Legal experts condemn Scott Morrison’s continuing attacks on Icac as ‘disgraceful’ and ‘stupid’

PM doubles down on denigrating NSW corruption watchdog as Liberals push for ex-premier Gladys Berejiklian to contest Warringah

Legal experts have labelled Scott Morrison’s latest attacks on the New South Wales corruption watchdog “disgraceful” and “stupid”, as the Liberal party ramps up efforts to have Gladys Berejiklian contest the federal seat of Warringah.

On Monday, the prime minister doubled down on his previous comments in parliament last week when he called the Independent Commission Against Corruption a “kangaroo court,” and accused it of trying to “publicly humiliate” the former NSW premier.

“Gladys was put in a position of actually having to stand down and there was no findings of anything,” Morrison said on Monday, in advance of any possible findings by Icac. Berejiklian resigned voluntarily in September, in line with her own ruling that an MP who is a substantial subject of an investigation must stand aside.

“I don’t call that justice. What I saw was a pile on,” Morrison said.

Icac is investigating whether Berejiklian failed to declare a conflict of interest due to her secret relationship with the then MP for Wagga, Daryl Maguire, when she was involved in awarding lucrative grants to Maguire’s electorate as treasurer and later as premier. Berejiklian has denied any wrongdoing and Icac is yet to hand down its findings.

There’s growing speculation the former NSW premier will put her hand up for Liberal preselection to run against Zali Steggall in the northern Sydney electorate, after the independent won it from former prime minister Tony Abbott in 2019.

The chair of the Centre for Public Integrity and former NSW supreme court judge, Anthony Whealy, criticised Morrison for dismissing the serious issues raised by the Icac inquiry.

“Even those who admire Berejiklian for many of her qualities when she was premier, realise there has to be a serious inquiry into the situation that arose … in unloading millions of dollars of public money into the Wagga electorate at the same time she was in a relationship with the member for Wagga,” he said.

“For Morrison to dismiss that as being of no significance, is to trash integrity and accountability in the most terrible fashion,” he said.

For her part, Berejiklian insisted before Icac that Maguire was treated just like any other MP and that she did not consider she needed to disclose the relationship, which was a personal matter.

Whealy said calling it a kangaroo court showed the prime minister “had no idea what NSW Icac legislation says, because it is not a court at all.”

“It’s an investigative body that is precisely the same as a royal commission. No one suggested that the royal commissions into banking or trade unions, or aged care were kangaroos courts and they were conducted in public,” he said.

“To accuse Icac in this way, is to blatantly misunderstand its nature or it’s a wilful refusal to acknowledge what its true function is,” he said.

Former judge of the Victorian court of appeal Stephen Charles SC said Morrison’s comments were “disgraceful”.

“I thought that what they indicated that he was hoping the former premier would stand against Zali Steggall and that Icac’s activities were interfering with his wishes.”

Barrister Geoffrey Watson, who was counsel assisting Icac in its investigation of Labor MP, Eddie Obeid, said Morrison was “trivialising” Icac’s investigation when he accused it of simply investigating her personal relationship.

“It’s not that he’s said it’s a kangaroo court, that’s just stupid. It’s that he said it was an investigation into who was her boyfriend. That’s a trivialisation of an investigation into whether there had been compliance at the highest level with a code of conduct. You set the standards from the top,” he said.

“But what I found really awful was he suggested that Icac had pursued this as a politically motivated agenda – and that was quite improper, and he should apologise to the people and Icac for that remark,” he said.

The Law Council of Australia has called for “moderation in the debate over the proposed federal anti-corruption commission” after Morrison’s “kangaroo court” comment last week.

“Respect for legal institutions underpins the administration of justice in Australia. The structure and powers of any commission are important topics for discussion, but any commentary must be tempered by fairness and balance,” Law Council of Australia president, Dr Jacoba Brasch QC, said.

Morrison has made much of the fact that Berejiklian has not been accused of criminal conduct.

But University of Sydney professor of constitutional law, Anne Twomey said the definition of corrupt conduct was much broader in NSW than that of criminality.

“So you can be found to have engaged in corrupt conduct if you have misused your public office by acting in a manner that is dishonest or partial, by misusing public information or those sorts of things she said.”

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

“I have noted what they are trying to do is to redefine the meaning of corruption so that corruption is only when you have committed a criminal offence,” she said of the federal government.

Twomey said that there was no legal bar to Berejiklian running for federal parliament while an investigation by Icac was yet to make findings. Section 44 of the constitution prevents a person holding public office if they have been convicted of a criminal offence that carries a sentence of one year or more.

“She hasn’t been convicted of anything and as far as I know Icac is not contemplating that,” she said.

Charles agreed there was nothing stopping her from standing for federal office.

“However, it is dangerous for those who choose to put her forward for election because there is always the prospect that she might get an adverse finding and that would be seriously disadvantageous.”

Berejiklian has not yet declared any intention to run for the Federal seat.

However Whealy said it would be hard to see the consistency between Berejiklian deciding she should step down of her own volition because of an ongoing inquiry into her integrity and then immediately stand as the member for Warringah.

“There is no imperative from a legal point of view not to stand, but politically it would be damaging for the Liberal party and for her personally because of the outstanding conclusion of the investigation, which on its face is quite a serious matter,” he said.

Contributor

Anne Davies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Menzies would be turning in his grave, Chris Kenny rails – as News Corp turns against him on climate | Weekly Beast
Old guard of conservative commentators distraught at Scott Morrison’s push for net zero

Amanda Meade

22, Oct, 2021 @1:18 AM

Article image
Former NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian rules out running for federal seat of Warringah
Former politician says ‘I want my life to change’ and will pursue a private-sector career, despite Scott Morrison urging her to contest seat

Katharine Murphy Political editor

09, Dec, 2021 @11:00 PM

Article image
Qld announces reopening plan; ACT hotspot status ends tonight – as it happened
All today’s news as it happened

Mostafa Rachwani and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

18, Oct, 2021 @8:26 AM

Article image
Gladys Berejiklian has ‘a lot more to contribute’, Scott Morrison says
PM’s comments fuel suggestions former NSW premier could run for a federal seat after Icac hearings

Paul Karp

04, Oct, 2021 @11:16 PM

Article image
Scott Morrison suspects Gladys Berejiklian may not run for federal seat of Warringah
PM says former NSW premier ‘may choose not to go ahead’ in trying to win back electorate for Liberals

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

08, Dec, 2021 @12:36 AM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: NSW voters sympathetic to Gladys Berejiklian despite Icac probe
More than 40% of survey respondents in NSW agreed with Scott Morrison’s criticism of corruption watchdog’s inquiry into former premier’s alleged conduct

Katharine Murphy Political editor

07, Dec, 2021 @6:32 AM

Article image
Icac: public servant believed Berejiklian wanted business case redone to support shooting club
NSW former premier was ‘particularly interested’ in project which initially did not meet necessary criteria, inquiry hears

Michael McGowan

21, Oct, 2021 @3:46 AM

Article image
Home Affairs assisting Icac over alleged cash-for-visa scheme linked to Daryl Maguire
Head of the department says he believes the former NSW MP may have approached the federal government to make representations about visa issues

Michael McGowan

19, Oct, 2020 @1:27 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison backs Gladys Berejiklian to run for federal seat of Warringah despite Icac cloud
Morrison says former NSW premier ‘very welcome’ in his team and calls anti-corruption inquiry ‘shameful’

Paul Karp

06, Dec, 2021 @1:32 AM

Article image
Voter confidence in Scott Morrison’s ability to manage a crisis dives as three-quarters say he plays politics
An increasing number also believe he shirks responsibility and is out of touch with ordinary people, poll suggests

Katharine Murphy Political editor

19, Jul, 2021 @5:30 PM