Rail industry prays for a Christmas miracle to avert strikes

Time is running out for a deal to send threat of disruption into the sidings and keep holiday travel plans on track

Christmas is, of course, a time to believe in miracles – but when the government is reduced to publicly imploring the RMT union to bring out its altruistic side, it seems more likely that the railway is teetering on the edge of a not very festive abyss.

The new rail minister, Huw Merriman, got all sides together on Friday, in a statement of intent. But time is running out to avoid what will probably be the most damaging strike action yet: two 48-hour walkouts across Network Rail and train operators between 13-17 December, and an overtime ban that will bring more disruption to services throughout the Christmas period – right up to another planned week of strikes in early January.

Talks between the RMT, Network Rail – employer of crucial signalling staff – and train operators must hit some sort of agreement by Monday night, or more rail chaos is assured. An 11th-hour truce, as the RMT showed last month, is too late to keep the trains running. And while paying members to stay home, instead of striking, may appeal in the short term, unions will swiftly lose public sympathy should that situation recur.

The first strikes are also due just after the introduction of a new timetable next Sunday, designed to restore more regular intercity trains on Avanti West Coast and more reliable services on Northern and TransPennine Express. Now 11 December – a red-letter day for Avanti’s promised recovery for many months – looks set to herald a week of more mayhem. Train drivers could walk out again, too, around Christmas: Aslef’s executive meets on Tuesday, armed with fresh strike mandates.

The industry is acutely aware of the sensitivities around seasonal travel. Passenger numbers are traditionally low, compared with daily commutes – but woe betide the rail boss who keeps, say, a newspaper editor from leaving the capital and returning to the office after Boxing Day. The ghosts of Christmas past include headlines about overrunning engineering works that left thousands of passengers delayed or diverted from central London one 27 December. Back in 2014, quaintly, such mayhem led to a parliamentary inquiry; this year, it’s been barely a morning’s work for Avanti.

At a point in December when dispute has raged for a year, when passengers are in despair and senior insiders privately admit they won’t be risking the train, the immediate outlook appears bleak.

But there are reasons to think the railway can be hauled back from the brink. Industry finances long escaped scrutiny in the good times; now, some argue, Treasury tightness is overblown. Passenger numbers are returning to pre-Covid levels outside the big commuter belts – and more firms want those reluctant travellers back.

Overall, rail traffic is at about 80% of 2019 levels, even with many deterred from taking the train. And if the poisoning of industrial relations is the main reason for the mayhem at Avanti and elsewhere, with staff no longer working the overtime that operators require, could spreading the love – and a little cash – fix the railway’s wider problem? Revenue may be £6m a day below 2019, but the whole dispute could be settled for the kind of money dropped on a dodgy PPE contract, or a fraction of the losses from a misjudged mini-budget.

In the short term, industry chiefs believe few staff, with bills mounting and presents to buy, are keen to forgo wages from strikes or from an overtime ban, in a season with plentiful opportunities for double pay.

Long-term, net zero ambitions rely on a switch to electrified transport – and trains far outstrip cars or buses on that front, never mind planes. On Thursday, underlining that point, the government pledged a continued £44bn spend on the railways over the next “control period” from 2024-29.

The ghost of Christmas yet to come cannot point a bony finger at railway’s grave. Salvaging Christmas present, however, will require some dramatic adjustments on both sides.


Gwyn Topham

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rail strikes: Hopes of a resolution have been indefinitely delayed
After a year of walkouts and failed talks, the unions, ministers and operators are as far apart as ever

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

27, May, 2023 @11:05 PM

Article image
Rail strikes: more talks this week to avert shutdown in Britain
Tickets will be refunded if national strikes go ahead, Rail Delivery Group chair says

Gwyn Topham and Joanna Partridge

08, Jun, 2022 @2:40 PM

Article image
Rail staff are set for battle, but a post-Covid strike could run off track
The working-from-home revolution has altered the dynamics of industrial action on the transport network

Gwyn Topham

28, May, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
Advent calendar of rail strikes set to shred service as deal is severely delayed
Eighteen months after action was announced, there is daylight for the RMT; but Aslef and the bosses still aren’t talking

Gwyn Topham

26, Nov, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Christmas rail strikes still on, says Mick Lynch after meeting minister
‘Until we get tangible outcome, action will be on,’ says RMT leader after talks with transport secretary

Gwyn Topham

24, Nov, 2022 @4:30 PM

Article image
Ministers avoiding talks to stop Christmas rail strikes, says RMT union
Passengers hoping to travel by train on Christmas Eve face disruption with most services ending by 3pm

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

23, Dec, 2022 @11:47 AM

Article image
Network Rail urges unions to return to talks to avert strike
Strike across Great Britain planned for 27 July as RMT calls latest pay offer of 4% this year, up to 4% the next, ‘paltry’

Mark Sweney

14, Jul, 2022 @12:49 PM

Article image
Fresh UK rail strikes announced in run-up to Christmas
Passengers warned of travel disruption as workers at Avanti West Coast and Eurostar join widescale action

Joe Middleton

30, Nov, 2022 @6:31 PM

Article image
UK rail strikes – the truth behind the claims and counter-claims
From accusations of ‘RMT intransigence’ to ‘government meddling’ behind the scenes, we check the facts

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

21, Jun, 2022 @5:34 PM

Article image
Rail industry and RMT resume talks amid hopes of end to strikes
But drivers’ union Aslef set to reject initial pay offer from train operators, meaning resolution is some way off

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

16, Jan, 2023 @5:49 PM