Too big for her boots? Alexandra Burke’s confidence should be feted | Rebecca Nicholson

Her Strictly performances were exceptional but the British public’s love of an underdog did her no favours. More’s the pity

Alexandra Burke has been speaking up for confidence, telling BBC News that the UK has “a massive problem” with mistaking self-belief for arrogance. Burke managed not to win Strictly Come Dancing in 2017 despite consistently dancing better than all of the other contestants. There was a feeling that the audience had not warmed to her, based on the fact that viewers regularly tweeted things such as “fake” and “false” and said she had too much experience as a dancer to win a best dancer competition.

“It’s a shame that some people mistook that determination and that will to want to do well, which everyone should have in life by the way, for arrogance or anything other than what it was,” she told the BBC last week. Burke became famous when she won The X Factor in 2008, after duetting with Beyoncé, a superstar now so aloof that she doesn’t bother with interviews, issuing only new photographs, which I imagine she peels from a pile and scatters like banknotes at the feet of desperate editors. Their version of Listen ended with Burke sobbing on Beyoncé’s shoulder, before Dermot O’Leary tied a ribbon around this odd time capsule by calling Beyoncé “hun”. It feels like longer than 10 years ago.

I spent some time last week on TV sets. Both productions had female directors. I watched these authoritative, confident women taking charge of the room with an easy, warm bluntness that was efficient and necessary, and I found this to be awe-inspiring. And then I realised what a shame it was that it seemed noteworthy to me, this brilliant, gleaming confidence. It has taken me years, for example, to stop couching work emails in apologetic language, to trim the “Do you mind if we…” to “Let’s…”, to cut “Is it okay with you if I…” to just, “I’m going to…” It’s hard to break the habit, and that’s down to accepting that it’s okay to be confident.

Is it a British thing? Perhaps. We’ve always had a fondness for the underdog; we don’t like it when people get too big for their boots. You see it again and again with British successes in Hollywood, say – any hint of a transatlantic twang, no matter how many decades that person has lived abroad, and they’ll be told to wind their neck in.

But confidence is a curious, nebulous concept, and the possession of it comes from a multitude of places, whether that’s the class you were raised in, the education you received, your gender, or the workplace that surrounds you. For many, it’s innate, and for others, it’s learned. Regardless of where it came from for Alexandra Burke, I’m pleased that she felt confident enough to justify her confidence.

• Rebecca Nicholson is an Observer columnist


Rebecca Nicholson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Craig Revel Horwood is making Strictly wholesome and inclusive fun | Rebecca Nicholson
If you’re offended by drag these days then it’s probably best just to stop watching this wonderful show

Rebecca Nicholson

12, Dec, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
Strictly crowns Katya Jones and Joe McFadden in a sea of schmaltz
It was a sparkling sugar-rush of nerves for the BBC Strictly Come Dancing final, a culmination of the winning formula of fake tan, sequins and a little controversy

Barbara Ellen

17, Dec, 2017 @8:12 AM

Article image
Alexandra Burke and the trouble with reality TV and race
As a brilliant dancer fails to win votes on Strictly week after week, an unsettling interpretation emerges: that racial anxieties are the problem

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

16, Dec, 2017 @1:35 PM

Article image
Pop maestro Simon Cowell finally bows to the public’s resounding ‘no’ vote | Rebecca Nicholson
The X Factor won’t be returning to our screens. It had long outstayed its welcome

Rebecca Nicholson

31, Jul, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Is nothing free from Brexit? Oh please leave Strictly out of it, Vince | Barbara Ellen
The Liberal leader citing the dance show does little to enhance the Remain cause

Barbara Ellen

28, Oct, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Ant and Dec, the kings of comfort TV make it 20 in a row | Rebecca Nicholson
The pair are on a huge National Television award streak – we just can’t get enough of them on our screens

Rebecca Nicholson

11, Sep, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Alexandra Burke: ‘I got asked to bleach my skin after X Factor’
Her career has taken her from pop success to Strictly and the stage. She discusses the pain of racist comments, the joy of duetting with Beyoncé – and the enduring influence of her late mother

Arifa Akbar

09, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Sorry, Ridley Scott, we just don’t think it’s safe to go back into the cinema | Rebecca Nicholson
The Last Duel director has blamed flighty ‘millennians’ for his latest epic film tanking, but maybe we’re not blockbuster-ready

Rebecca Nicholson

27, Nov, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Little Mix revamp the talent show with warmth and power | Rebecca Nicholson
The all-girl group reveal competition can happen without cruelty

Rebecca Nicholson

03, Oct, 2020 @6:12 PM

Article image
Strictly Come Dancing and racial prejudice | Letters
Letters: Tim Bale thinks more research is needed before deciding whether ethnicity affects a contestant’s chance of winning, Sue Boulding says some took against Alexandra Burke because they thought she had an unfair head start, while Alex More points to the expected success of Anthony Joshua in another public vote


17, Dec, 2017 @6:45 PM