Bank of England deputy's slip-up was astonishing – but its reaction was predictable | Nils Pratley

Charlotte Hogg will survive her failure to declare a conflict of interest, but the Bank has revealed it remains a cosy club

Charlotte Hogg, a week ago, could not have been clearer. “I am in compliance with all of our codes of conduct. I know that. I helped to write them,” declared the Bank of England’s new deputy governor to the Treasury select committee.

Now comes the excruciating apology. Actually, no, she was not in compliance because she didn’t declare to the Bank when she joined in 2013 that her brother, Quintin, has a senior job in strategy at Barclays, a bank regulated by Threadneedle Street. In fact, the first time she mentioned her brother was in a questionnaire she filled out for the Treasury committee. She takes full responsibility for this regrettable oversight.

Astonishing would be better description. At a push, one might say that Hogg comes from such well-connected stock (her grandfather, Lord Hailsham, was lord chancellor and her parents are serving members of the House of Lords) that a sibling at Barclays is easy to overlook.

But that doesn’t wash. The codes are designed to cover all potential conflicts of interests, plus perceptions of conflicts. Her brother’s gig clearly met the threshold.

Thus Hogg, in her previous role of chief operating officer at the Bank, had been commanding others to follow a code while failing to do so herself. There were at least two occasions when she could have corrected the omission in the records but didn’t.

For two and a half hours the Treasury committee chewed over these revelations and only one member came to a firm conclusion. Hogg’s position was “untenable” and she should resign, said John Mann. Chair Andrew Tyrie said the committee as a whole would only give its view after “a period of reflection.”

Let’s hope that reflection goes wider than just Hogg’s foul-up. Her mistake seems to have been honest and there is no suggestion that information passed improperly between her and her brother. Rather, it’s the Bank’s reaction that is alarming.

Anthony Habgood and Bradley Fried, chairman and deputy chairman of the governing court of the Bank, gave a hapless performance in front of the MPs. If they were aware that governor Mark Carney gave Hogg a verbal warning on Monday, they didn’t mention the fact. Neither man seemed to have tried to establish what Quintin Hogg’s loosely defined job at Barclays actually involves. And the MPs made mincemeat of the suggestion that Charlotte Hogg’s undeclared potential conflict of interest didn’t matter terribly in her previous operational role.

The sense of closing ranks around an “impeccable” individual whose error was serious but merited only “grumpiness,” as Fried put it, was unmistakable. Jacob Rees-Mogg, for the MPs, got it right. The court’s investigation lacked rigour. It accepted “bland reassurances and passed them on”, which is not good enough if you’re in the business not only of avoiding conflicts of interest but also the perception.

Hogg, almost certainly, will survive the affair, albeit with her authority dented. But the whiff of complacency in the court is harder to overlook. After the financial crisis, the outside world was promised firm 21st-century governance led by commanding outsiders. Tuesday’s show looked old-style cosy.

House prices: bring on the slowdown

Annual house price growth slowed to the weakest rate seen in nearly four years in February.
Annual house price growth slowed to the weakest rate seen in nearly four years in February. Photograph: Yui Mok/PA

Encouraging news from the housing market: cooler winds are blowing. The rate of growth in prices fell in February to the lowest for three and a half years, according to the Halifax’s index. This development may not delight homeowners looking to sell in a hurry but, for anybody with a wider or longer perspective, a slowdown is exactly what the UK needs.

Annual house price inflation a year ago had reached the silly level of 10%, far too fast for an economy growing at about 2%. A correction was overdue and the steady decline to 5.1%, down from 5.7% in January, restores a degree of sanity. A rate of 5% is still too high given that average earnings are currently growing at 2.5%, but most economists think house price inflation should slow to 2% by the end of this year. Bring it on.

To see why, look at Halifax’s ratio of house prices to earnings, as reliable a guide as any to affordability, froth and danger. The current level is about six times (pdf), which was last seen in 2007, just before the banking crash and recession. If 10% house price inflation had continued, the UK would have been heading into dangerous waters.

The Bank of England’s monetary policymakers, already fretting about the rise in unsecured credit card debt, should be relieved. Their working plan this year and next, one assumes, will be to keep interest rates at ultra-low levels and ignore the inflationary effects of the 15% fall in the pound against the dollar.

It is a sensible plan to address the Brexit uncertainties, but it is horribly exposed to the risk of a house price bubble fuelled by cheap money. If that risk is receding, the Bank has a freer hand and the Brexit obstacle looks slightly less daunting.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK housing market is on fire, warns Bank of England chief economist
Continued rise stoked by tax breaks and demand from well-off households likely to deepen inequality, says Andy Haldane

Phillip Inman

08, Jun, 2021 @5:16 PM

Article image
Bank of England explores easier options for getting a mortgage
Review comes as concerns grow that first-time buyers are being left out of property market during Covid crisis

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

11, Dec, 2020 @12:13 PM

Article image
Bank of England gets sweeping powers to prevent next house price bubble
Financial policy committee details new powers as RICS predicts house sales will jump in 2013 as prices stabilise

Phillip Inman, economics correspondent

15, Jan, 2013 @12:05 AM

Article image
Treasury commitee struggles to hide scorn over Osborne's Help to Buy plan

• Report points out consequences of chancellor's policy
• Gold prices fall
• Rich Ricci and the Barclays shakeup
• Royal Mail and a privatised post

Nils Pratley

19, Apr, 2013 @11:01 PM

Article image
Bank of England prepares stress tests to ensure banks can survive housing crash
Eight institutions face checks to see if they can survive 35% slump in property prices and interest rates jumping to 5%

Jill Treanor and Katie Allen

28, Apr, 2014 @8:24 PM

Article image
Bank of England asks for powers to intervene in housing market
Central bank wants restrictions on loan-to-value and loan-to-income multiples to protect financial system from housing bubble

Jill Treanor

02, Oct, 2014 @6:34 PM

Article image
Bank of England holds off action on house prices despite bubble fears
FPC will 'closely monitor' property market, while FCA will assess vulnerability of hedge funds to rate changes

Jill Treanor

25, Sep, 2013 @11:16 AM

Article image
The Brexit economy: looming rate rise clouds outlook as inflation dips
‘The beast from the east’ blew the UK economy off course, further complicating an already complex picture

Richard Partington

26, Apr, 2018 @12:21 PM

Article image
Stress tests: Bank of England flags up buy-to-let concerns
BoE reviewing lending criteria adopted by firms and puts banks on notice about holding £10bn capital cushion to guard against economic downturn

Jill Treanor

01, Dec, 2015 @7:25 PM

Article image
Keep UK interest rate low for now, IMF tells Bank of England
International Monetary Fund warns Bank to be ready to raise rates if other measure fail to keep housing market in check

Katie Allen

28, Jul, 2014 @4:50 PM