The Guardian view on tuition fees: Labour needs an alternative solution | Editorial

The opposition should fix a system that benefits the highest earners and those with wealthy parents

Since the coalition government raised the cap on tuition fees in 2012, student debt has soared. Due to interest on student loans, many graduates will spend most of their working lives paying off a debt that is greater than what they borrowed. The system has produced intractable problems: students are paying more than ever to get degrees, but many will not get graduate-level jobs. The declining value of tuition fees has left some universities struggling to cover their costs. Increasingly, they rely on recruiting international students and selling expensive master’s courses.

Labour’s initial solution was to scrap tuition fees altogether. Sir Keir Starmer has now reneged on this promise. The question is what will replace it. The current system magnifies inequity. In 2022, the government lowered the threshold at which graduates start repaying their loans to £25,000 and extended it to 40 years. Some low- and middle-income earners, who would have previously only paid back a portion of their debt, will now pay it back in full. The government’s decision to reduce the interest rate on loans was a small improvement. But the setup remains fundamentally unfair as high earners who can pay off their loans quickly will end up repaying less.

It’s a common refrain that student debt is not a cause for worry because it functions like a tax. But taxes do not provoke the gnawing anxiety of compounding interest. Moreover, an estimated 10% of students have rich parents who can pay their fees upfront, thus avoiding any “tax”. One way of making the system more like a tax would be replacing the Student Loans Company with a student funding agency that paid fees to universities, the cost of which would then be taxed back from graduates, with high earners paying a larger contribution. The psychological toll of debt would be diminished, while high-earning graduates – including those whose fees were paid upfront – would pay more of the tax.

This would not be a magic bullet. Taxing graduates who already face steep housing costs is unlikely to be an easy sell. And Sir Keir will need to find a way of increasing university funding. The next government is likely to come under pressure to raise tuition fees. It should avoid doing so. More generous funding from central government would be a better solution – but it would also require an independent funding body, insulated from the political whims of ministers.

There are straightforward ways to make the existing system fairer. Labour should reintroduce maintenance grants for poorer students, which were scrapped in England in 2015. It cannot be right that students from disadvantaged backgrounds have to juggle shift work alongside their studies. Likewise, the opposition could reinstate the bursary for nursing students and exempt graduates who enter occupations such as teaching from paying back their loans in full. It should also commit to changing the interest on student loans to the lower Bank of England base rate.

But a broader rethink ought to be on the cards. Politicians have regarded university as the main lever for social mobility, neglecting other forms of higher and vocational education. Funding has flowed towards students, excluding the 50% of 18- to 30-year-olds who don’t get degrees. A fairer system would shield those on low incomes from the burden of student debt while providing other routes in higher education beyond university degrees. Labour should commit to both.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on universities: a bailout is in all our interests | Editorial
Editorial: By helping to solve a short-term funding crisis, ministers could signal their plans for a national recovery

Editorial

24, Apr, 2020 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on England’s universities: a summer of campus discontent | Editorial
Editorial: Institutions, academics and students are being ill-served by a failing marketised model of higher education

Editorial

07, Aug, 2023 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Open University: issues, not just personalities | Editorial
Editorial: The model of universities as competing in a marketplace for students is the most profound threat to the OU

Editorial

09, Apr, 2018 @5:39 PM

Article image
Labour considers legal challenge over tuition fees increase
Shadow education secretary says Conservatives are ‘ruling by decree’ after refusal to allow parliamentary vote

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

14, Sep, 2017 @11:51 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on academic freedom: ministers’ claims don’t add up | Editorial
Editorial: The government says it is the champion of free speech in universities. But its actions tell another story

Editorial

18, Jul, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on university financing: the making of a market mess | Editorial
Editorial: What the Tories are offering is just an accelerated form of a winner-takes-all marketisation where top performers increasingly capture all the rewards while the rest are left with crumbs

Editorial

19, Feb, 2018 @6:26 PM

Article image
Cutting tuition fees will turn universities into vassals of the state | Simon Jenkins
The tuition fees scheme has failed to balance universities’ books, says Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins

10, Jan, 2019 @6:55 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on university strikes: a battle for the soul of the campus | Editorial
Editorial: The market model in higher education has created an intellectual precariat who are right to fight back

Editorial

25, Nov, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on university strikes: another winter of campus discontent | Editorial
Editorial: The deterioration of pay and conditions has hammered staff morale. Students will feel the effects

Editorial

07, Nov, 2021 @6:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on abolishing student fees: easier to say than to do | Editorial
Editorial: Graduates are seeing few of the benefits they were promised for their £9,000. But free university would mean hard choices

Editorial

09, Jul, 2017 @5:45 PM