Queensland’s plan to override human rights law ‘deeply concerning’, commissioner says

Scott McDougall alarmed at Palaszczuk government plan to make breach of bail an offence for children

The Queensland human rights commissioner says he is “deeply concerned” at the state’s plan to charge children with criminal offences for breaching their bail conditions – the first time the Labor government has sought to override protections enshrined in its own Human Rights Act.

Proposed youth justice legislation, which would make breaches of bail an offence for children, was tabled in parliament on Monday by the police minister, Mark Ryan.

The new laws were accompanied by a statement that acknowledged they were not compatible with human rights.

The Human Rights Act – a landmark piece of legislation passed with fanfare by the Palaszczuk government in 2019 – gives parliament the ability to make an “override declaration”, which allows laws to take effect if they are at odds with human rights provisions.

Such declarations should “only be made in exceptional circumstances”, such as war, a state of emergency or “an exceptional crisis” constituting a threat to public health, safety or order.

The state’s human rights commissioner, Scott McDougall, said in a statement on Tuesday evening that he was alarmed by the government’s actions, including that it would remove human rights protections for the first time. He said the bill had been brought without proper consultation.

“It is deeply concerning that the government has sought to exclude the Human Rights Act from the operation of new provisions of the Youth Justice Act, because the government accepts that they are incompatible with human rights,” he said.

“The government must consult widely and properly consider evidence-based solutions rather than rashly overriding human rights protections. Removing the rights of children ultimately does not uphold the rights of victims of crime.

“This is yet another piecemeal reaction to youth crime and with no overarching coordinated multi-agency plan to meaningfully address the causes of youth offending.”

McDougall raised concern that the government was implementing a policy that experts and others say would result in “an explosion” of the population in Queensland’s buckling youth detention system, but contained no plan to get children out of police watch houses, where about 80 are currently being detained.

He said the government required an “urgent” plan to get kids out of watch houses.

“I am deeply concerned about the lack of any plan to immediately cease the practice of prolonged watch house detention,” McDougall said.

“In Queensland, we have become desensitised to the practice of holding children in small police cells for days and weeks at a time. We have heard troubling accounts of up to 11 children held for long periods in a single cell with only one toilet.

“This would be unacceptable in any jurisdiction, but for it to occur in Australia’s newest human rights jurisdiction is particularly distressing.”

McDougall said the government’s policies risk normalising the inhumane treatment of children, by exposing them to a psychological and physical harm.

“The proposals will inevitably lead to greater pressure on detention centres and threaten to normalise the inhumane treatment of children by exposing them to an unacceptable risk of psychological and physical harm,” he said.

“There is no evidence that the amendments will work to improve community safety in the immediate or longer term.”

On Tuesday, Ryan tabled a statement that said the government “accepts that these provisions [in the bill] are incompatible with human rights”.

“Therefore, in this exceptional case, the [Human Rights Act] is being overridden and its application entirely excluded from the operation of these new provisions to protect community safety.”

Ryan said that the amendment was “inconsistent with international standards about the best interests of the child”.

He said this was because the amendment could make it more likely that children will be detained pending trial, despite standards by the UN that it “shall be used only as a measure of last resort”.

The measures would also breach the UN’s standards that detention “before trial shall be avoided to the extent possible and limited to exceptional circumstances” and “all efforts shall be made to apply alternative measures”, he wrote.


Ben Smee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Human Rights Act could be critical in divisive Queensland youth bail case
Palaszczuk government’s 2019 laws to be weighed against underlying principles of human rights

Ben Smee

14, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
‘Recipe for disaster’: Queensland bail law that overrides children’s human rights won’t work, experts say
Legal groups also criticise the push to override the state’s Human Rights Act to create the offence

Joe Hinchliffe and Eden Gillespie

22, Feb, 2023 @3:00 AM

Article image
Queensland committee backs overriding human rights for new youth laws as striking ‘appropriate balance’
Changes ‘justified’ in light of public anxiety and despite some provisions being incompatible with rights act

Eden Gillespie

10, Mar, 2023 @3:10 AM

Article image
Magistrate grants girl bail amid concern she would join dozens of children held in adult watch houses for weeks
Eoin Mac Giolla Ri in a separate case last month said children could be exposed to ‘drunk, abusive, psychotic’ detainees

Eden Gillespie

07, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Head of Queensland police taskforce says ‘keeping children in detention’ not the solution
George Marchesini says new group will focus on preventing youth offending and work to address underlying complex factors

Eden Gillespie

01, Feb, 2023 @7:38 AM

Article image
Using Queensland’s own laws to highlight the government’s youth justice failings does not make judges soft | Ben Smee
The judiciary has exposed how children are being treated and yet it is still blamed for the recidivism that occurs as a result

Ben Smee

03, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Queensland passes controversial youth crime laws after heated human rights debate
New laws include the overriding of the Human Rights Act to allow children to be charged for breaching bail

Eden Gillespie

16, Mar, 2023 @7:42 AM

Article image
Queensland to override state’s Human Rights Act in bid to make breach of bail an offence for children
Police minister Mark Ryan says the government accepts that its new laws ‘are incompatible with human rights’

Eden Gillespie

21, Feb, 2023 @3:38 AM

Article image
‘Public anxiety’ no justification to override Human Rights Act on youth crime laws, Queensland MPs told
Human rights commissioner Scott McDougall warns against making breach of bail an offence for children at tense parliamentary committee hearing

Eden Gillespie

28, Feb, 2023 @7:44 AM

Article image
Nazi salute will be captured in proposed ban on hate symbols, Queensland government says
Proposed bill also aims to ensure those who commit crimes motivated by prejudice face tougher penalties

Eden Gillespie

29, Mar, 2023 @1:59 AM