Intersex people undergo surgery when too young to give consent, inquiry told

Australian Human Rights Commission recommends new legislative protections for children

Intersex people have endured controversial surgeries and treatments, often when they were too young to provide consent, an inquiry by the Australian Human Rights Commission found in a report that recommends new legislative protections for children.

The commission has been consulting with intersex people, their family members, peer-support and advocacy organisations, clinicians, and legal and human rights groups to make recommendations on how best to protect the human rights of people born intersex when it comes to medical procedures.

Intersex refers to people who are born with genetic, hormonal or physical sex characteristics that do not conform to medical norms for male or female bodies. Intersex people have a diversity of bodies and identities.

The commission’s final report, published on Monday, included experiences from intersex people who had a range of medical interventions without their consent, including surgery intended to “normalise” the appearance of genitalia.

The commission heard about people undergoing surgeries to reduce the size of the clitoris [known as clitoridectomy or clitorectomy]; other surgeries to modify female genitalia such as reducing the size or modifying the shape of the labia minora [labiaplasty]; surgery on external female genitals, generally reducing the size or addressing the asymmetry of the labia minora [vulvoplasty], and surgery on an infant born with smaller than usual male genitalia [micropenis] to create the appearance of a female child by the construction of a vagina [vaginoplasty].

The commission was also told people were put on hormone treatment to facilitate typical male or female sex development.

The report recommends new legislation so that medical interventions take place only with the prior, informed, personal consent of the person concerned, except in the case where the treatment is a medical necessity.

Whenever a medical intervention is proposed for a person under the age of 18, the medical treatment team should seek authorisation from an independent panel, the commission recommended.

“There should be criminal penalties for not complying with these requirements,” the recommendations said. “It is the commission’s view, however, that parents should not be subject to criminal sanctions.”

The commission heard about medical interventions that had a variety of negative consequences on people’s physical and mental wellbeing. A lack of access to records about past experiences and interventions compounded this trauma.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

One individual told the commission how “lots of men would look between my legs, put their fingers in my vagina, and talk about how abnormal I was”. People reported ongoing issues due to treatments and surgeries such as loss of fertility, urinary tract issues, and loss or diminution of sexual function, sensitivity and/or capacity to experience sexual pleasure.

“The size of the population who may be affected is not clear,” the report found.

“There is a lack of data collection on population size and on frequency and types of interventions that have occurred. About 1.7% of the population is estimated to have some variation in sex characteristics, though there is some contention about the accuracy of this figure.”

The executive director of Intersex Human Rights Australia, Morgan Carpenter, said people with innate variations of sex characteristics had been subject to ongoing human rights abuses.

“The report identifies key problems with current clinical practice, including lack of evidence, a reliance on psychosocial rationales that are better addressed by peer support and other forms of support, and a lack of attention to concerns raised by psychological and psychiatric professionals,” she said.

“Today we’re calling on state, territory and commonwealth governments to act to end these abuses. We need new laws that recognise our right to decide what happens to our own bodies.”


Melissa Davey Medical editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
National ban sought on sonic anti-loitering device aimed at young people
Queensland solicitor’s success in having shopping centre stop using high-pitched ‘Mosquito’ drives push for it to be barred around the country

Joshua Robertson

30, Jun, 2016 @4:46 AM

Article image
Surgeon performed unnecessary hysterectomy without consent, tribunal told
Exclusive: Dr Emil Shawky Gayed allegedly operated on women without realising they were pregnant and removed one patient’s healthy ovary

Melissa Davey

07, Jun, 2018 @8:05 PM

Article image
Religious discrimination bill may breach constitution by allowing doctors to refuse treatment
Coalition’s proposal criticised for giving more weight to the beliefs of religious people

Paul Karp

30, Sep, 2019 @7:16 AM

Article image
Human rights groups set deadline to get all refugee children off Nauru
Coalition of NGOs and charities calls for children to be brought to Australia by 20 November

Helen Davidson

19, Aug, 2018 @10:00 PM

Article image
Private health insurance: tactics to lure young people ineffective, Senate told
Under-30s need to be shown the cover is relevant to them and worth their while in terms of their budgets, insurer NIB says

Melissa Davey

10, Aug, 2017 @11:57 PM

Article image
Women the decision-makers when starting a family, study finds
Australian study also finds traditional gender roles prevalent, and each additional $1,000 earned by a woman’s partner increases her pregnancy probability by 1.5%

Calla Wahlquist

20, Jul, 2016 @1:41 AM

Article image
Doctor denounces News Corp’s ‘inaccurate’ coverage of Melbourne gender clinic, inquiry hears
Michelle Telfer says the Australian newspaper published disinformation that created ‘fear and anxiety’ and ‘attempted to destroy my professional reputation’

Josh Taylor

25, Feb, 2021 @3:30 AM

Article image
Aboriginal people in prison and out-of-home care suffering under 'punitive' Covid-19 restrictions
Report reveals inmates going without soap and children in out-of-home care system being refused contact with families

Lorena Allam

27, May, 2020 @12:57 AM

Article image
More young girls asking GPs about genital cosmetic surgery, study finds
Fashion, online pornography, perceptions of beauty and Brazilian waxes contributing to women’s dissatisfaction with their genitals, study author says

Melissa Davey

06, Oct, 2016 @3:27 AM

Article image
National disability insurance scheme 'faceless' and rigid, inquiry told
Fears children could miss out on crucial early intervention services amid reports of families waiting 18 months for help

Christopher Knaus

19, Sep, 2017 @5:00 AM