Will Morrison’s new ‘forever’ friends speak louder than Barnaby Joyce on climate? | Katharine Murphy

The PM’s Aukus partners, Biden and Johnson, are on a backslapping unity ticket of ambition on combatting global heating

Scott Morrison flies to Washington next week. So does the British prime minister Boris Johnson. On current planning, Australia’s prime minister will see Joe Biden and Johnson in the US capital on Tuesday, and not on a screen, which feels strangely audacious from locked-down Canberra.

Morrison will fly into a diplomatically hectic week. The core purpose of his trip is to participate in the first face-to-face leaders meeting of the Quad – an informal security grouping of Australia, the US, India and Japan. Biden will host this group on Friday; a foursome of leaders orbiting around a cold war in the Indo-Pacific triggered by China’s increasing assertiveness.

Fronting the Quad is not the only item on Morrison’s dance card. The prime minister is expected to participate in a Biden-led summit about the pandemic and vaccines. The president is hosting this virtual event on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly. Reports suggest Biden will be asking political and business leaders to commit to vaccinating 70% of the world’s population by next September.

The Quad, scheduled for Friday, will also work up proposals on vaccines. A virtual meeting of this group in March ended with a promise to boost manufacturing to help low-income countries, and Australian officials are expecting leaders to emerge after the discussions next Friday promising a strong step up in vaccine development and delivery.

On current planning, as well as Biden’s pandemic summit and the Quad, Morrison will attend a reception marking the 70th anniversary of the Anzus alliance. He’ll have breakfast with the vice-president Kamala Harris and see the leaders of financial institutions, like the World Bank, as well as meeting members of key committees in the US legislature that deal with foreign affairs, intelligence and armed services.

Morrison will also deliver a pre-recorded address to the UN because his speaking slot clashes with the Quad meeting. And he’ll catch up with Pacific leaders and the secretary general of the UN during a virtual hook up on Thursday.

Tuesday’s meeting with Biden will be the first grip and grin on US soil. Last time Morrison dropped by, Donald Trump indulged a dialogue with himself in the Oval Office about whether or not to launch a military strike against Iran, and Gina Rinehart floated through a Rose Garden soiree in a bejewelled white evening gown.

The coming visit will be important, but I suspect less surreal.

Morrison will see Johnson (who he saw in London earlier in the year) because Biden happens to be hosting the British leader next week (more on the why of that shortly). As well as the foursome, he’ll also have one-on-ones with Narendra Modi and Yoshihide Suga – who is on his way out of the prime ministership of Japan.

Obviously the coming trip had a significant prelude. Biden, Johnson and Morrison unveiled a new agreement to construct nuclear powered submarines – a deal these leaders cooked up in total secrecy. Morrison told Modi and Suga about the submarine agreement on Wednesday night before he told his own backbench.

In reality this new agreement is very thin. Morrison’s “forever partnership” right now is a handshake and a weird acronym. It’s an agreement to work out in 18 months whether or not an agreement can proceed.

Costs? Undisclosed, but astronomical. (Morrison told us cheerfully this week that defence spending was an elevator that would only go up). Delivery? A submarine in the water by 2040 – possibly – assuming this new bit of defence procurement isn’t a rolling botch-up, which would be a big assumption given the history in this country. And given our interim self-defence plan is patched up Collins-class vessels, and more frequent visits from our heavily armed friends, we can only hope China is generous enough to hold our beer until our lethal weapons arrive.

But pointing out the paucity of hard facts while indulging a chuckle about whether or not Biden momentarily forgot Morrison’s name when the Aukus deal was unveiled shouldn’t obscure the significance of what’s just happened.

Morrison has just presided over a consequential point in time in Australia’s 21st century strategic policy. Thursday’s announcement, coordinated across the Pacific and the Atlantic, arrived like a thunderclap, because it is momentous.

Momentous, because before things went seriously south in Australia’s relationship with Beijing, there used to be lots of tut-tutting about false binaries when journalists asked if the time would come when Australia would have to chose between our most important security ally, and our largest economic partner.

This tut-tutting was reasonable to the extent that the question always had an obvious answer. Australia would always look to America if China’s nationalist-fuelled, grievance-laden bellicosity forced our hand. Liberal democracies are like that. They travel in packs. Middle powers need the protection of great ones.

But for a long time, Australia studiously avoided being explicit about the choice we would ultimately make. We wanted it both ways.

Well, that extended period of artful non-specificity is over. It’s over with a capital “O”. Australia is all in with the military complex of the US and Britain. We are a wholly owned subsidiary of the great powers in a dangerous region where escalating militarisation narrows the scope for transactional pragmatism between neighbours with different values and political systems.

That’s Australia’s reality.

It was our reality before this nuclear submarine pact threw it into sharp relief. The highly choreographed atmospherics of the deal voids any remaining grey area.

So the coming week will be about security, yes. But the other pressing issue of our time is global heating.

On that issue, Morrison’s nuclear submarine “forever” partners, Biden and Johnson are on a backslapping unity ticket of ambition, while Australia is still working out just how miserable we can be at the Cop26 in Glasgow without being heckled out of the room. After the tumult of the past week, perhaps the chief heckler will be Emmanuel Macron.

Johnson will be in Washington next week in part to coordinate efforts with Biden ahead of the Glasgow Cop. Morrison fully expects to be pressed on climate policy in his bilaterals with Biden and Johnson, and then again through the Quad grouping, given Japan has increased its ambition.

This didn’t get much attention, but a public statement issued after defence talks between the US and Australia late this week, interestingly, contained stronger language around climate action than we’d routinely see from Australia.

That statement committed the US and Australia to “enhanced actions during the 2020s with the aim of achieving net zero emissions as early as possible”. It acknowledged climate change was a “global security threat”. It committed the two governments to strengthening climate action ahead of the Cop “through ambitious nationally determined contributions, with 2030 targets”. On net zero by 2050, the language reflected Australia’s technology mantra. “Our joint ambition is to make low-emissions technologies globally scalable and commercially viable to rapidly accelerate global emissions reductions, enable clean growth, and make achievement of net zero emissions by 2050 possible”.

Australian officials say new climate commitments aren’t expected from Morrison next week, although there is some stakeholder talk about technology partnerships through the Quad and possible assistance from Australia to developing countries to finance low-emissions capability.

In terms of what Australia will ultimately say at Glasgow, the government is working to a timetable of an announcement in the middle of next month.

Senior US officials and Johnson have been happy to express displeasure with Australia’s unconscionable climate record in recent times.

It will be interesting to see if Biden chooses to apply a bit of polite public pressure to the visiting laggards next week.

I don’t know if Biden will go there or not.

But I do know there’s a glaring contradiction Morrison should address – and it’s this.

Why is Australia willing to be a wholly owned subsidiary of the US and the UK on military matters, trading away sovereignty, offering allies a blank cheque commitment on the rationale that prime ministers don’t keep receipts when they are saving the country from an existential threat?

But when it comes to another pressing existential threat, runaway global heating – a problem just as visible as the militarisation of the South China Sea – Australia can promise nothing unless Barnaby Joyce gets a spreadsheet identifying the precise costs of the transition for the average worker in Muswellbrook, and graciously grants his permission?

I mean, seriously. What a crock.


Katharine Murphy

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Morrison expects US to ramp up military presence in region as China attacks ‘irresponsible’ defence pact
Beijing denounces Aukus pact, raising question of nuclear proliferation, as Morrison expects a greater US military presence in Indo-Pacific and deeper UK defence ties

Daniel Hurst and Katharine Murphy

16, Sep, 2021 @10:34 AM

Article image
The nuclear option: why has Australia ditched the French submarine plan for the Aukus pact?
Just two weeks before the bombshell, senior ministers from both countries met and declared they were ‘committed to cooperation’. How did it all go so wrong?

Daniel Hurst

17, Sep, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Game-changer or irresponsible? The known unknowns on Australia’s nuclear submarine deal
Analysis: Stay tuned as we battle the notoriously secret defence establishment to work out what we are getting and when, and maybe why and whether it’s worth it

Tory Shepherd

17, Sep, 2021 @8:35 AM

Article image
‘Right decision’ to scrap French submarines but South Australian jobs will be lost
Senator Rex Patrick says there were doubts over the Shortfin Barracuda but ‘it’s a huge jump’ to building a nuclear submarine

Tory Shepherd

16, Sep, 2021 @7:20 AM

Article image
Australia nuclear submarine deal: Aukus defence pact with US and UK means $90bn contract with France will be scrapped
Scott Morrison says nuclear-powered submarines will be built in Adelaide under the Aukus framework announced with Joe Biden and Boris Johnson

Katharine Murphy and Daniel Hurst

16, Sep, 2021 @1:41 AM

Article image
Diplomacy dialled up to 11: Australia saddles up with US as Indo-Pacific heads for cold war | Katharine Murphy
Australia didn’t announce the ‘forever partnership’ while Donald Trump was in the White House. What happens if he returns?

Katharine Murphy

16, Sep, 2021 @9:40 AM

Article image
‘That fella down under’: Joe Biden forgets Scott Morrison’s name during historic pact announcement
US president calls Australian prime minister ‘that fella down under’ at press conference for new trilateral security partnership

Justine Landis-Hanley

16, Sep, 2021 @4:14 AM

Article image
Aukus pact: UK and US battle to contain international backlash
Nuclear submarine deal with Australia draws criticism from allies and China amid fears of conflict

Dan Sabbagh, Julian Borger, Helen Davidson and Angelique Chrisafis

16, Sep, 2021 @7:48 PM

Article image
Scott Morrison tells Cop26 Australia will exceed 2030 target in bid to fend off criticism
Glasgow conference is focused on more ambitious 2030 cuts but, while PM says Australia may cut emissions by 35%, the 26% to 28% target won’t be changed

Katharine Murphy in Glasgow

01, Nov, 2021 @8:16 PM

Article image
Making waves in the Pacific: how Boris Johnson’s Global Britain went rogue
Defence pact with Australia and the US increases chance of confrontation with China and spurs nuclear proliferation

Simon Tisdall

19, Sep, 2021 @6:30 AM