Taxes on electric vehicles will slow Australia’s progress. It’s not complicated | Richard Denniss

While most of the world offers incentives to people buying EVs, our government hands out subsidies for utes

As a rule of thumb, it’s good economics and good politics to tax the things you want less of and subsidise the things you want more of. That is why the Australian government raises so much tax from alcohol and tobacco, and why the Victorian government’s electric vehicle tax is the dumbest idea since Tony Abbott made the Queen’s husband a knight.

But it’s not just the Victorian government that’s waging an unwinnable war against new technology. While most of the world is offering financial subsidies and incentives such as free parking to people who buy electric cars, the Morrison government is spending billions of dollars on subsidies for the enormous twin cab utes that now dominate Australian car sales while our local councils offer free and convenient parking for the same behemoths.

At the same time Scott Morrison is saying that Australia is “leading the world” in the transition away from fossil fuels, all of the top 10 company cars in Australia are twin cab utes or so-called “sports utility vehicles”, and Australia’s emissions from transport are, unsurprisingly, trending up, not down. Thank god for accounting tricks.

It’s no accident that inefficient and emission-intensive twin cab utes are taking over Australia’s streets. It’s the direct result of our tax system, our planning system and the way that governments use policy to send signals to voters rather than solve substantive issues. Let’s start with the tax system.

Forget the “women’s budget”, one of the big announcements in the latest budget was the $17bn extension of the “instant asset write off”. “UTE BEAUTY” screamed the Daily Telegraph front page the day after the budget. While few Australians understand the new instant asset write off provisions in our tax system, I assure you, car salespeople do.

Daily Telegraph front page Wednesday 12 May 2021
The Daily Telegraph’s front page on Wednesday 12 May 2021. Photograph: Daily Telegraph

If you own a small business, be it as a plumber or a graphic designer, and you want to buy an enormous twin cab ute, you can deduct the entire cost of that vehicle, up to $150,000, against your income from that year in order to calculate your taxable income. If you earned $100,000 per year from your graphic design business and bought a $150,000 ute, then for tax purposes your income (loss) would be -$50,000, so you wouldn’t have to pay any income tax at all. Importantly, the $150,000 cap only applies to “commercial vehicles”, which means while you can drop off a USB drive to your customer at a cafe in a subsidised 2.5 tonne diesel ute, you can’t get the same tax breaks for a Tesla.

It gets better. Parking in Australian cities is both hard to find and expensive to pay for but for those driving commercial vehicles, many of the most convenient parking spots are not just reserved for your preferred vehicle but provided for free. In the words of the New South Wales government: “Vehicles primarily designed to carry goods can stop in a loading zone to drop off or pick up goods.”

For most people, the twin cab ute solves tax and regulatory problems, not transport problems. The Australian tax rules treat vehicles that can carry more than one tonne of cargo quite differently than they treat other vehicles. But – to be clear – the vehicle doesn’t have to actually carry more than one tonne of cargo to get the tax breaks or the free parking, it just needs to have the capacity.

Which brings me to the politics. While many mock the absurdity of the prime minister’s pre-election comments about utes, electric vehicles and the ruination of the weekend, few see the political genius at play. In an era where a lot of people never watch the news, let alone analyse policy, the PM wanted an easy way to signal that he was on the side of people who own utes, not the people who drive EVs, for the simple reason that a lot more swinging voters drive the former. Not only did it work, but his strategy both anticipated (and required) the outrage of progressives. Mission accomplished.

Countries like Norway have been offering financial subsidies and incentives like preferential parking to electric vehicles for years and, in turn, they now have more electric vehicles on the road than they do petrol and diesel powered cars. Australia, on the other hand, has been offering big tax breaks and preferential parking for big utes, and guess what? It has worked. The average weight of the Australian car fleet is rising, which inevitably means Australia’s transport emissions are as well.

The Victorian government argues that it has to impose a new tax on electric vehicles because drivers of those vehicles don’t pay fuel excise, which makes about as much sense as taxing nicotine patches on the basis that those giving up smoking aren’t paying tobacco excise any more. If Australia wants to actually transition away from fossil fuels we need to stop using so many fossil fuels. Subsidies for solar panels have helped us achieve that goal. Subsidies for giant utes have slowed our progress, and so too will taxes on electric vehicles. It’s not complicated.

• Richard Denniss is chief economist at independent thinktank the Australia Institute


Richard Denniss

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Victoria’s electric vehicle tax faces high court challenge
Case, launched by two Melbourne EV drivers, will argue the levy is unconstitutional and ‘similar to the GST which is a commonwealth tax’

Lisa Cox

16, Sep, 2021 @10:53 AM

Article image
'The chips have been placed': experts weigh in on the Australian budget 2020 | Danielle Wood, Cassandra Goldie, Terry Slevin, Erwin Jackson, Andrew Norton
This year’s budget will have far-reaching implications for the economy, social services, public health, the environment and higher education

Danielle Wood, Cassandra Goldie, Terry Slevin, Erwin Jackson, Andrew Norton

07, Oct, 2020 @12:45 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison is the accidental architect of a carbon tax – whether he likes it or not | Richard Denniss
While Australia sticks to accounting tricks, calls by other countries are growing to impose a carbon price on our exports

Richard Denniss

16, Jun, 2021 @1:31 AM

Article image
Labor’s electric vehicle policy drives Australia forward – but not far | Adam Morton
While committing to a fuel-efficiency standard is an important step, a shift to clean cars alone won’t get us where we need to be

Adam Morton

19, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Australia could become a net negative emissions economy. The technology already exists | Frank Jotzo
To understand our opportunities and pressure points we need an open, inclusive, genuine process

Frank Jotzo

01, Nov, 2021 @11:36 PM

Article image
While the government is in denial, the states are making staggering progress on renewable energy | Tristan Edis
State governments seem frustrated with the Coalition – but we are closer to 100% renewables than you think

Tristan Edis

02, Jul, 2019 @12:03 AM

Article image
Labor urged to halve $8bn a year in fuel tax credits for trucks and heavy vehicles
Reforming scheme would shrink budget deficit and help Australia hit net zero emissions by 2050, Grattan Institute says

Elias Visontay Transport and urban affairs reporter

05, Feb, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Australian states were warned road user tax on electric vehicles could discourage its uptake
Leaked report says tax would slow emissions cuts, with South Australia and Victoria warned before they announced plan to introduce charge

Adam Morton Environment editor

08, Dec, 2020 @9:41 PM

Article image
Make no mistake – Labor and the Coalition have starkly different climate policies | Thom Woodroofe
Both sides have committed to net zero emissions but voters will hopefully reward the one that knows how to get there

Thom Woodroofe

21, Jan, 2022 @3:27 AM

Article image
Labor now has the chance to act with gusto on climate policy | Frank Jotzo
Australia needs a far more ambitious agenda than the one Anthony Albanese took to the election

Frank Jotzo

23, May, 2022 @3:49 AM