties on water companies to monitor water quality, come up with a plan for developing systems to decrease the amount of sewage discharged over the next 25 years, and provide real-time information on storm overflows.


Aubrey Allegretti

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Thames Water fined £2.3m for raw sewage pollution incident
Judge says firm’s breach of environmental standards in 2016 amounted to ‘high negligence’

Diane Taylor

26, Feb, 2021 @5:03 PM

Article image
Boss of English water firm fined over sewage says he would swim in rivers
MPs challenge heads of five water companies over ‘routine’ discharges into English waterways

Sandra Laville

13, Oct, 2021 @3:46 PM

Article image
Water firms discharged raw sewage into English waters 400,000 times last year
Data published for first time by Environment Agency shows 27% increase on previous year

Sandra Laville

31, Mar, 2021 @10:34 AM

Article image
Cross-party bloc of MPs back action on sewage discharge into rivers
Private member’s bill seeks to ensure water firms do more to clean up their act on untreated waste

Sandra Laville

09, Jan, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
‘The sea was milky white’: how the Southern Water sewage scandal unfolded
Company has been issued with a huge fine but those affected by its actions are finding it hard to celebrate

Sandra Laville

09, Jul, 2021 @12:39 PM

Article image
Severn Trent Water fined £1.5m for illegal sewage discharges
Firm illegally discharged about 360,000 litres of raw sewage from Worcestershire treatment plants in 2018

Sandra Laville Environment correspondent

08, Dec, 2021 @3:52 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on water pollution: come clean on sewage | Editorial
Editorial: If the water industry is to improve its dismal performance, regulators need to be open with the public


18, Jan, 2022 @6:51 PM

Article image
UK government U-turns on sewage after Tory MPs threaten rebellion
Water companies will have duty to reduce impact of sewage discharges from storm overflows

Helena Horton

26, Oct, 2021 @5:39 PM

Article image
Tories can’t blame the Victorians for sewage pollution | Letter
Letter: Margaret Thatcher’s privatisation of water companies led to huge dividends for shareholders and enormous CEO salaries, but not investment in our water infrastructure, writes Rosie Brocklehurst-Franczak


28, Oct, 2021 @5:12 PM

Article image
MP calls for crackdown on raw sewage discharges in English rivers
Tory Philip Dunne says he wants to ‘introduce water firms to polluter pays’ principle and launches private member’s bill

Sandra Laville Environment correspondent

02, Jul, 2020 @2:00 PM