Powerhouse Parramatta: three-year battle to save historic Willow Grove ends in union backdown

The 140-year-old homestead will be dismantled brick by brick and relocated, following a deal between the CFMEU and the NSW government

A green ban has been lifted on historic Parramatta homestead Willow Grove, after the New South Wales government struck a deal with the construction union that heritage activists believe took advantage of the Covid-19 crisis evolving in the area.

The dismantling of the Victorian mansion, to make way for the new Powerhouse Parramatta project, has already begun, ending a three-year battle to save the home by a local residents’ group and the area’s Indigenous community.

Willow Grove will be reassembled brick by brick at a yet to be disclosed alternative location, with NSW arts minister Don Harwin saying on Tuesday that a broad-based community reference group would be consulted on the relocation.

“The CFMEU and others who have a clear interest in the future location of Willow Grove will be invited to participate,” Harwin said in a statement.

The Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union placed a green ban on the Willow Grove site in November 2020, to prevent the homestead’s dismantling and relocation.

On Tuesday, the union announced that it had lifted the ban after the NSW Government agreed to save another threatened heritage building on the site, St George’s Terrace, that will now be incorporated into the Powerhouse Parramatta design.

“The union, like the community, had preferred for the [Willow Grove] villa to remain where it is currently,” the union’s statement said.

“The conditions upon which this agreement was reached includes the establishment of a committee to oversight the dismantling, re-location, re-build and re-use of the villa and ongoing maintenance.

“The villa will be kept in public hands, funded and utilised for the community of Parramatta.”

Suzette Meade, the spokesperson for the North Parramatta Residents Action Group, said the community was disappointed by the union’s decision to back down, and accused the NSW government of using the Covid-19 crisis to its advantage.

The Parramatta region is among the 12 local government areas of concern operating under the harshest lockdown restrictions and a 9pm to 5am curfew, due to a surge in Delta cases.

“We’ve been pushed into a Covid situation where we can’t battle the green ban like we could have,” Meade told Guardian Australia.

“The government has chosen the cover of Covid to move in, when it knows nobody wants to break health orders.”

In July, the residents’ action group failed in its bid to stall the removal of Willow Grove, by challenging the validity of Infrastructure NSW’s environmental impact statement for the Powerhouse Parramatta project.

“It’s a bad outcome for Parramatta’s heritage, and sets a dangerous precedent for all heritage,” Meade said.

Contributor

Kelly Burke

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Powerhouse Parramatta: heritage activists lose legal battle but pin hopes on green ban
NSW government wins case to relocate the 140-year-old Willow Grove mansion, but unions vow a green ban will save the site

Kelly Burke

16, Jun, 2021 @2:49 AM

Article image
Revealed: the ‘buried’ Powerhouse Museum report that could have stopped $500m redevelopment
A prominent heritage architect alleges the NSW government terminated his contract and hired another company after he advised that the Ultimo site should be heritage listed

Kelly Burke

25, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Sydney Powerhouse ‘a half-empty neglected mess’ amid redevelopment, museum staff claim
Exclusive: Staff say buildings are not maintained and exhibits have been put at risk during parties, with a former director saying ‘you just don’t believe what you’re looking at’

Kelly Burke

26, Apr, 2023 @1:50 PM

Article image
NSW arts minister defends Powerhouse Parramatta museum days after giving it the green light
NSW government gave the go-ahead for the controversial $950m project amid a parliamentary inquiry into its management of cultural institutions

Kelly Burke

15, Feb, 2021 @5:39 AM

Article image
Powerhouse Parramatta: entertainment centre ‘masquerading’ as a museum has high flood risk, inquiry finds
NSW parliamentary committee releases scathing appraisal of decision to build $1.34bn project on site with ‘very real flood risks’

Kelly Burke

30, Sep, 2022 @10:23 AM

Article image
Parramatta Powerhouse: NSW arts minister dismisses claims $915m museum is being built on a flood zone
Minister grilled over museum’s ability to withstand one-in-100-year flood levels at Parramatta riverbank site

Kelly Burke

23, Feb, 2022 @4:54 AM

Article image
‘Unprecedented’: the fight for Sydney independent bookstore Better Read Than Dead
‘Historic’ agreement reached between staff and management after industrial action sent shockwaves across Australia’s literary community

Walter Marsh

28, Jul, 2021 @2:50 AM

Article image
'Insignificant' building threatens to scuttle $800m Powerhouse Parramatta
The row over Willow Grove continues with two unions imposing a green ban on the heritage relocation and a protest taking place

Kelly Burke

16, Nov, 2020 @10:42 PM

Article image
Property developer Lang Walker throws Powerhouse Parramatta $20m lifeline
The controversial museum in development has received the second largest donation to any western Sydney institution in history

Kelly Burke

22, Oct, 2021 @3:16 AM

Article image
‘Everything had been on hold’: Powerhouse Museum announces program after rocky few years
Chief executive Lisa Havilah has faced a series of setbacks and controversies since stepping up in 2019. Now the Ultimo site can finally unveil what’s next

Kelly Burke

09, Feb, 2021 @4:59 AM