Don’t blame men for the climate crisis – we should point the finger at corporations | Arwa Mahdawi

Male spending – on petrol and meat – is apparently worse for the environment than women’s. But it’s the system, not individuals, that needs to change

Sorry, boys, but it’s all your fault. Melting ice caps, flash floods, rising sea levels: men are to blame for the lot of it. Please don’t drown the messenger, I’m just relaying the results of a Swedish study that found that men’s spending habits cause 16% more climate-heating emissions than women’s. The biggest difference seems to be that men spend more money on petrol. Another big difference: the men surveyed bought more meat than women. So this is the way the world ends, eh? Not with a bang, but with blokes eating too many burgers.

I don’t know how many studies published in the Journal of Industrial Ecology go viral, but this paper has had an enormous amount of traction. Of course, this is largely because its findings leant themselves to delicious clickbait such as Men Are Worse for Climate Change Than Women Because They Love Meat and Cars. To be fair, the study didn’t lean into gender war territory in the way you would expect based on the headlines it generated. Gender wasn’t even mentioned in the paper’s title, which was “Shifting expenditure on food, holidays, and furnishings could lower greenhouse gas emissions by almost 40%”.

The climate crisis is undoubtedly a feminist issue. Climate change exacerbates increasing inequality and hits women harder than men. UN data suggests that 80% of people displaced by climate change are women. However, while gender is an important part of the climate crisis conversation – and an essential part of its solution – it is not helpful to focus on the gender-based spending habits of ordinary consumers. Placing the burden of mitigating climate change on individuals, no matter their gender, feels futile as we watch corporations and the 1%, who are the main drivers of climate change, do whatever the hell they like. I am not saying we don’t all need to do our part; of course we do. But it’s galling to be lectured on the evils of flying while billionaires are fawned over for shooting themselves into space.

While it’s always convenient to blame men for the dire state of the world, you can’t get around the fact that women in rich countries (myself included) are responsible for far more emissions than men in poor countries. The problem isn’t that certain men are spending more on motoring and meat than their female counterparts – it’s the obsession with economic growth at any cost. The rich world does the bulk of the sowing, while the poor world does most of the reaping.

Just look at what is happening in Madagascar. More than a million people are facing desperate food shortages due to what has been called the first famine in modern history caused by global heating alone. “This is an area of the world that has contributed nothing to climate change, but now they’re the ones paying the highest price,” said an executive from the UN World Food Programme last week.

We are not going to fix the climate crisis by shaming largely powerless individuals or getting men in the west to eat more plant-based burgers; it can be fixed only through systemic change.

Alas, it’s easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. That adage feels truer every day. While us plebs keep being told we have to change our habits, the masters of the universe have made it abundantly clear that they have no intention of changing theirs. Worse still is the fact that billionaires and corporations seem intent on having us believe not only that their greed isn’t ruining the world, but that it will in fact be its salvation. “We have to go to space to save Earth,” Jeff Bezos has opined loftily. It’s not just emissions that are the problem; it’s the greenhouse gaslighting.

• Arwa Mahdawi is a Guardian columnist


Arwa Mahdawi

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Yes, the climate crisis is terrifying. But I refuse to abandon hope | Arwa Mahdawi
The world seems to be on the verge of collapse – yet I have just brought a baby into it, writes Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

10, Aug, 2021 @2:18 PM

Article image
A heatwave in Seattle? Extreme weather is no longer ‘unprecedented’ | Arwa Mahdawi
This is serious enough for the 1% to start building bunkers ready for environmental collapse, says Guardian columnist Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

30, Jun, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Considering air con? That’s how much the UK’s climate has changed already
My kids are growing up in an England where sweltering conditions are no longer freakish, writes Zoe Williams – no wonder they think pumping in cold air is reasonable

Zoe Williams

17, Aug, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Blood glaciers: why is Alpine snow turning pink?
French scientists have noticed blooms of algae are becoming much more visible than they once were – possibly due to accelerated global heating

15, Jun, 2021 @2:11 PM

Article image
Most plastic will never be recycled – and the manufacturers couldn’t care less | Arwa Mahdawi
Oil and gas companies make far more money churning out new plastic than reusing old. Meanwhile, the public gets the blame, writes Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

15, Sep, 2020 @4:45 PM

Article image
‘2.4C is a death sentence’: Vanessa Nakate’s fight for the forgotten countries of the climate crisis
She started a youth strike in Uganda – then just kept going. She discusses climate justice, reparations, imperialism and why the global north must take responsibility

Zoe Williams

13, Dec, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
The real problem with your Netflix addiction? The carbon emissions | Arwa Mahdawi
Questions are being asked about the energy consumption of streaming services – which is why we should all pay more attention to our digital footprint

Arwa Mahdawi

12, Feb, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
The world is literally on fire – so why is it business as usual for politicians? | Arwa Mahdawi
Our extreme weather is making me nostalgic for the damp conditions of my English childhood. But despite the climate emergency, capitalism continues regardless, says Arwa Mahdawi

Arwa Mahdawi

23, Jul, 2019 @11:56 AM

Article image
David Wallace-Wells on climate: ‘People should be scared – I'm scared’
The journalist and author has claimed climate change will soon render the world uninhabitable, leading his supporters to say he’s telling the terrifying truth and critics to brand him a reckless alarmist. Why is he so worried?

Jonathan Watts

03, Feb, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
One year to save the planet: a simple guide to fighting the climate crisis in 2020
Veganism might help and it’s always good to avoid flying. But the answer to Earth’s emergency must involve political, collective action – and there are countless ways to get active

Sandra Laville

07, Jan, 2020 @3:31 PM