Voters in fast-growing suburbs have some of Melbourne’s worst access to services, analysis shows

Safe seats are more likely to lack social infrastructure such as libraries, childcare and sports facilities, researchers say

Outer suburban electorates with high rates of growth have some of Melbourne’s worst access to social infrastructure, despite political parties closely watching the areas ahead of the Victorian state election, new analysis has shown.

Based on research conducted by the Australian Urban Observatory, half of the 20 suburban electorates with the lowest liveability rankings are located in the outer north and south-west.


They include Labor heartland seats and some where independent candidates are attempting to harness frustration about infrastructure pressures on the region’s ballooning population.

However, 12 are “safe” seats, held on margins higher than 5%. The director of the Australian Urban Observatory, Dr Melanie Davern, said voters in safe seats were often disadvantaged by poorer access to services.

“If you want to live somewhere, perhaps you want to live in a marginal seat,” she said. “The marginal seats are where people are trying to provide services whereas when you’re in a safe seat, it’s easier to not be worried.”

The observatory’s “social infrastructure index” is based on access to 16 key everyday services, including childcare services, GP clinics, sporting facilities and libraries.

Richmond topped the list, with a score 13. Other inner-city seats, including Melbourne, Brunswick, Prahran and Albert Park, also ranked highly.

But the ultra marginal Labor-held electorate of Nepean – on the Mornington peninsula in Melbourne’s south-east – had the lowest infrastructure ranking, scoring 2.53 from a possible score of 16.

Nepean’s Labor MP, Chris Brayne, who won the seat off the Liberal party at the 2018 election, said he had received no response after writing to politicians to improve the area’s infrastructure access for years.


He pointed to the rebuilding of local schools and the Rye Pier as achievements during his first term.

“Slowly but steadily, things are finally starting to happen on the Mornington peninsula,” he said. “We had politicians on the peninsula who took us for granted.

“We don’t need patchy election promises, we need someone who will keep getting things done.”

But Liberal candidate Sam Groth said a Coalition government would deliver for the electorate by upgrading the Mornington Peninsula Freeway and redeveloping Rosebud hospital.

“Under the Andrews-Labor government, communities across Nepean have been short-changed on critical road and community infrastructure,” he said.

In Melbourne’s west, the latest census data showed some of the fastest-growing local government areas can be found.

The Labor-held electorate of Werribee – about 30km south-west of the city – had a score of 4.43.

The chair of council advisory committee LeadWest, Peter Maynard, said state and federal governments needed to invest in the region.

“We need to cater for the current population, but also to plan and accommodate for future growth,” Maynard said.

“The outer western suburbs are booming with population growth expected to more than double in the next 30 years, so there is a lot of work to do, let alone preparing for future needs.”

Maynard, the mayor of Wyndham City, said LeadWest had been calling for a co-designed mental health program, particularly for young people in the region, as well as increased cycling connections and a review of the area’s bus networks.

Davern said across the country, growth areas had long been subjected to poor planning, where key services did not arrive until the population reached critical mass.

“Nobody’s actually thinking about when we put the houses in, what kind of services can we put in there,” she said.

“We wait up to 10 years or more before people get even a supermarket and maybe even a school.”

Davern said the research found access to the 16 services had an impact on people’s life satisfaction and happiness.

“Social infrastructure has sometimes been described as soft infrastructure,” she said. “But it’s definitely not soft in terms of the impact it makes on people’s lives.”


Adeshola Ore and Josh Nicholas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Melbourne’s eastern suburbs are ground zero in battle for Liberal party’s future
Hawthorn and Kew seen as vital seats for the Victorian Liberals, still reeling from their federal election rout

Benita Kolovos

31, Oct, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Discontent in Melbourne’s west is seeing Labor’s rivals getting ready to shake the party’s stronghold
Liberal and independent candidates are united in accusing the government of neglecting the region and its infrastructure

Adeshola Ore Photography: Chris Hopkins

05, Nov, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Labor takes Melbourne council to court over removal of Victoria election campaign billboards
Exclusive: ‘Greens dominated’ Darebin council accused of ‘blatant political interference’ for removing signs in state seat of Northcote

Benita Kolovos and Cait Kelly

21, Nov, 2022 @11:39 PM

Article image
From bail reform to Covid: the five issues missing from the Victoria state election campaign
Amid the pledges for new hospitals, power bill relief and $2 public transport fares, other important matters have been noticeably absent

Cait Kelly, Benita Kolovos and Adeshola Ore

23, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Young Victorians caught in cycle of homelessness despair of missed education
Campaigners call on state government to act on crisis, as most young people who approach homelessness services are turned away

Cait Kelly

23, Nov, 2022 @5:52 AM

Article image
In the battle for Melbourne’s Bayside, can fired-up independents snatch seats?
Razor-thin margins put Brighton, Caulfield and Sandringham within striking distance this Victorian election – but the major parties remain quietly confident

Benita Kolovos

11, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
‘The surprise element is gone’: how Victoria’s Nationals won voters back from independents
The major parties are now better prepared to fight them, says one defeated candidate, as Nationals win back seats in former strongholds

Adeshola Ore

03, Dec, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Leaked video shows Glenn Druery bragging of working with CFMEU to help Labor hobble Greens
Opposition refers ALP to Ibac over video of so-called ‘preference whisperer’ skiting about 2018 Victoria election deal

Benita Kolovos and Adeshola Ore

17, Nov, 2022 @1:31 AM

Article image
No matter who wins, both major parties have made this Victorian poll the Daniel Andrews election
Sources say the Liberal strategy of focusing the campaign around the premier is working, with Labor unsure of how to respond

Benita Kolovos

25, Nov, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
One Nation on track to have its first MP in Victorian parliament
Rikkie-Lee Tyrrell expected to enter upper house, where Labor needs six crossbench votes to pass legislation

Benita Kolovos

12, Dec, 2022 @2:00 PM