The floundering of GB News and Talk TV reveals a dark truth about the mainstream media | Nesrine Malik

The only reason fringe channels are failing to flourish in Britain’s rightwing media swamp is because it is already full

It couldn’t have happened to a nicer channel. GB News, it appears, has lost half its value since it launched last year. Shareholder Discovery sold its stake in the channel in August, with accounts lodged after the sale showing that its 25% share of the company, bought initially for £20m, was offloaded for just £8m. One of the buyers, Vote Leave backer Sir Paul Marshall, said of his participation in the new funding round: “As investors we’re proud of what GB News is doing for media plurality in the UK, bringing fresh perspectives to the national conversation.” One of the channel’s “fresh perspectives” on the coronavirus vaccine is currently being investigated by media regulator Ofcom.

If ploughing more cash into a channel where the average daily view is less than a minute sounds like a waste of money, then spare a thought for those paying for Piers Morgan’s reported £50m deal with Talk TV. Ratings have been comically low. “Morgan has gone from Good Morning Britain to good evening no one,” said Slate. Other big names have not fared better. Earlier this year, Tom Newton Dunn did not register a single viewer for half of his evening broadcast. Having positioned themselves as challengers to mainstream “woke” channels catering to a limited viewership, both channels have now pivoted to telling us that they are in fact not in the business of “linear TV” at all, conjuring a new world of “content TV” in which no one actually watches the telly any more and instead scrolls through clips of it on social media. Except those who don’t watch television channels any more don’t want to follow them on social media either. Talk TV has 83,000 followers on TikTok, less than your average “this is what I ate in a day” account.

The repositioning away from ratings to views, despite the former securing advertising, suggests that the entire model of rightwing TV is adjusting its course from commercial viability to sustainable loss, with the payoff being prominence in the discourse. The bad news is that this model is floundering not because there’s no appetite for inflammatory, opinion-based news. It’s because there’s too much. In fact, the appetite is so huge that it feeds off, and is fed by, the very mainstream media that these channels thought they were differentiating themselves from. The rightwing media swamp isn’t any less fertile. It’s full.

Piers Morgan interviewing Donald Trump on Talk TV, April 2022
Piers Morgan interviewing Donald Trump on Talk TV, April 2022. Photograph: Piers Morgan uncensored/Talk TV

Just look around you. If you’re after some immigrant-bashing, then some of our tabloids are the best in the business. So good, in fact, that they have received international attention, condemned by the UN for, in the case of a column in the Sun by Katie Hopkins in which she referred to migrants as “cockroaches”, reflecting a “nasty underbelly of racism that is characterising the migration debate in an increasing number of EU countries”. If you are in the market for some incitement against civil servants, judges and MPs on behalf of “the will of the people”, the Daily Mail has you covered.

If you are an altogether more refined reader, the broadsheets can supply upmarket outrage in slicker form. The Times will do an “audit” of UK universities by submitting almost 300 freedom of information requests, find that a grand total of two books had been removed from reading lists, and serve you an“exclusive” splash saying that “universities have started removing books from reading lists to protect students from ‘challenging’ content”. See what they did there? Technically true, your honour.

And in any case, who needs TV debates when you have phone-in radio? The thriving medium that gave Hopkins, Maajid Nawaz, Julia Hartley-Brewer and of course Nigel Farage a platform.

There is no refuge from the swamp: its waters lap at your feet even if you seek higher ground. That last bastion of “impartiality”, the BBC, has stripped the notion of all responsibility and reduced it to gullibility, treating almost all positions as if they were of equal value, and allowing funded interests to promote their own version of reality. The result is a capture by unvetted rightwing thinktanks and the indulging of climate-crisis deniers.

But it is the revolving door of “talent” that is the biggest giveaway of a wider ideological consensus. People travel, without missing a beat, between these media houses, between publishing invectives in the Sun to literary supplements, or between the BBC and GB News, and then to Downing Street.

It’s all one ecosystem, one that is constantly disguising its uniformity with claims of censorship and cancellation, with figures such as John Cleese casting themselves as rebellious mischief-makers in a bland neutered monoculture. They’re right about the monoculture bit, but it’s not “woke” or impotent. It is a raging furnace of rightwing provocation, spitting out lies, fear and spite, shaping a political culture of miserliness and insularity. People look to the media not just for information but for a moral compass, and that needle is currently pointing in one direction: away from a world of equality and shared resources.

The result is that calamitous rightwing rule is promoted, and sustained way past its natural expiry point, even as the doom-laden scenarios the Tories predict under a Labour government arrive on their watch. The lights will literally go off, and the Telegraph will tell you that power cuts are character-building.

So GB News’s value can halve or be decimated for all it matters. It is merely another home to the noxious positions and people that already populate our politics, rather than the augur of a radical new frontier I feared it had the potential to be. Its difficult task lay not in challenging the mainstream media, but in significantly differentiating itself from it.

  • Nesrine Malik is a Guardian columnist

Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.


Nesrine Malik

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
GB News may be useless at news – but it’s Britain’s top channel for luvvie drama | Marina Hyde
Andrew Neil’s departure from the station set up as a scourge of the ‘London media’ marks a new high in TV news flouncing, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

14, Sep, 2021 @2:15 PM

Article image
GB News is no joke, despite the risible start | Nesrine Malik
As much as it might like to, the left can’t pretend the channel doesn’t exist, says Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

Nesrine Malik

21, Jun, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Delusional broadcast disorder has claimed its latest victim: John Cleese | Marina Hyde
The great affliction of our age makes men believe they have been cancelled by the BBC while they are literally on the BBC, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

11, Oct, 2022 @1:14 PM

Article image
Goodbye to the age of rage: why Piers Morgan’s outrage journalism is flopping | John Harris
With sobering crises like Ukraine and the cost of living, it’s no surprise the appetite for venting behind a microphone is waning, says Guardian columnist John Harris

John Harris

22, May, 2022 @11:15 AM

Article image
Is condemning GB News before it's started a good use of the left's energy? | Zoe Williams
It might seem like the last thing we need, but if the channel avoids fake news we can live with it, says Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

09, Feb, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
The BBC news channel revamp has been a PR disaster – but it also makes perfect sense | Jane Martinson
The merger of channels is a cost-cutting measure that has provoked derision and anger. But changes needed to happen, says Guardian columnist Jane Martinson

Jane Martinson

06, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
How can the news media reach young people? Tell their stories | Leah Boleto
Newsround, the children’s news programme I present, has adapted as British kids switch from TV to social media, says CBBC Newsround presenter Leah Boleto

Leah Boleto

01, Apr, 2019 @12:07 PM

Article image
We should be free to talk about racism without being penalised | Afua Hirsch
Historian David Olusoga talked of being isolated and devalued in the TV industry. It shouldn’t have to be such an act of courage, says Guardian columnist Afua Hirsch

Afua Hirsch

27, Aug, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
The BBC’s Bodyguard is becoming a ‘Netflix Original’. So who gets the credit? | Sarah Hughes
The streaming giant is so dominant, it can blur the line between shows it creates and shows it acquires, says Guardian TV writer Sarah Hughes

Sarah Hughes

20, Sep, 2018 @12:25 PM

Article image
Mock the Week was never part of the culture wars. We only fought for laughs | Dara Ó Briain
If there’s one lesson I draw looking back on it all, it’s this: people have taken our nonsense waaaayyyy too seriously, says comedian Dara Ó Briain

Dara Ó Briain

06, Aug, 2022 @8:00 AM