Angela Rayner called Tory ministers ‘scum’ – and now they’re weaponising it | Zoe Williams

It is entirely un-newsworthy for people on opposing sides to dislike one another. But that doesn’t stop the language of fake hurt and victimhood being ceaselessly deployed

I went to sleep thinking about Angela Rayner. (I think I even dreamed about her, but I would never burden you with that.) Multiple front pages had a picture of her at Labour conference smoking, which would be the most subversive thing about her, were it not for her calling Boris Johnson “scum” at a fringe meeting.

So many conversations have ricocheted off her speech: is “scum” the authentic language of the British working class, or is that insulting to working-class people? (A side question: I would always say “scumbag”, which is much more affectionate, but why? It is merely a bag full of scum. Talking specifically about Johnson, on the other hand, I would be much more likely to reach for a swear word.)

Isn’t prejudice against Etonians, when you really drill into it, as bad as racism and misogyny? (That was from the Spectator, and is the single best argument against saying these things in public. If you ever find yourself even scoping in your head the parameters of an argument with someone who thinks Etonophobia is as bad as racism, that is a catastrophic waste of both your own and the world’s time.) How can Rayner call the prime minister racist or misogynistic, Nick Robinson wanted to know of the shadow chancellor, Rachel Reeves, on the radio on Sunday morning, when he has an Asian home secretary and a female foreign secretary? It was a question so dumb that it got me out of bed, though to be fair, there was also someone at the door.

Why is everyone else in the shadow cabinet, right up to the leader, finding it so incredibly hard to say the obvious thing: Johnson can probably cope with the fact that Rayner doesn’t like him. If she said it to his actual face, he could probably still cope. I know this because I met him once, in a bus hangar in Flitwick, Bedfordshire, where he was promoting the new Routemaster. Some other time, we can talk about that bus, and whether, in its vanity, drummed-up nostalgia and huge cost, it was a harbinger of things to come.

Johnson said to me: “Aren’t you the person who wrote all those horrible things about me?” The childish cadence is making this sound invented, but that is genuinely how he speaks, as the luckless dignitaries of the United Nations recently discovered. I had, indeed, before the 2008 mayoral election, written a horrible thing, detailing the many reasons why I, too, believe him to be racist, misogynistic and homophobic. I didn’t have anything concrete; it’s not as if he has a criminal conviction for hate crime. I was just going by all the racist, sexist and homophobic things he had said. Anyway, I shrugged, and said: “Well, I disagree with you,” and he shrugged back, and drove off at a stately pace. His parting words were: “Beep beep.”

But we’re not in the politics of adults, where it is entirely expected and un-newsworthy for people on opposing sides to dislike one another. We’re in what the journalist and disability campaigner Frances Ryan calls “civility politics”, where you can cause people calculable and demonstrable pain and hardship, deliberately (with a £20 universal credit cut, for instance) or by accident (with incompetent decision-making) – but if someone calls you “scum”, they’re the ones destroying the very fabric of society.

It’s the same culture in which someone can stand on a global platform while complaining they have been cancelled; in which Brexiters, five years after their victory, are still whining about the remainiac media. The language of fake hurt and ersatz victimhood is ceaselessly deployed; nobody really swallows it, but it’s not there to be swallowed. It’s there to undermine the idea that there could ever be a real victim, or genuine hurt; it’s there to make empathy a moot point, so you can get on with the politics of not feeling any. So no, Rayner is not the problem. The word “scum” is not the problem. The smoking, though, Ang: I believe it is actually quite bad for you.

• Zoe Williams is a Guardian columnist


Zoe Williams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
When Angela Rayner told the FT about her ‘boob job’, she was telling the rightwing press to bring it on | Zoe Williams
No disclosure goes unpunished by the tabloids if you are a Labour politician - and the typical defence is to say nothing. The deputy leader has a different strategy, writes Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

14, Nov, 2022 @7:33 PM

Article image
The US may not share Britain’s obsession with class – but it hates women every bit as much | Arwa Mahdawi
Kamala Harris and Elizabeth Warren have an unpleasant amount in common with Angela Rayner, writes Arwa Mahdawi. Female politicians are routinely belittled on both sides of the Atlantic

Arwa Mahdawi

27, Apr, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Angela Rayner apologises for calling Tory MP 'scum' in Commons
Labour deputy leader made comment during speech by Chris Clarkson

Simon Murphy Political correspondent

21, Oct, 2020 @6:41 PM

Article image
Why do so many Tory ministers have giant union jacks in their lounge? | Zoe Williams
Keir Starmer may be planning a ‘patriotic’ rebrand for Labour, but I’m more curious about the government’s approach to the flag, writes Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

14, Feb, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Angela Rayner smear puts Tory party ugliness on show | Letters
Letters: Paul McGilchrist, Nick Sinclair, Ian Ferguson and Neil Hutton on the misogyny and contempt revealed by a newspaper report about Labour’s deputy leader


26, Apr, 2022 @5:16 PM

Article image
Angela Rayner stands by labelling of Tories as ‘scum’
Labour deputy leader refuses to say sorry, describing terms as ‘street language’ of her working-class roots

Rowena Mason Deputy political editor

26, Sep, 2021 @5:43 PM

Article image
PM's single mother remarks 'disgusting', says Angela Rayner
Shadow education secretary says comments reveal Tory stigmatisation of working class

Kate Proctor Political correspondent

06, Dec, 2019 @6:05 PM

Article image
What do Boris Johnson and other Tory leaders really need? Far less self-confidence | Arwa Mahdawi
Impostor syndrome is always described as a bad thing, but the UK’s political class would genuinely benefit from self-doubt, writes Guardian columnist Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

23, Mar, 2021 @1:40 PM

Article image
Helping Mum canvass for Labour in the 80s, I think I actually turned people Tory | Zoe Williams
I’m unconvinced that knocking door to door works in bagging undecided voters, says the Guardian columnist Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

26, Apr, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Angela Rayner demands detailed answers on Boris Johnson’s refurb
Labour’s deputy leader says it is ‘scarcely believable’ PM did not know who funded work on flat

Clea Skopeliti

29, May, 2021 @4:00 PM