Sale of Tasmanian salmon farmer ‘a certainty’ but opponents remain bitterly disappointed

Institutional investors expected to vote in favour of sale, giving Brazilian meat processor JBS the minimum support needed to take control of Huon

The $500m takeover bid of Tasmanian salmon farmer Huon by Brazilian meat processing giant JBS is a “certainty’” with a key shareholder vote on Friday expected to approve the deal.

Sam Baker, private wealth adviser from Shadforth Financial Group, said FIRB approval on Monday removed any question about the deal, leaving shareholders to decide just how much will be sold off.

“It is a certainty that JBS will receive the majority of the shares and therefore control of Huon will move across,” Baker said.

Baker said the vote, which will take place on Friday, will probably have two results: either JBS takes full control of Huon and compulsorily acquires shares held by minor shareholders, or it will be forced to accept a smaller majority position.

The deal has been organised by a Scheme of Arrangement – a friendly takeover where the board of the company losing control supports the transfer and minority shareholders are bought out by the incoming owners.

Huon’s owners, Peter and Frances Bender – who own 52% of Huon – initiated the sale of the company in February this year after losses they attributed to the pandemic. In August the company announced a $128m loss despite a 39% increase in production.

Once the agreement was approved by the board, JBS needed 75% of shareholders to vote in favour of the transfer in order to take full control of the company.

While JBS fought off a competing bid by Canadian aquaculture firm Cooke, a twist came when mining billionaire Andrew Forrest increased his share in the company to 18.5% and began floating the possibility of his own takeover bid.

This forced JBS to make a second “off market” offer where it would take a smaller controlling interest in Huon should it receive just 50.1% of support from shareholders.

Baker said he expected Australian Super to vote in favour of selling to JBS on Friday alongside other institutional investors, giving the Brazilian multinational the minimum 75% support it needed to take full control.

At $3.85 a share this compulsory acquisition would net the Benders $220m, while Forrest could pocket roughly $12m if he decides to sell his, accounting for the money spent to acquire different amounts of shares at prices between $2.40 and $3.85 each.

Even if Australian Super voted with Forrest to reject the takeover by refusing to sell their shares, Huon would still be absorbed into the multinational entity leaving Forrest with little influence over the company’s operation.

“If you think about it, it’s a $530m acquisition in what is more than a $20b sized company,” Baker said. “Huon will only make up about 2.5% of JBS’ global operation. And Andrew Forrest will only own 18% – if he decides to hold on to his shares.

“That’s 0.05% of the total [JBS] operation. It’s not even a rounding error, really.”

The Guardian contacted Forrest’s investment firm, Tattarang, which is handling the bid but did not receive a response by publication.

Once the result of the vote is known, final approval will be given by a court next Wednesday but unless an unforeseen irregularity is detected, this step is considered a formality.

Federal Greens senator Peter Whish-Wilson said whatever the outcome, the development was “disappointing”.

“I can’t see JBS being a driver of reform to the industry,” Whish-Wilson said. “They play to win. I don’t think they’re going to care about a social licence. It isn’t in their corporate DNA.”

Whish-Wilson said that as JBS has access to more investment capital, he anticipates the company will ramp up its operations at a time when Huon will be subject to fewer reporting requirements

As JBS assumes total control of the company, Huon will become a private entity and will no longer be required to report to the Australian Stock Exchange, leaving Tassal as the last publicly-listed Australian salmon farmer.

“For anyone who wants to look at it forensically, it will be very difficult,” Whish-Wilson said. “The industry is going to be less transparent because there’s only one company to focus on.”

Contributor

Royce Kurmelovs

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Approval given for $500m takeover of Tasmanian salmon farmer by Brazilian meat processing giant
Environmentalists say Huon deal will make it harder to regulate local industry and is ‘truly bleak news’ for the state

Royce Kurmelovs

25, Oct, 2021 @10:41 AM

Article image
Environmentalists call on treasurer to reject Brazilian meat giant’s bid for Tasmanian salmon farmer
Josh Frydenberg urged to use foreign investment review powers to reject JBS’s bid for Huon Aquaculture

Adam Morton Climate and environment editor

18, Aug, 2021 @10:33 PM

Article image
Meet the Batistas: the global beef barons battling for control of Australia’s meat
JBS, which is trying to take over pork producer Rivalea, now finds itself in a stoush with Andrew ‘Twiggy’ Forrest over Tasmanian salmon farmer Huon

Ben Butler

28, Aug, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Tasmanian salmon should be off the menu for now, says conservation group
Fish eaters advised to ‘Say No’ due to environmental concerns surrounding Tasmania’s salmon farming industry

Alexandra Spring

20, Oct, 2018 @10:22 PM

Article image
Tasmanian family refuses to pay council tax on 'God's land'
The Beerepoot family have not paid their rates for seven years, according to the council, and say that doing so would be bowing down to a false god

Calla Wahlquist

14, Mar, 2017 @3:23 AM

Article image
Ban on contentious tourism project in Tasmanian world heritage area overturned
Appeal tribunal reverses council decision to block luxury camp on Halls Island on Lake Malbena in Walls of Jerusalem national park

Adam Morton Environment editor

22, Oct, 2019 @2:14 AM

Article image
Chinese firm's promises on Tasmanian dairy farm 'not legally binding'
Moon Lake Investments won approval to buy Van Diemen’s Land Company after promising to invest $100m in Tasmania and create jobs

Christopher Knaus

30, May, 2018 @4:28 AM

Article image
Woolworths concerned by claims salmon certification scheme ‘may not be fit for purpose’
Supermarket ‘closely reviewing’ report that found the certification system failed to prevent a mass fish kill in Tasmania

Royce Kurmelovs

09, Sep, 2021 @9:11 AM

Article image
Andrew Forrest takes $20m stake in Tasmania’s controversial salmon industry
Mining billionaire’s private investment arm, Tattarang, hauls in 7.33% stake in Huon Aquaculture

Michael McGowan

22, Jun, 2021 @4:12 AM

Article image
Stormy waters: the salmon farmer trying to limit fishing and save the ocean
Unlikely environmentalist Frances Bender is taking legal action against Tasmanian government for failing to protect the environment

Dyani Lewis

08, Jun, 2017 @12:26 AM