Biloela Tamil family to be granted new three-month bridging visas to stay in Australia

Friend of the Murugappans welcomes announcement by immigration minister but says family ‘are still essentially trapped in Perth in community detention’

The Murugappan family from Biloela will be allowed to stay in Australia for at least another three months after the immigration minister, Alex Hawke, told a court he intended to renew their bridging visas next week.

Hawke initially announced in late June he had granted three-month bridging visas to parents Nades and Priya and their daughter Kopika, so they could live in community detention in Perth while the youngest daughter, Tharnicaa, received medical treatment after being evacuated from Christmas Island.

Those visas are due to expire on Wednesday and there was concern among the family’s supporters that without valid visas they could be put back into immigration detention or removed from Australia.

Hawke, through his barrister Stephen Lloyd, told the federal circuit court on Thursday he was prepared to extend their visas next week for another three months, subject to any adverse events or evidence.

Family friend Simone Cameron welcomed the announcement but said it meant the family’s situation was largely unchanged. “They are still essentially trapped in Perth, in community detention along with little Tharni,” she said.

A week before the 23 June visa announcement, the Department of Home Affairs wrote to the family advising them Hawke proposed to “lower the bar” in immigration law, which would then prevent three of the members of the family – Nades, Priya and Kopika – from reapplying for bridging visas.

The case before the court on Thursday centred on how the “close of business” is defined in a time when government departments and businesses often communicate up to 24 hours a day.

In the invitation to comment, the department said the family could make submissions on whether the bar should be lowered by 22 June.

The family’s lawyer, Carina Ford, passed on a submission to the department at 5.45pm AEST on 22 June. However, the department did not consider this submission when ultimately providing a brief to Hawke an hour later, and 22 minutes after the brief was received, Hawke decided to lower the bar.

Federal circuit court judge Heather Riley has been asked to rule on whether the family was denied procedural fairness in the decision by not taking into account the submissions sent to the department at 5.45pm.

“There’s a measure, we submit, of unreasonableness in which the department rushed to a decision without checking to see whether there was a submission put to them,” Angel Aleksov, the barrister acting for the family, said.

Lloyd argued the invitation stated submissions needed to be provided by close of business on 22 June and close of business was understood to be 5pm Canberra time.

The family’s lawyer, Carina Ford, gave evidence to the court on Thursday that she was not aware of the 5pm deadline and the definition of “close of business” was a grey area. She pointed out often people within the department would be responding to emails at all hours and, on that particular day, she sent the email to the department after finishing up with another client at 5.30pm and her work day didn’t finish until 7pm.

“The issue of what constitutes close of business is the grey area,” she said.

On Thursday afternoon, the family’s barrister, Angel Aleksov, asked home affairs department assistant secretary Belinda Gill whether it was reasonable to consider after 5pm to still be before the close of business when staff in the department would often work longer hours.

Given the correspondence was addressed to the family, who are currently based in Perth, Aleksov also raised questions about how “close of business” could be understood to be 5pm Canberra time when it would be later in Perth.

Gill suggested she didn’t really talk to her colleagues about when they usually finished.

Ford told the court she was initially “shocked” to hear the bar could be lowered because she hadn’t known it had been lifted at some point previously allowing the family members to apply for a visa. The ongoing legal battle – since their visas expired in 2018 and they were removed from Biloela – had been on the understanding they were not able to apply for a visa.

Closing submissions will be due to the court by 1 October and judgment has been reserved.

The case before the federal circuit court does not apply to Tharnicaa because a brief on her case is currently before Hawke.


Josh Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Three members of Biloela family granted temporary bridging visas
Immigration minister Alex Hawke grants visas, meaning family will be released from community detention in Perth

Daniel Hurst , Josh Taylor and Paul Karp

23, Jun, 2021 @6:44 AM

Article image
Biloela family to reunite on Australian mainland but visa status expected to remain unchanged
The immigration minister, Alex Hawke, is set to announce the Murugappan family will be released from detention on Christmas Island

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

14, Jun, 2021 @9:53 AM

Article image
Coalition says community detention not a pathway to resettlement for Biloela family
Campaigners say minister’s decision must be ‘first step’ in returning Murugappans to Queensland

Katharine Murphy and Sarah Martin

15, Jun, 2021 @7:46 AM

Article image
Biloela Tamil family deportation case: asylum seekers can stay until final hearing
Federal court rules the family has a prima facie case to stay, and government cannot deport them to Sri Lanka until a final hearing

Josh Taylor

19, Sep, 2019 @4:56 AM

Article image
Tamil family from Biloela fight fresh deportation appeal
Federal government denies that requesting a briefing on the family days before the 2019 election indicated minister was considering allowing Tharunicaa to apply for a visa, court hears

Josh Taylor

14, Oct, 2020 @6:49 AM

Article image
Biloela Tamil family separated as mother flown to Perth for medical treatment
Priya Murugappan moved after doctors on Christmas Island unable to identify cause of pain, but she says ‘the greater pain’ is separation from young children

Hannah Ryan

20, Jul, 2020 @2:43 AM

Article image
Home affairs minister suggests reports about Biloela daughter’s illness ‘inaccurate’
Karen Andrews refuses to say what is not correct after Tharnicaa was evacuated from Christmas Island to Perth to treat a blood infection caused by pneumonia

Josh Taylor

16, Jun, 2021 @5:33 AM

Article image
Tamil asylum seeker family remains in Australia after last-minute reprieve
Family taken into detention in dawn raid a week ago reprieved just before take-off to Sri Lanka

Ben Doherty

14, Mar, 2018 @7:36 AM

Article image
Peter Dutton could grant visas to the Biloela family – his powers are broad and sweeping | Ben Doherty
The ministerial power to grant a visa is unchallengeable, and its use is not novel

Ben Doherty

02, Sep, 2019 @10:00 PM

Article image
Keeping Biloela family locked up on Christmas Island cost Australia $1.4m last year
Detention of Tamil family denounced as ‘morally disgraceful and obscenely expensive’ as visa case for Australian-born daughter remains locked in federal court

Josh Taylor

07, Jan, 2021 @4:49 AM