£45 for a YouTuber’s energy drink? The age of the scammer is truly dead | Amelia Tait

Post-Fyre Festival, Caroline Calloway and Anna Delvey, being scammed by your idols now has currency

Some sentiments are so obvious that they should never need to become sentences, but: £45 is too much to pay for a can of pop. I recently walked into my local sweetshop with a mind to buy some candy sticks when I stopped to marvel at a humming fridge lined with pink, orange and blue cans. Each can contained the energy drink Prime, which was “created by” YouTubers Logan Paul and KSI in 2022. And each bore a pale yellow price tag reading “£44.99”.

You may be surprised to hear that this is a bargain. One shop in Yorkshire has been selling bottles of Prime for £100 each, while sold eBay listings show that someone, somewhere paid £351 for a single grape-flavoured drink. While the beverage retails for just £1.99 in Asda, stampedes and scuffles have resulted in shortages – hence the price gouging. On 7 January, KSI urged his adoring fans not to pay over the odds for Prime, screaming into his front-facing camera: “Oh my God, NOOO!” and “Stop buying it at these prices!”

KSI, it seems, does not want his fans to be scammed – but what does that matter, when they themselves are more than happy to be? For the past three years, media outlets have confidently declared that we’re living in the golden age of the scammer, as evidenced by the fact that Anna Delvey or Billy McFarland’s Fyre festival need no introduction. Yet I would now like to equally confidently declare that the age of the scammer is over – for in a time of unadulterated celebrity worship, far too many people are willing to be scammed.

In 2019, internet personality Caroline Calloway became a key figure of the scammer era when she sold tickets to $165 (£133) creativity workshops, then failed to book venues to host them in. Two years earlier, the Instagrammer withdrew from a $500,000 book deal with Flatiron Books after failing to write her promised memoir; she subsequently had to pay her advance back. Ever since, Calloway has aggressively leaned into her reputation as a swindler: since 2020, she has been accepting $25 (£20) pre-orders for a new book, Scammer, which has not yet materialised (customers are told “the art will be ready when it’s ready” on her official site). In 2021, Calloway began selling a homemade skincare blend named Snake Oil for $75 (£60) a bottle.

Billy McFarland leaves federal court after his arraignment in New York on charges of scheming to defraud investors in his company, Fyre Media.
Billy McFarland leaves federal court after his arraignment in New York on charges of scheming to defraud investors in his company, Fyre Media. Photograph: Mary Altaffer/AP

Anyone who buys from Calloway knows what they’re getting – sometimes nothing. Throughout January, the influencer has been selling signed tarot cards for $15 a card and fans have leapt at the chance to part with their money. “When Caroline Calloway presented me with an opportunity to get scammed by THE Caroline Calloway, I PayPal-ed her $15,” one TikTok user named Kressie said. When Kressie discovered that the tarot card she received was unsigned, she was delighted: “I have to respect the grind! She got me!”

In our era of constant content creation, and in the wake of endless TV shows about scammers (Netflix has released shows about Anna Delvey and Billy McFarland, while Disney+ has a show about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos), being scammed ironically now has currency. Scammers no longer take your money and give you nothing: instead, they give you the opportunity to make a TikTok, Instagram post or YouTube video about your experiences.

The death of scamming is linked to another phenomenon, which is that it is no longer possible for celebrities to “sell out”. While creatives were once scorned for linking themselves to big brands and shilling products, hustle culture means that fans are delighted to see their heroes earn big – at times, even declaring they’ll buy a product they don’t want or need just to “support” a celebrity. On TikTok, users joke about the expressions children make when they finally get their hands on Prime, taste it, and declare it delicious despite visibly looking unimpressed.

But it’s not just YouTubers and influencers who have the sway to lure willing victims – after all, numerous parents enrolled their children into Kanye West’s $15,000-a-year school despite the fact that was not accredited (following West’s antisemitic social media posts, the Donda Academy is now shut until September). Families reportedly had to sign non-disclosure agreements, so very little is known about the school’s curriculum – but how much do you have to love a celebrity to send your children off to chant in what appears to be a basement, dressed in all black, knowing they could emerge with zero academic credentials?

If you don’t mind, or even actively seek out, being scammed by your idol, then fundamentally you haven’t been scammed. The scam era is officially over – phone fraud hasn’t gone away, obviously, or those texts from fake delivery men saying you owe them £1.99, but the era of sexy scams, celebrity scams, seven-part series scams needs to be put to bed. They no longer exist – at least, not in a way that deserves the four-letter word. In the coming months, it’s likely you’ll read countless more stories about celebrity scammers. But when you read them, ask yourself one question: has anyone actually been scammed?

  • Amelia Tait is a freelance features writer

  • Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.


Amelia Tait

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Now we know for sure that big tech peddles despair, we must protect ourselves | Zoe Williams
After the Molly Russell case, there can be no doubt: our anger must be put to good use, says Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

07, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
'Self-deprecating' black Tiktokker agency challenges prejudices in Italy
Social media influencers of African origin have banded together, using ‘fun activism’ to make their voice heard

Angela Giuffrida

05, Mar, 2021 @12:11 PM

Article image
Social media sites warned over risky investment offers
City watchdog flags up platforms such as YouTube and TikTok in promoting investments to inexperienced consumers

Rupert Jones

20, Apr, 2021 @5:26 PM

Article image
Instagram influencers show how ads have changed. We need to catch up | Suzanne Moore
If it’s hard to decide what constitutes an ad now, it’s because YouTube vloggers and the Kardashians changed the rules, says the Guardian columnist Suzanne Moore

Suzanne Moore

17, Aug, 2018 @12:05 PM

Article image
Your online identity is precious. Here’s how to protect it | Holly Brockwell
People who would never leave their front door unlocked can be dangerously lax about their online security, says Holly Brockwell, freelance technology journalist and editor of Gadgette

Holly Brockwell

28, Aug, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Finally, the Wagatha Christie battle is over. But did anyone really win? | Zoe Williams
The appetite to watch women fighting is infinite, and Vardy v Rooney has given us enough material to keep going for decades, says Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

29, Jul, 2022 @1:11 PM

Article image
Be warned: for influencers, social justice is no more than a branding device | Rachel Connolly
Social media stars’ low-risk, high-gain activism has become a core part of how they attract attention, says journalist Rachel Connolly

Rachel Connolly

09, Feb, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Don't know your James Charles from Zoella? Get with YouTube celebrity culture | Amelia Tait
When a YouTuber brings Birmingham to a standstill, don’t pride yourself on ignorance, says journalist Amelia Tait

Amelia Tait

29, Jan, 2019 @10:04 AM

Article image
Why is Kim Kardashian famous? You asked Google – here’s the answer | Eleanor Morgan
Every day millions of internet users ask Google life’s most difficult questions, big and small. Our writers answer some of the commonest queries

Eleanor Morgan

20, Apr, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Daisy Ridley is right to quit social media. Actors should be seen and not followed | Ryan Gilbey
For actors there are no downsides to leaving Instagram and the like. A star should radiate mystique, not false bonhomie and complaints about queues for the toilet, writes film critic Ryan Gilbey

Ryan Gilbey

07, Dec, 2017 @12:36 PM