UK to trial ‘highly protected marine areas’ in win for ocean campaigners

‘Historic’ move to ban destructive fishing methods in five habitats welcomed, but conservationists say change must come faster

The UK government has announced plans to increase protection of wildlife and habitats by banning fishing and other damaging activities from a handful of selected marine sites off the coast of England.

More than 97% of British offshore marine protected areas (MPAs), designed to safeguard habitats and biodiversity, are being dredged and bottom trawled, according to data published by the Guardian. They have long been criticised by conservationists as ineffective “paper parks”.

The pilot scheme of at least five highly protected marine areas (HPMAs), announced by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, was welcomed by the Wildlife Trusts as a “historic” move that would allow degraded underwater habitats to recover and set a new standard for marine protection.

Other groups and conservationists said the proposal, while being a step in the right direction, lacked formal commitment and that the government was not acting fast enough to meet its own targets to protect 30% of oceans by 2030 or to mitigate the climate crisis.

The Blue Marine Foundation said the pilot risks glossing over the “currently lamentable” system of MPAs around the UK. Nearly 40% of the country’s territorial waters are covered by MPAs.

The pilot scheme of HPMAs was the government’s response to the independent Benyon review, published last year, into the case for the special sites to be introduced alongside MPAs in England.

HPMAs are defined as “areas of the sea that allow the protection and recovery of marine ecosystems by prohibiting extractive, destructive and depositional uses and allowing only non-damaging levels of other activities to the extent permitted by international law”. The selected sites would be chosen by Natural England and the Joint Nature Conservation Committee with input from stakeholders. A formal consultation will be held next year.

Puffins on Lundy island in the Bristol Channel, off the coast of Devon
Puffins on Lundy Island, Bristol Channel, a marine protected area. The birds face competition for their staple food, sand eels, from commercial boats, which catch them for use in animal feed. Photograph: Ben Birchall/PA

Charles Clover of the Blue Marine Foundation welcomed the pilot scheme, which he said would show the full potential for the recovery of our seas, provided the selected sites were large enough.

“They will, however, be proposed next year, two years after Lord Benyon’s review, so this is not actually very quick,” Clover said.

“There is also a danger that the creation of a few highly protected areas will distract from the enforcement of the existing network, which is lamentable, with the majority of protected areas – including all of those offshore – allowing damaging fishing methods such as trawling and dredging.”

Jean-Luc Solandt, a specialist in MPAs at the Marine Conservation Society, said: “There is little commitment in it. In order to be ecologically meaningful, they should be offshore, they should be comprehensive. At scale, you would get carbon storage, and you would secure animals in the seabed and in time, would spawn more fish.”

He urged the government to “just get on with the measures and put money into enforcement”.

On World Oceans Day on Tuesday, Greenpeace UK launched Operation Ocean Witness, a six-month operation patrolling Britain’s coasts. The group said its ship, the Sea Beaver, will “patrol the UK’s protected areas off the south coast and do what the government has so far failed to do – protect the UK’s marine protected areas from destructive fishing, a key Brexit promise which has been broken.”

Conservation group Oceana revealed this week that bottom trawlers spent 68,000 hours fishing in UK protected areas that were set up specifically to protect the seabed in 2020.

The short-snouted seahorse
An extremely rare short-snouted seahorse, discovered off the coast of Devon. HPMAs could allow degraded habitats and marine life to recover. Photograph: Russ Shears/National Marine Aquarium

Prof Callum Roberts, a marine conservationist at the University of Exeter and a panel member for the Benyon review, said: “We need to move a lot faster. The UK is leading on their charge to protect 30% of the oceans by 2030, but it is of little value unless the protection of these sites is sufficiently high.

“The question is whether it will slow progress rather than accelerate it. We said in the Benyon report that if the government wants to achieve its ambition of mitigating climate change and protecting biodiversity that it is going to have to go for high protection of large areas.”

Chris Thorne, oceans campaigner at Greenpeace UK, said the scheme was “a small step in the right direction” but would need scaling up.

“Highly protected marine areas will be vital to transforming our existing broken network of marine protected areas, where all forms of destructive fishing are still allowed to take place. They can restore habitats, revive fish populations, breathe life into struggling coastal communities and help us tackle the climate emergency.”


Karen McVeigh

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Auditors decry 'marine protected areas' that fail to protect ocean
Only 1% of 3,000 supposedly ‘protected’ areas in the Mediterranean ban fishing

Karen McVeigh

03, Dec, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
UK fishing licences could be unlawful, says Oceana
Permits for UK and EU vessels will hinder efforts to protect marine life and may break habitats directive, conservation group warns

Karen McVeigh

17, Dec, 2021 @6:20 AM

Article image
‘An invisible killer’: how fishing gear became the deadliest marine plastic
Plastic in the depths: as ‘ghost gear’ chokes the ocean, campaigners call for mandatory measures including buy-back schemes and recycling

Emma Bryce

07, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
World leaders descend on France for ocean summit as Macron puts spotlight on seas
As One Ocean event in Brest aims to deliver ‘blue diplomacy’ in areas from pollution to overfishing, activists warn against ‘bluewashing’

Jon Henley

08, Feb, 2022 @1:09 PM

Article image
EU accused of ‘neocolonial’ plundering of tuna in Indian Ocean
Indian Ocean states say EU pushing weakest conservation efforts for yellowfin tuna while EU ‘distant fleet’ hoovers up the most fish

Karen McVeigh

05, Mar, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
EU slammed over failure to protect marine life from ‘destructive’ fishing
Strict no-take policies urged by scientists, who note there is less protection in 59% of marine protected areas than outside MPAs

Karen McVeigh

12, Sep, 2022 @4:16 PM

Article image
Cop26: Oceanographer Sylvia Earle calls for industrial fishing ban on high seas
Ending unsustainable commercial exploitation of the Earth’s ‘blue heart’ is as vital as curbing fossil fuel use, says pioneering biologist

Dan Collyns

10, Nov, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Tiny Pacific island nation declares bold plan to protect 100% of its ocean
Niue is creating a marine park to protect its waters, an area the size of Vietnam, from illegal fishing

Claire Turrell

30, May, 2022 @6:15 AM

Article image
Latin American countries join reserves to create vast marine protected area
‘Mega-MPA’ in Pacific will protect migratory turtles, whales and sharks from fishing fleets

Dan Collyns in Lima

02, Nov, 2021 @4:22 PM

Article image
Weak controls failing to stop illegal seafood landing on EU plates, investigation shows
EU financial watchdog blames small fines and feeble controls in some states for amount of illegal seafood

Karen McVeigh

27, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM