Billion-dollar polar engineering ‘needed to slow melting glaciers’

Underwater sea walls and artificial islands among projects urgently required to avoid devastation of global flooding, say scientists

Scientists have outlined plans to build a series of mammoth engineering projects in Greenland and Antarctica to help slow down the disintegration of the planet’s main glaciers. The controversial proposals include underwater walls, artificial islands and huge pumping stations that would channel cold water into the bases of glaciers to stop them from melting and sliding into the sea.

The researchers say the work – costing tens of billions of dollars a time – is urgently needed to prevent polar glaciers melting and raising sea levels. That would lead to major inundations of low-lying, densely populated areas, such as parts of Bangladesh, Japan and the Netherlands.

Flooding in these areas is likely to cost tens of trillions of dollars a year if global warming continues at its present rate, and vast sea-wall defences will need to be built to limit the devastation. Such costs make glacier engineering in polar regions a competitive alternative, according to the team, which is led by John Moore, professor of climate change at the University of Lapland.

“We think that geoengineering of glaciers could delay much of Greenland and Antarctica’s grounded ice from reaching the sea for centuries, buying time to address global warming,” the scientists write in the current issue of Nature. “Geoengineering of glaciers has received little attention in journals. Most people assume that it is unfeasible and environmentally undesirable. We disagree.”

Ideas put forward by the group specifically target the ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctic because these will contribute more to sea rise this century than any other source, they say. Their proposals include:

• Building a 100-metre high wall on the seabed across a 5km wide fjord at the end of the Jakobshavn glacier in western Greenland. This would reduce influxes of warming sea water which are eroding the glacier’s base;

• Constructing artificial islands in front of glaciers in Antarctica in order to buttress them and limit their collapse as their ice melts due to global warming;

• Circulating cooled brine underneath glaciers such as the Pine Island glacier in Antarctica – in order to prevent their bases from melting and sliding towards the sea.

In each case, the team – which includes scientists in Finland and the US – acknowledges that costs would be in the billions. Construction is also likely to cause considerable disruption. For example, building a dam across the Jakobshavn fjord could affect ecology, fisheries and tourism, and large numbers of workers would have to be shipped in to complete the project.

Similarly, building artificial islands in front of glaciers would mean importing about six cubic kilometres of material, a task that would be immensely difficult in stormy Antarctic waters. And drilling through ice that is kilometres thick to pump down cooled water would also stretch the capabilities of engineers.

However, the team insists that such projects should be carefully assessed now as the likely costs appear to be compatible with those of other large energy and civil engineering works being planned across the globe. The issue is simple, they state: should we spend vast sums to wall off all the world’s coasts, or can we address the problem at its source?

“Potential risks, especially to local ecosystems, need careful analysis,” they conclude. “In our view, however, the greatest risk is doing nothing.”


Robin McKie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Thinning glaciers driving polar ice loss, satellite survey finds
Satellite survey of Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets reveals extensive network of rapidly thinning glaciers that is driving ice loss in the regions

Ian Sample, science correspondent

23, Sep, 2009 @5:05 PM

Article image
Polar ice sheets melting - in pictures

Ice sheets covering Greenland and Antarctica are melting three times faster today than they were in the 1990s, according to a 'definitive' study of satellite data. These pictures show the different ways that melting occurs

29, Nov, 2012 @7:00 PM

Article image
Polar ice caps melting six times faster than in 1990s
Losses of ice from Greenland and Antarctica are tracking the worst-case climate scenario, scientists warn

Damian Carrington Environment editor

11, Mar, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
The glaciers are still shrinking – and rapidly | Jonathan Bamber
Jonathan Bamber: A couple of glaciers shrinking more slowly than expected does not change the irrefutable fact that most are melting rapidly

Jonathan Bamber

15, Apr, 2012 @5:00 PM

Article image
Melting glaciers start countdown to climate chaos

Climate experts warn of effects of disappearing glaciers

Juliette Jowit, environment correspondent

16, Mar, 2008 @2:46 PM

Article image
Scientists fly glacial ice to south pole to unlock secrets of global warming
High on Mont Blanc, huge ice cores are being extracted to help researchers study the alarming rate of glacial melt

Robin McKie Observer science editor

27, Mar, 2016 @12:03 AM

Article image
Drones proving useful in polar regions to study the melting of the ice
Researchers have sent unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) across Antarctica, Greenland and the Svalbard archipelago in Norway

 Suzanne Goldenberg in Kangerlussuaq, Greenland

27, Aug, 2013 @1:36 PM

Speed of melting glaciers' destruction revealed

Further signs of dramatic climate change will be revealed this week with new figures showing that the world's glaciers are continuing to shrink at an alarming rate.

Juliette Jowit, environment editor

28, Jan, 2007 @3:45 PM

Article image
Earth has lost 28 trillion tonnes of ice in less than 30 years
‘Stunned’ scientists say there is little doubt global heating is to blame for the loss

Robin McKie Science editor

23, Aug, 2020 @5:09 AM

Article image
New satellite maps show polar ice caps melting at 'unprecedented rate'
Climate News Network: Scientists reveal Greenland and Antarctica losing 500 cubic kms of ice annually

Tim Radford for the Climate Network, part of the Guardian Environment Network

01, Sep, 2014 @11:34 AM