No young child should be waking up in jail on Christmas Day | Megan Mitchell

Australia has one of the youngest ages for criminal culpability in the world, which allows us to imprison 10-year-olds

This year around 900 children and young people in Australia will spend Christmas in jail. More than 5% of this population are between 10 and 12 years old and 74% of this age group are Indigenous. Most have been charged or convicted with petty crimes, like graffiti, vandalism, shop lifting or fare evasion.

More than half of the children in Australian jails have not been convicted of a crime. They are in jail because the authorities have not found suitable residential alternatives while they await a court determination. Many will be released following sentencing, with no time remaining to serve in custody.

Punishment, deterrence and public safety are some of the common arguments used to justify the imprisonment of offenders. But, to be effective, the offender must understand that the punishment is a result of their actions.

Compared to other countries, the age threshold of 10 for treating children as criminally culpable and permitting their incarceration in Australia is low. In New Zealand and Germany, the age of criminal responsibility is 14 years old – the most common minimum age worldwide. In Canada it is 12 years old and in Portugal it is 16 years old.

The United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child recommends that the absolute minimum be 12 years of age.

Many studies have shown that children even well into their teens have not yet fully developed the ability to distinguish right from wrong, make careful judgments, delay gratification, restrain impulsive behaviour, or think through their actions.

Younger children also lack the capacity to properly engage in the criminal justice system, are more likely to accept a plea bargain, give false confessions or fail to keep track of court proceedings.

Similarly, does a 10-year-old child represent such a threat to public safety that we would lock them away? Is the system so poorly developed that we have no other solution or option?

While it is important to make clear that there are consequences for wrong-doing, I believe that the system should be focusing on preventing future crimes, rather than simply punishing old ones. As Dylan Voller, who was first incarcerated at the age of 11, told the royal commission into the protection and detention of children in the Northern Territory: “One of the biggest problems we face is the fact that we are being further punished while in prison.”

There are many examples from around the world that provide us with some useful alternative approaches. These include: programs to assist parents in supervision and control techniques; treatment and counselling; training courses; community service orders; child and family conferencing; intensive mentoring or family supervision; and professional foster or kin care.

Police also frequently operate diversionary programs for at-risk youth. Depending on the age of the child and the particular circumstances, some interventions may be ordered by police, a court or tribunal, or child protection agency, while others are voluntary. Evaluations of such interventions for children consistently demonstrate significantly lower rates of recidivism and better life outcomes than for those who are incarcerated at an early age.

These alternatives are in line with the principles enshrined in the Convention of the Rights of the Child: that detention of children should be a last resort, that children who do offend or are at risk of offending should be understood and treated as children, and that, wherever possible, measures for dealing with such children without resorting to judicial proceedings be pursued.

It’s time to seriously think about increasing the age of criminal responsibility and establishing a solid suite of alternative interventions and pathways to support children who are at risk.

No 10-year-old should be waking up on Christmas Day in a jail.


Megan Mitchell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Not caging children under 14 is the bare minimum we can do to not torture kids | Sophie Trevitt
I’ve watched smart, funny teenagers unravel behind bars. Australia needs to raise the age to keep young kids out of prison

Sophie Trevitt

19, May, 2023 @2:48 AM

Article image
Is 2016 the year our leaders are shocked into action for Indigenous kids? | Rodney Dillon
As Coag meets to discuss youth detention, we urge them to recognise that cohesive societies are built through stronger families not stronger prisons

Rodney Dillon

08, Dec, 2016 @1:10 AM

Article image
Like that young fella shackled to a chair, it seems like we have little say in our fate | Louise Taylor
Indigenous people are supposed to see images of their children tied up, stripped naked and brutalised and meekly accept assurances that the government will, this time, find a solution

Louise Taylor

02, Aug, 2016 @2:36 AM

Article image
To keep young children out of adult prisons, Australia must urgently raise the age of criminal responsibility | Cheryl Axleby
It won’t fix all injustices but it’s a step towards getting children back to their families and communities where they belong

Cheryl Axleby for IndigenousX

25, Aug, 2022 @5:53 AM

Article image
The colony’s solution to Indigenous youth crime? Jail and traumatise kids as young as 14 | First Dog on the Moon
Why? Racism obviously

First Dog on the Moon

27, Jul, 2022 @5:55 AM

Article image
Indigenous woman to be released from WA jail after donor pays $3,000 fine
The 35-year-old mother of five had been given two weeks’ jail to pay down fine in move senator Pat Dodson described as ‘reprehensible’

Calla Wahlquist

29, Sep, 2017 @7:57 AM

Article image
Indigenous advocate: 'Jail is part of our life and part of being institutionalised'
Every night, one in 15 Indigenous men in WA will spend the night in jail

Calla Wahlquist

03, Aug, 2016 @9:15 PM

Article image
Aboriginal man dies in custody days after jail was told he was suicidal
‘The system has failed another one of our young men,’ spokesman for West Australian Indigenous support group says

Lorena Allam

17, Jun, 2019 @3:42 AM

Article image
We saw how terribly children were treated in prisons and promised ‘never again’. Now there is just bitter disappointment | Sophie Trevitt
There is no question about what needs to be done, only a question of who is prepared to do it

Sophie Trevitt

23, Jul, 2019 @12:17 AM

Article image
One Nation failure in Queensland's election doesn't mean race relations are better | Melinda Mann for IndigenousX
Covid may have distracted many voters from Pauline Hanson but there’s been no let up in the targeting of Indigenous people

Melinda Mann for IndigenousX

10, Nov, 2020 @7:01 AM