The Guardian view on the Aukus defence pact: taking on China | Editorial

The agreement between the US, UK and Australia strengthens old ties as a new era unfolds in the Indo-Pacific region

No one – least of all Beijing – believes the denials. The new defence pact between the US, UK and Australia is unmistakably aimed at containing China. The question is how substantive it will prove to be. The initial project – Canberra’s acquisition of nuclear-powered submarines, with Washington and London’s help – is prompted in part by growing Australian frustration over its troubled contract for French-made vessels. But it opens the way for greater military cooperation and is to be underpinned by wide-ranging collaboration on areas such as cyber-security, artificial intelligence and quantum computing, which China is pursuing intensively.

Joe Biden appears to be realising Barack Obama’s pledge of a pivot to Asia, with US capacity freed by withdrawal from Afghanistan, and China’s behaviour ringing alarm bells internationally. The Aukus pact binds the UK and Australia more closely to the US position, and should augment US military power in the region (though France, Europe’s most significant Indo-Pacific player, is openly furious). Though Boris Johnson has highlighted the promise of UK jobs, a White House official described the deal as a “downpayment on global Britain”.

Three years ago, Australia’s prime minister, Scott Morrison, insisted Canberra need not choose between Beijing and Washington. Now he seems to have judged that China has made the choice for him, given the punishing trade war, the treatment of Australian citizens, mammoth hikes in military spending (albeit from a lower base than the US) and its broader behaviour. Donald Trump’s presidency gave China an opportunity to strengthen relationships with US allies; the pandemic gave it an opportunity to rebalance towards cooperation. Instead, it accelerated course with Wolf Warrior diplomacy, trade pressure, clashes with India and more frequent incursions into Taiwan’s air defence identification zone, and upped the ante in the South China Sea.

The result is growing coordination among anxious nations. The anglophone “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing nations have increased cooperation; Australia and the US have worked more closely with India and Japan in the “Quad”; the UK invited India, South Korea and Australia (as well as South Africa) to the G7. At US prompting, Nato has taken a stronger line on China.

A firm and unified response to China’s actions by democratic nations is both sensible and desirable. Whether the new pact will restrain it – or prompt it to boost its military even further, pursue closer relations with Russia, and intensify other forms of pressure – remains to be seen. Beijing’s attacks on “cold war mentality” are about perception, not just rhetoric. This week we learned that the top US military officer reportedly called his Chinese counterpart fearing that Beijing believed the Trump administration was preparing to attack. Mr Biden may believe he can pursue “extreme competition”, confronting Beijing in some areas and engaging it in others, but China clearly disagrees. It sent a junior official to meet John Kerry for climate change talks. Reportedly, Xi Jinping did not respond to the president’s proposal of a face-to-face summit.

While many herald Aukus as a momentous step, this is not a treaty but a statement of intent, with even the details of the submarine agreement 18 months away. Setting aside that project (and the real concerns it might open the door to proliferation), we cannot yet tell how significant the pact will be. Faith in US commitments is shakier in the wake of Mr Trump. What is certain is that this further sharpens the divide between China and the west.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Aukus pact: UK and US battle to contain international backlash
Nuclear submarine deal with Australia draws criticism from allies and China amid fears of conflict

Dan Sabbagh, Julian Borger, Helen Davidson and Angelique Chrisafis

16, Sep, 2021 @7:48 PM

Article image
Making waves in the Pacific: how Boris Johnson’s Global Britain went rogue
Defence pact with Australia and the US increases chance of confrontation with China and spurs nuclear proliferation

Simon Tisdall

19, Sep, 2021 @6:30 AM

Article image
Morrison expects US to ramp up military presence in region as China attacks ‘irresponsible’ defence pact
Beijing denounces Aukus pact, raising question of nuclear proliferation, as Morrison expects a greater US military presence in Indo-Pacific and deeper UK defence ties

Daniel Hurst and Katharine Murphy

16, Sep, 2021 @10:34 AM

Article image
The Aukus pact is a sign of a new global order | Rana Mitter
The deal has upset China, but it also binds the US into European security, in a world where Nato may be less relevant, says China expert Rana Mitter

Rana Mitter

17, Sep, 2021 @2:55 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on cyberwar: an urgent problem | Editorial
Editorial: The internet is now used as a low-level weapon of war. How should Britain best defend itself?


22, Jan, 2018 @5:42 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Britain and China: fasten your seatbelts | Editorial
Editorial: The UK and other countries are reshaping their approach to Beijing. It’s going to be bumpy


09, Jul, 2020 @5:57 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the defence budget: be realistic | Editorial
Editorial: The military has suffered from austerity and the world is a dangerous place, but that doesn’t mean the case for higher defence spending needs no interrogation


27, Jun, 2018 @5:31 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on post-Covid recovery: powered by the state not the market | Editorial
Editorial: The Thatcherite wing of the Conservative party desires a restoration of ideas whose time has come and gone


09, Aug, 2021 @6:02 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the G7 Afghanistan talks: desperate damage limitation | Editorial
Editorial: Lack of planning and coordination has left the west scrambling to do the right thing


23, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Biden, China and Europe: the US is back – for now | Editorial
Editorial: Democratic unity is welcome against authoritarian might. That doesn’t mean signing up to everything on the US agenda


15, Jun, 2021 @6:25 PM