Be serious, conservatives. ‘Wokeness’ didn’t cause Silicon Valley Bank’s demise | Tayo Bero

The right is claiming that political correctness – not capitalism – caused this financial catastrophe. Really?

You’d think that witnessing the second-biggest bank failure in US history would be a sobering moment. Since Silicon Valley Bank collapsed on Friday amid a bank run, however, Republicans have instead been twisting themselves into inelegant pretzels to blame “wokeness” for the financial disaster.

For context, SVB – which before it collapsed was the 16th largest bank in the US and worth more than $200bn in assets – proudly reported that aside from 45% of its board being women, it also had “1 Black”, “1 LGBTQ+” and “2 Veterans”. According to Republicans, the bank’s focus on “woke” ideals is what led to its ultimate demise.

“This bank, they’re so concerned with DEI and politics and all kinds of stuff, I think that really diverted from them focusing on their core mission,” the Florida governor Ron DeSantis told Fox News’s Maria Bartiromo.

And according to Donald Trump, Jr: “SVB is what happens when you push a leftist/woke ideology and have that take precedent over common sense business practices. This won’t be the last failure of this nature so long as people are rewarded for pushing this bs.”

This is a ridiculous and senseless leap, even for the right. “Wokeness” has gone from being a hamfisted shorthand for progressive overreach to a convenient – if lazy and illogical – explanation for every catastrophe.

Of course, the actual circumstances that led to the collapse of SVB are of no importance here. Republicans have said little about the higher interest rates brought on by inflation anxiety and bad government bonds that helped SVB speed toward collapse.

They’ve also refused to acknowledge that, as James Downie writes in MSNBC, “SVB might still be around today but for deregulation signed by former President Donald Trump that was supported almost unanimously by Republicans (and even some Democrats).”

Look, it’s not easy to decide who deserves sympathy, or the opposite, in this moment. Nobody wants to “side” with a sinking Silicon Valley institution – we’re supposed to be eating the rich, remember? Still, it’s important to remember that while politicians spin this disaster, workers suffer. Americans will probably go without paychecks; some won’t have have jobs when this shakes out.

According to The Verge, “Some people already know their paychecks will be [disrupted]; a payroll service company called Rippling had to tell its customers that some paychecks weren’t coming on time because of the SVB collapse.”

Most of those people aren’t high-flying Silicon Valley tech founders. For some of these workers, money for rent, groceries, mortgage payments, childcare and other essentials simply isn’t coming.

The right has always been contemptuous of corporate solidarity with marginalized people, so their disdain for SVB’s messaging is unsurprising. In a line that truly sounds like something out of an SNL sketch, Home Depot co-founder Bernie Marcus recently claimed on Fox News that SVB collapsed because the bank was overly concerned with global warming.

“I feel bad for all of these people that lost all their money in this woke bank,” he said. “It’s depressing to me. Who knows whether the justice department would go after them? They’re a woke company, so I guess not. And they’ll probably get away with it.”

The New York Post is also toeing the party line, accusing the bank’s head of risk management of wasting time in “spearheading multiple ‘woke’ LGBTQ+ programs, including a ‘safe space’ for coming-out stories”, even as “the firm raced toward collapse”.

God forbid a financial institution be concerned with anything that even remotely falls outside their mandate of self-enrichment.

SVB was a part of a Silicon Valley economic machine that has helped drive the tech industry’s success for decades. Initial reporting suggests that shoddy practices at the bank brought about its collapse; either way, that doesn’t change the essentially sad story here.

As institutions continue to crumble under the weight of shaky policy and a volatile economy, it’s the people at the very bottom of that food chain who will suffer the most. That’s not because of “wokeness”. It’s just called capitalism.

  • Tayo Bero is a Guardian US contributing writer


Tayo Bero

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Silicon Valley Bank said it was too small to need regulation. Now it’s ‘too big to fail’ | Rebecca Burns and Julia Rock
Student debts and underwater mortgages are private burdens, but corporate losses are matters of urgent public interest

Rebecca Burns and Julia Rock

17, Mar, 2023 @10:15 AM

Article image
There’s a deeper story to Silicon Valley Bank’s failure. What can we learn from it? | Robert Reich
Financial deregulation led to the crash in 2008 and it could again in 2023. It’s time to make banking boring again

Robert Reich

13, Mar, 2023 @1:43 PM

Article image
Silicon Valley Bank: inquiries launched into bank’s collapse and UK arm
Probes announced in the UK and US over failure of California lender as financial markets recovered from Monday’s turmoil

Joanna Partridge and Graeme Wearden

14, Mar, 2023 @6:35 PM

Article image
Big tech has long thought itself above the state. Silicon Valley Bank’s meltdown is stark proof that it isn’t | James Ball
In the US, the Federal Reserve has stepped in to guarantee deposits. The tech sector should realise it can’t go it alone, says James Ball, of The Bureau of Investigative Journalism

James Ball

13, Mar, 2023 @5:54 PM

Article image
Silicon Valley Bank’s parent company files for bankruptcy
SVB Financial Group files for chapter 11 protection but failed Silicon Valley Bank, now under FDIC control, is not part of bankruptcy

Edward Helmore

17, Mar, 2023 @2:53 PM

Article image
TechScape: How Silicon Valley Bank UK was saved
In this week’s newsletter: While its quick slip into financial hardship has left American bankers reeling, its UK division is surprisingly fine. But the tech sector isn’t out of trouble yet

Alex Hern

14, Mar, 2023 @11:45 AM

Article image
Silicon Valley Bank: global banking shares slide as fallout spreads
Stock markets fail to be reassured by Joe Biden’s intervention, as SVB failure is followed by Signature

Richard Partington, Kalyeena Makortoff and Edward Helmore

14, Mar, 2023 @3:36 AM

Article image
Government to meet tech firms following collapse of Silicon Valley Bank UK
Industry leaders expected to call for state intervention to avoid failure of hundreds of UK firms

Kalyeena Makortoff Banking correspondent

11, Mar, 2023 @5:19 PM

Article image
Silicon Valley Bank: why did it collapse and is this the start of a banking crisis?
Until last Friday Silicon Valley Bank was the 16th largest bank in the US, worth more than $200bn

Jonathan Barrett

13, Mar, 2023 @6:42 AM

Article image
Why Silicon Valley Bank was so important to UK tech sector
SVB specialised in high-growth startups, solving problems other lenders would not touch

Alex Hern UK technology editor

12, Mar, 2023 @5:33 PM