Australia must guard against ‘malign actors’ disrupting our elections, Jenny McAllister says

New intelligence committee deputy chair calls on government to clarify security agencies’ roles in countering foreign interference

Australia must guard against attempts by foreign governments to “deliberately disrupt” its political system and elections, the new deputy chair of parliament’s powerful intelligence committee says.

New South Wales Labor senator Jenny McAllister accused the government of failing to make clear which agency was responsible for managing the risk of foreign interference during elections, meaning critical decisions might be made “on the run”.

McAllister sounded the alarm in her first substantive interview since being appointed to replace Anthony Byrne as the deputy chair of the intelligence and security committee.

Byrne resigned from the bipartisan committee – which receives sensitive intelligence briefings and reviews a raft of national security laws – after giving evidence to Victoria’s corruption watchdog about branch stacking allegations.

In a podcast published on Thursday, McAllister said Australia must “be very aware of the potential for malign actors to deliberately disrupt our political system”.

“We also need to be aware that the opportunity to do so is enhanced if we allow our political system and all of the infrastructure around it to degrade,” she told the Australian National University’s National Security Podcast.

“It is not clear to me which government agency is actually responsible for managing the possibility of foreign interference in an election period. I think that failing to designate a lead agency leads to the risk that people may make decisions on the run, and that is not a recipe for good decision making.”

McAllister believes national security agencies are aware of the risks and said it required “leadership from the top to really bring this to a close and to identify which agency is going to take the lead and to define the scope of their responsibilities”.

The issue of disinformation being used as a tool of state-backed foreign interference – including in the lead-up to elections – was also raised during Senate estimates hearings this week.

The Asio chief, Mike Burgess, said his intelligence agency had “seen nation states lining up issues in an attempt to provide disinformation on certain topics”.

“Do we expect that before an election? Maybe,” Burgess said. “We’ll continue to watch that, with other agencies, and put out the appropriate advice at the time.”

Burgess said his response would depend on the nature of the problem, but he would have a conversation with the electoral commissioner and the prime minister and the opposition leader if such activity was detected during a campaign.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

“Our democracy is fairly robust … but of course we wouldn’t let it rest, the community would not let it rest if we saw a nation state engaged in acts of misinformation or disinformation,” Burgess said. “That would be drawn to the government’s attention and during caretaker [mode] be drawn to both parties’ attention.”

McAllister has a longstanding interest in the issue, as chair of a Senate select committee into foreign interference through social media.

In the interview, McAllister defined national security widely as including “our capacity to maintain an inclusive set of democratic institutions that the broad public can have confidence in”.

Across the western world, McAllister said, many key institutions had experienced a decline in public trust. But she viewed measures to increase trust in democratic institutions – including establishing a national integrity commission – and tackling inequality as “enormously” important.

McAllister also argued increased powers and funding for security agencies should be accompanied by greater scrutiny.


Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Foreign actors targeted Facebook users during Australian 2019 election, thinktank finds
Country’s democracy at risk by actions that can ‘affect electoral outcomes’, says submission to Senate inquiry

Katharine Murphy Political editor

21, Jun, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
Facebook says it doesn’t need news stories for its business and won’t pay to share them in Australia
Social media giant rejects ACCC proposal, saying it could cut out news completely without any significant impact on its business

Naaman Zhou and Amanda Meade

15, Jun, 2020 @1:00 AM

Article image
Consumer watchdog may investigate if Facebook data illegally used in Australian elections
ACCC and information commission both signal possibility of separate investigations in wake of Guardian revelations

Helen Davidson

20, Mar, 2018 @1:36 AM

Article image
Australia urged to manufacture mRNA Covid vaccines onshore to guard against supply disruption
Without the technology to produce mRNA vaccines such as the Pfizer jab, Australia and region remain ‘vulnerable to supply shocks’, scientists warn

Melissa Davey

23, Feb, 2021 @4:22 AM

Article image
Australia could implement mandatory age verification for pornography websites
A government report calls for users to verify their age before access despite the UK abandoning similar proposals

Josh Taylor

05, Mar, 2020 @2:11 AM

Article image
Russian Twitter trolls stoking anti-Islamic sentiment in Australia, experts warn
Researchers say Russia-linked accounts strongly back Julian Assange and try to destabilise democracy by amplifying social divisions

Paul Karp

20, Nov, 2018 @1:27 AM

Article image
Public servants warned against liking anti-government social media posts
Union says Australian Public Service Commission advice a restriction on right to participate in democracy

Paul Karp

07, Aug, 2017 @2:24 AM

Article image
Australia passes social media law penalising platforms for violent content
Labor supports legislation in response to Christchurch shooting that threatens jail for executives, despite media companies’ concerns

Paul Karp

04, Apr, 2019 @2:09 AM

Article image
Facebook's botched Australia news ban hits health departments, charities and its own pages
Social media company’s ban on sharing news has also affected dozens of government, not-for-profit and community pages

Josh Taylor

18, Feb, 2021 @1:49 AM

Article image
If Facebook and Google limit services in Australia, could the ABC run a social network?
A new paper suggests a publicly funded replacement could be form part of the government’s response if the tech giants limit access

Amanda Meade

18, Oct, 2020 @9:00 PM