What hope for wage growth when the right to strike is curtailed? | Greg Jericho

Expect a big fight on industrial relations this year as job numbers grow but wages lie low

The disconnect between the current strong employment growth and the weak growth in household incomes remains the biggest issue for the coming political year, and it has emerged as the greatest weakness to the government’s economic argument.

One of the more absurd suggestions that did the rounds when the Rudd government introduced the Fair Work Act was that the new laws were swinging the pendulum too far in favour of unions.

The claim continued despite evidence to the contrary. In May 2012, the then BHP chairman Jac Nasser suggested that the review of the Fair Work Act would be “an opportunity to move the pendulum back to a more appropriate balance”. A couple of months later, Tony Abbott said he wanted to “restore the workplace relations pendulum to the sensible centre. That’s where it always should be”.

Ahh ... the sensible centre – a position Malcolm Turnbull embraces as well. At the 2016 annual LNP conference in Queensland, while referring to the capacity of industrial disputes to act “as a handbrake on economic growth”, he urged Bill Shorten to “meet us in the sensible centre” – a point that from Turnbull’s point of view included the Australian Building and Construction Commission and the Registered Organisation Commission – two organisations implicitly established to curtail union power.

This week, we saw evidence of just how hollow the suggestion is that somehow the pendulum has swung too much in favour of unions.

The Fair Work Commission suspended the proposed 24-hour strike scheduled for Monday by Sydney and NSW train drivers because it was “threatening to endanger the welfare of part of the population” and would “cause significant damage to the Australian economy or an important part of it.”

The ability for the industrial umpire to ban a strike because of such reasons has long been a part of our industrial relations framework. But the margins for breaching such conditions are now so wide that, as the Australian Council of Trade Unions secretary, Sally McManus, said on Thursday, it means “the basic right to strike in Australia is very nearly dead”.

That is why we can expect a big fight on industrial relations this year.

In December, a record percentage of Australians aged between 15 and 64 were employed, and the month had the most number of people working full-time for the past five years. But while such figures would previously lead to wages and household income growth, workers are still waiting for such rewards. Therein lies the problem for the government.

You can talk of underemployment and the hangover from the past five years of poor employment growth and generally low inflation around the world, but the Australian government is doing nothing to improve the situation.

Turnbull and the treasurer, Scott Morrison, will talk of greater wages growth emerging once company profits improve via tax cuts, but such a link requires a system of industrial relations that allows workers to agitate for such wages, and one that also seeks to reduce underemployment rather than foster it.

And despite the improved profitability of companies in 2017 and the strong rise in employment, we already have evidence that low wage growth will continue.

The latest figures from the Department of Jobs and Small Business show that the average wage rise for enterprise agreements approved in the September quarter last year was a record low at 2.2%.

Such a result is not surprising given the abuse of the enterprise bargaining system by companies seeking to terminate agreements during the bargaining process and forcing workers to negotiate with the award rate as the starting point rather than the pay and conditions previously agreed to.

Companies know the current industrial relations system is in their favour, and they are more than happy with the current level of low wage growth.

In the recently released Australian Industry Group 2018 Business Prospects report, rather than bemoaning the poor growth in wages, Australian CEOs actually championed it.

The AIG expresses a desire for “the continuation of moderate wages growth” (note that “moderate” means record or near record low) and argues that “the record jobs growth of 2017 and the ability to meet expectations of still higher jobs growth in 2018 are closely associated with the moderate wages outcomes of recent years and require the continuation of this pattern into 2018”.

So you can have your strong employment growth only if you have record-low wages growth.

And far from looking for higher wages, the report also noted that concerns about wages “are already spreading among Australia’s CEOs”.

The disconnect between the current low level of wages growth and the employment situation has come about through decades of industrial relations policy, where the right to strike has been severely restrained and the unions are seen as having too much control.

Regardless of its rhetoric, the government is more than happy for the disconnect to remain in place. Its policies foster an environment where workers’ negotiating power is diminished and it tries to convince us that higher wages will come once companies can afford them – even as the companies tell us that what they really want is for the record low wage growth to continue.

– Greg Jericho is a Guardian Australia columnist


Greg Jericho

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Whoever wins the argument over wages growth will likely win the next election | Greg Jericho
Voters have a stark choice: Turnbull’s plea to be patient and let the market do its job or Shorten’s mantra that the system is broken

Greg Jericho

03, Feb, 2018 @9:01 PM

Article image
Record low wage growth is a blow to the government's case for tax reform | Greg Jericho
Spare us the sentiment about unions having too much power. The latest figures show businesses have more than ample flexibility to control wages

Greg Jericho

19, Nov, 2015 @12:02 AM

Article image
The Morrison government is trying to lock in a less equitable economy for years to come | Greg Jericho
Anyone thinking this government will use this crisis to give workers a better say at the bargaining table has a near life-threatening level of gullibility

Greg Jericho

15, Aug, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
We need to talk about recession: why the 'record run of growth' won't pay the bills | Greg Jericho
We have had a record period without a recession and yet we have wages growing at levels you would associate with one

Greg Jericho

07, Jun, 2017 @8:10 PM

Article image
Coalition ignoring lack of job security in Australia, Labor says
Record jobs numbers belies low wages growth, 730,000 unemployed and rising use of labour hire, says shadow finance minister

Gareth Hutchens

21, Jan, 2018 @5:00 PM

Article image
Sally McManus says enterprise bargaining is 'smothering' wage growth
ACTU boss calls for industry-level bargaining and equal rights for casuals in speech criticised by employer groups as anti-jobs

Paul Karp

21, Mar, 2018 @6:06 AM

Article image
Economic ​picture ​leaves ​Coalition in solid position to be re-elected | Greg Jericho
Tony Abbott’s prediction before the 2013 election of creating 1m jobs in five years looks set to come to fruition

Greg Jericho

22, Jan, 2018 @5:00 PM

Article image
Wage theft: Coalition says tough new penalties won't apply for 'genuine mistakes'
Christian Porter says government wants to ‘stamp out deliberate and systematic wage theft by Australian employers’

Paul Karp

18, Sep, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
Australians aren't being paid for their productivity. Get set for an industrial relations war | Greg Jericho
An OECD report shows that the gap between productivity and pay is wider in Australia than almost any other advanced economy, including the USA

Greg Jericho

22, May, 2017 @10:00 PM

Article image
The government is desperate as protesting workers have public opinion behind them | Van Badham
Scott Morrison condemns ‘cocky’ unionists and Kelly O’Dwyer warns of ‘dark days’ - all for workers demanding equal rights

Van Badham

25, Oct, 2018 @5:57 AM