Extinction Rebellion: rights experts say peaceful protest in UK under threat

Liberty condemns ‘unworkable restrictions, fines and arrests’ used by police to stifle rallies

Civil liberty experts have warned that peaceful protest is under threat in the UK, after the environmental campaigners were targeted with pre-emptive arrest and “unworkable restrictions” were placed on this week’s Extinction Rebellion (XR) demonstrations.

Thousands of people have taken to the streets this week to highlight the escalating climate emergency and demand urgent action from the government.

More than 200 campaigners have so far been arrested. The civil liberties group Liberty said legitimate protest was being hampered by forceful police tactics.

“Despite the fact the police have a duty to facilitate protest, recent weeks have seen unworkable restrictions, fines and arrests all used to deter us from exercising our rights,” said Gracie Bradley, the group’s interim director. “These restrictions are heavy-handed and go too far.”

The Metropolitan police has issued restrictions under section 14 of the Public Order Act that state the XR demonstration in Westminster must take place within the off-road area of Parliament Square between 8am and 7pm.

Protesters said it was an attempt to stifle legitimate protest amid government inaction over the climate emergency.

“I think [the police] are a lot more stringent, and much more feisty this time round … It’s very, very different,” said Alice Huntington, a 48-year-old protester from Bedford.

Extinction Rebellion has organised several events across the UK this week, timed for the return of government officials after the summer break.
Extinction Rebellion has organised several events across the UK this week, timed for the return of government officials after the summer break. Photograph: Sean Smith/The Guardian

“I think it’s disgraceful, it remains to be seen whether this is legal really, but it’s bordering on oppression. We have a legal right to protest, and it feels as though that’s not being allowed.”

Roger Lockey, 65, said he felt the police had ramped up their actions for each of the group’s rebellions over the past two years. “The response is much more robust than in October, they are not spending much time allowing us to block roads but we didn’t expect it to be the same,” he said.

Last week five climate activists from the newly formed Beyond Politics group were arrested and charged with conspiracy to cause criminal damage. An XR co-founder, Roger Hallam, was among them and he and another activist, Diana Warner, remain in prison on remand.

Bradley said: “These tactics are not new but they are damaging as they undermine our right to protest by reframing it as a public nuisance. Peaceful protest is a core pillar of any healthy democracy, and it is vital it is protected whatever the cause.”

The Met declined to comment but directed the Guardian to its website where a statement said the restrictions had been imposed as the protest could “result in serious disruption to the life of the community”.

This week’s demonstrations are the first mass gathering of XR activists since a rebellion planned for earlier this year was cancelled because of the coronavirus pandemic. The group has been warned it could face a £10,000 fine for organising a gathering of more than 30 people under Covid legislation.

In London, XR’s latest rebellion has so far focused on Westminster but activists say they intend to target other institutions responsible for the climate crisis in the days ahead.

On Thursday, several protesters in the centre of the capital glued their hands to the pavement in an attempt to block two entrances to parliament, before being removed and arrested by police.

Nearby, a group of eight Animal Rebellion demonstrators stopped traffic outside the Department of Health and Social Care, blocking the road with a slaughterhouse truck to raise awareness of the link between animal farming and the climate crisis, as well as the risk of pandemics.

“We don’t want to upset people going to work, going about their business, especially with the tough times because of Covid, so we are targeting the main areas of government and organisations we feel are most to blame,” said XR activist Tim Grigg.


Matthew Taylor and Jessica Murray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Battle of Waterloo Bridge: a week of Extinction Rebellion protests
Group’s ongoing peaceful disruption in London is gaining it global attention and new members

Matthew Taylor and Damien Gayle

20, Apr, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion protester convicted of public order offence
Angie Zelter, 68, wanted judge to take ‘urgency of the climate emergency’ into account

Matthew Taylor

25, Jun, 2019 @3:10 PM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion protesters may sue Met as ban ruled unlawful
Section 14 order issued to halt protest across London was not legitimate, high court rules

Damien Gayle and Vikram Dodd

06, Nov, 2019 @10:26 AM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion defies protest ban and targets Google
‘Nurse-in’ held outside company’s offices in protest at funding of climate deniers

Damien Gayle, Vikram Dodd and Jessica Murray

16, Oct, 2019 @5:17 PM

Article image
Why was the Met's Extinction Rebellion protest ban unlawful?
What is the significance of the ruling, and what does it mean for policing future protests?

Vikram Dodd and Matthew Taylor

06, Nov, 2019 @5:16 PM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion plans new London climate crisis shutdowns
Action on capital’s bridges and roads from 7 October expected to be bigger than April protests

Matthew Taylor

23, Sep, 2019 @1:59 PM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion protest ban was 'abuse of power', court hears
Lawyers for climate group in high court to fight police order stopping London protests

Damien Gayle

24, Oct, 2019 @2:49 PM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion activists cleared over London rush hour disruption
Jury decision over 2019 action is the latest acquittal involving a high-profile protest

Matthew Taylor

14, Jan, 2022 @1:52 PM

Article image
Specialist police assigned to Extinction Rebellion rallies
Scotland Yard plans ‘proactive and swift’ counter-action as forces send extra officers to London for October protest

Damien Gayle

02, Oct, 2019 @5:17 PM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion rush-hour protest sparks clash on London Underground
Commuters clash with demonstrators over morning rush hour disruption

Damien Gayle and Ben Quinn

17, Oct, 2019 @5:41 PM