Losing Eden: Why Our Minds Need the Wild by Lucy Jones; Wanderland by Jini Reddy – review

Two books examining the importance of nature on our wellbeing feel all the more vital under lockdown

When the first daffodils were blooming two months ago, the apocalyptic prologue to Lucy Jones’s Losing Eden would have felt urgent enough. It describes a young girl, Xena, wearing goggles and a respirator, walking to her grandmother’s house. Here, they sit together and experience nature – birds singing, trees growing – through a virtual-reality scene. “Why did nature end, Granny?” Xena asks. “We didn’t love it enough,” Granny answers. “And we forgot it could give us peace.”

The subtext here is climate change. But today, with the country in lockdown, and the blossoming world outside feeling more important to us than ever, Jones’s and Jini Reddy’s books take on extra significance.

Nature writing in recent years has often been about landscapes granting peace, even if that peace has mostly been limited to white men walking up mountains and having epiphanies. (If they tried that today, the police would send them home.) These books, each in their own distinct way, take that idea and twist it.

Jones’s book is a beautifully written, research-heavy study about how nature offers us wellbeing. She begins by telling us how much we’ve travelled inwards as human beings, both literally and psychologically, nowadays spending only 1 to 5% of our time outdoors (she adds later that three-quarters of children in the UK, aged five to 12, now spend less time outside than prisoners). In her 20s she had a dependency on drink and drugs that was partly relieved by her walks in London’s Walthamstow Marshes (along with psychiatry and psychotherapy, she says; she’s not a writer wanting to give nature an easy, breezy pass). “Nature picked me up by the scruff of my neck,” she writes, “and I rested in her teeth for a while.”

Jones’s ideas are not cosseted in psychobabble, but rooted firmly in peer-reviewed science. She tells us how the human epidermis is more like a pond surface or forest soil than fleshy armour, and how it responds to microorganisms in fresh air. We find out about Dacher Keltner’s study of our emotional response to nature, and a 2015 experiment proving that “microbreaks” in nature (looking at a green roof in a city, rather than bare concrete) improve our cognitive functioning. She discovers that our eyes respond to fractal patterns in nature because their internal physical structure is made up of similar patterns. Jones unpicks the science in accessible, moving writing.

She also focuses on those who lack access to the outdoors. Writing about the expansion of “forest school” sessions in British education (where children are taught outside and encouraged to explore), Jones is at pains to point out how many British children don’t have access to gardens. While celebrating green spaces in cities, she flags up a study showing that women, low-income groups and BAME communities report more instances of feeling unsafe in public parks. More acknowledgment of these issues is sorely needed in nature writing.

Jini Reddy’s Wanderland explores being a non-white female finding solace in nature. This is a less unusual perspective than it used to be, thanks to writers such as Elizabeth-Jane Burnett and Zakiya Mckenzie and the brilliant Willowherb Review, a journal celebrating nature writers of colour. Reddy is British by birth, Indian by descent, Canadian by upbringing, with South African parents. “People I meet for the first time in the countryside often look at me a second longer than they need to,” she writes, “a woman with coffee-coloured skin walking on her own.”

But Reddy’s book is more about seeking extremes in landscape, both literal and spiritual. She begins her story up a mountain in the Pyrenees with little food, a small tent, and nine bottles of water. She admits straightaway that some people may think her “a deluded hippy”, and she does sometimes consider nature a little too romantically. At one point she visits the Welsh borders to spend time with a goddess worshipper, in touch with the mystical powers of nature. Reddy is surprised that the woman lives on an ordinary road near a barn of “desperate-looking cows” and wonders how she copes “in constant proximity to so much misery”. Rural life is not always full of delights.

But Reddy is also a product of her parents’ hard-won social mobility, her father getting help to study in the UK, before the family moved to Canada when she was young. Here, her childhood experiences of Quebec landscapes are transporting: “Into this weird, wild winter wonderland, I was delivered, agog… the space, the nature and the quiet were exactly what an inquisitive, imaginative seven-year-old needed.” Her interest in more shamanic relationships with nature also feed into her heritage, particularly her connections with her mother’s Hindu faith. As a child she had a shrine to Shiva and Lakshmi, and writes about how goddesses are believed to be present in trees, flowers, water, and the sun.

Both these books remind us, as we look out of the window at the budding spring, or listen to birds on our daily socially distanced walks, just how very individual, and how personally precious, these experiences can be.

Losing Eden: Why Our Minds Need the Wild by Lucy Jones is published by Penguin (£20). To order a copy go to guardianbookshop.com. Free UK p&p over £15

Wanderland: A Search for Magic in the Landscape by Jini Reddy is published by Bloomsbury (£16.99)


Jude Rogers

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Walker by Matthew Beaumont review – an urban wanderland
Beaumont draws on multiple literary sources in his paean to the joys of thinking while pounding the city streets

Sean O’Hagan

30, Nov, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Cyber Effect by Mary Aiken – review
A cyberpsychologist is worryingly persuasive about the potential damage to children of a life online

John Naughton

14, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
This Is Your Mind on Plants by Michael Pollan review – the trip of a lifetime
This fascinating insight into our relationship with mind-altering plants weaves personal experimentation with cultural history

Tim Adams

20, Jul, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
How to Do Things With Emotions by Owen Flanagan review – don’t shout, don’t let it all out
A philosopher contends that we should value shame and reject rage in a valuable study of the role that emotions play in society

Susie Orbach

11, Jan, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Sounds Wild and Broken review – a moving paean to Earth’s fraying soundtrack
David George Haskell’s often wonderful book explores the often lost frequencies of nature – heard clearly during Covid’s initial human hush

Tim Adams

25, Apr, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Drugs That Changed Our Minds by Lauren Slater – review
Twenty years after hailing antidepressants in her memoir Prozac Diary, a now jaded, sceptical Lauren Slater revisits the psychopharmacological industry – with uneven results

Alex Preston

01, Apr, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Brainwashed by Daniel Pick review – do great minds really think alike?
From The Simpsons to QAnon via The Stepford Wives, the psychoanalyst’s absorbing study of mind control is part media studies, part political history

Anthony Cummins

28, Jun, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Our Place review – damning indictment of Britons’ ecological complacency
Mark Cocker delivers a blistering attack on the country’s collective failure to protect its landscape and wildlife

Alex Preston

17, Apr, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
A Farewell to Ice by Peter Wadhams review – climate change writ large
The warning this book gives us about the consequences of the loss of the planet’s ice is emphatic, urgent and convincing

Horatio Clare

21, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Climate Book, created by Greta Thunberg review – an angry call for action
The environmental activist curates a supergroup of climate experts in a valuable set of essays, which at times risk overwhelming the reader

Dorian Lynskey

15, Nov, 2022 @7:00 AM