University tuition fees could be cut to £8,500, say sources

Exclusive: the Treasury is known to be unhappy about the cost of student loans that are never paid back

High-level discussions have been held in Whitehall over controversial proposals to cut university tuition fees from £9,250 to £8,500, sources have told the Guardian.

Officials from No 10, the Treasury and the Department for Education (DfE) are said to have been engaged in “lively” talks about a possible cut to fees but have struggled to thrash out an agreement in time for the chancellor’s spending review.

An announcement on changes to higher education is long overdue following the 2019 Augar review of post-18 education, which recommended tuition fees were cut from £9,250 to £7,500 as part of a radical overhaul of university funding.

According to one source, the Treasury has been pushing for a tuition fee cut to £8,500, which would reduce the amount undergraduates have to borrow and in turn the amount of unpaid debt picked up by the state if they fail to repay the fees within 30 years.

The cut is said to have been opposed by officials at the DfE and No 10, who warned it could have a devastating impact on universities’ finances when they are already under pressure from rising inflation.

Ministers have also been considering cutting the threshold at which graduates begin to repay their tuition and maintenance loans, from just over £27,000 to £23,000 as part of an overhaul of student financing designed to save the Treasury billions of pounds.

Sources suggested there may be little detail on higher education in the chancellor’s spending review on Wednesday, with an announcement at a later date once an agreement has been finalised.

Nick Hillman, director of the Higher Education Policy Institute (Hepi) thinktank and special adviser to the universities minister in 2012 when tuition fees in England were raised to £9,000, said debates in Whitehall on the issue had been lively.

He thought that cuts on the scale recommended by Augar looked increasingly unlikely in the current climate, though a smaller reduction may be more palatable and might have stayed on the table.

“The Augar recommendation of a cut of almost 20%, to £7,500, has come to look implausible, especially in the context of rising inflation, as it would have a dramatic impact on institutional finances,” he wrote in a Hepi blog.

“Imagine being a Tory MP for a red wall seat with a higher education institution that might be pushed to the wall by such a cut: you are not going to hold your seat easily and, therefore, you are not going to support such a change.”

With outstanding student loans reaching £140bn last year, the Treasury is desperate to reduce the cost of the student loan system in England. Hillman later told the Guardian the Treasury was “very, very keen” to save money on higher education.

“As far as I can tell there has been serious thought in the Treasury on the idea of lowering the student repayment threshold. My feeling is there will be no across the board reduction in fees right now.”

Under the current system, graduates repay 9% of their income over the first £26,575. Interest is charged on the outstanding amount but the total remaining including interest is wiped by the government 30 years after graduation.

On other possible higher education developments, Hillman said he was concerned there may be a “slowing down” of the government’s past firm commitment to have 2.4% of UK GDP spent on research and development by 2027.

A government spokesperson said: “The student loan system is designed to ensure all those with the talent and desire to attend higher education are able to do so, while ensuring that the cost of higher education is fairly distributed between graduates and the taxpayer. We do not comment on speculation in the run up to fiscal events.”


Sally Weale and Rowena Mason

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labour considers legal challenge over tuition fees increase
Shadow education secretary says Conservatives are ‘ruling by decree’ after refusal to allow parliamentary vote

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

14, Sep, 2017 @11:51 AM

Article image
Tuition fees: key questions about the government review
What can we expect from the sweeping review into post-18 education and funding?

Sally Weale

19, Feb, 2018 @11:57 AM

Article image
Fall in state-school university entrants since tuition fees hit £9,000
Shadow education secretary Angela Rayner says government ‘slamming the doors’ on talented students on low incomes

Lisa O'Carroll and Carmen Fishwick

03, Aug, 2016 @4:30 PM

Article image
George Osborne pledge to scrap 'very unfair' tuition fees comes to light
Letter written by MP for Tatton in 2003 promises that education ‘will once again be free for students’ under a Tory government

Sally Weale Education correspondent

17, May, 2016 @6:56 PM

Article image
School pupils plan national walkout over tuition fees
Thousands of school and FE students – some as young as 15 – planning sit-ins, demonstrations and occupations in protest at education cuts

Matthew Taylor, Paul Lewis and Bibi van der Zee

19, Nov, 2010 @7:29 PM

Article image
Tuition fees from UK students fail to cover costs of undergraduate courses at UCL
University College London and other institutions must rely on fees from international students, provost says

Richard Adams Education editor

11, Sep, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Michael Gove mounts defence of university tuition fees
Environment secretary says it is fair for graduates to ‘pay something back’, after Damian Green’s call for debate on issue

Heather Stewart

02, Jul, 2017 @10:19 AM

Article image
Tuition fees and student loans stir rift in coalition

Coalition government seeks compromise deal to make higher earning graduates pay more

Jeevan Vasagar and Patrick Wintour

10, Oct, 2010 @11:01 PM

Article image
Student fees: Liberal Democrat MPs braced for 'doorstep' protests

Security at constituency offices stepped up ahead of marches, sit-ins and walkouts planned for Wednesday over proposed rises

Paul Lewis and Matthew Taylor

22, Nov, 2010 @7:50 PM

Article image
May warns universities over high cost of tuition fees
PM’s proposal to cut charges for courses including humanities is branded unworkable by critics

Richard Adams and Peter Walker

18, Feb, 2018 @10:32 PM