Piling into Palaszczuk: LNP gambles by targeting premier in Queensland election

Labor hopes voters will continue to back its coronavirus response, but conservatives are lobbing grenades over border closures

On Sunday in Brisbane, a light plane looped the city trailed by the slogan “she is heartless”. Everyone on the ground knew exactly who “she” was.

Annastacia Palaszczuk was once Queensland’s “accidental premier”; as Labor attempts to win a third successive term, it is now framing a presidential-style campaign around her massive social media following and popular pandemic leadership.

But the Liberal-National opposition – via a series of personal attacks led by the prime minister, Scott Morrison, and other federal figurers as surrogates – has begun to train its focus firmly on Palaszczuk, too.

An LNP source said the “get Palaszczuk” campaign strategy that has emerged in the past week was the sort usually used to target unpopular political leaders. In this case, it was “a huge unknown, obviously”.

“In any normal campaign, you wouldn’t want to focus too much on leadership when your opponent is well-liked or seen as a strong leader,” the LNP figure said.

“But this is not a normal election. There is one issue and it’s how the government has handled the pandemic.

“I don’t think it’s fair to say we are just aiming to [tear Palaszczuk down], you’ve got to remember she has been very quick to claim credit for [the state’s suppression strategy]. What would you expect us to do, let her take all the credit but none of the blame when things go wrong?

“But yeah, it’s no secret that whether or not Queenslanders still have faith in the premier in seven weeks’ time will probably also determine who wins.”

‘Indiscriminate swinging’

With an election on the horizon, the coronavirus pandemic has been a politically charged topic in Queensland for most of the year. Labor and the LNP have argued about policy; they’ve each claimed the other has exploited the coronavirus situation for political ends.

In April and June, the opposition leader, Deb Frecklington, called for the state border to reopen. Labor says they counted 64 times. Her quotes and soundbites will be rerun until election day. In line with polling showing widespread support for the border closure, the LNP now supports the policy.

Queensland opposition leader Deb Frecklington.
Queensland opposition leader Deb Frecklington. Photograph: Dan Peled/AAP

Political commentator Chris Salisbury, from the University of Queensland, said the LNP’s tactics had clearly sharpened in the past week, as they have sought to highlight inconsistencies in border restrictions and cases like the Canberra woman denied permission to attend her father’s funeral, where decisions have caused emotional hardship.

Salisbury says the LNP appears to be allowing high-profile surrogates like Morrison and the home affairs minister, Peter Dutton, to launch intense criticisms of Palaszczuk and her government to see what sticks.

“I think it’s become clear in the last week or two that the LNP opposition in Queensland is playing things a bit more tactically. They’re leaving a lot of the running on the strident attacks to federal colleagues.

“It seems they’ve decided to pick on these individual highly emotional cases as a means of just picking holes at what can be seen as inconsistencies in border controls. The heavy-hitting, indiscriminate swinging will be left to federal figures.”

Part of the complexity of a coronavirus election is there is no campaign template; Salisbury says the usual messages about spending, cuts and government debt are unlikely to resonate.

The need for economic stimulus, however, would allow campaigns to make large spending commitments with little scrutiny of the future budget implications.

Salisbury said the pandemic would also pose challenges for minor party candidates and independents across the state.

“We might see a bit of hardening of the votes behind the majors. The dominance of the airwaves of the narrative by the government and to a similar extent the opposition is only going to make things more difficult to minor parties.

“Pretty much the only conversation is the pandemic. That doesn’t leave a lot of room for the minor voices to make much of an impression.”

Annastacia Palaszczuk on 2 September at the announcement that Brisbane will host the AFL grand final.
Annastacia Palaszczuk on 2 September at the announcement that Brisbane will host the AFL grand final. Photograph: Darren England/AAP

Have the attacks on Palaszczuk cut through?

On Friday, Palaszczuk briefly showed some signs the pandemic had taken a personal toll. She mentioned she had “lost loved ones as well”, a reference to the death of her nanna, Beryl Erskine, in June.

That morning the federal finance minister, Matthias Cormann, had called Palaszczuk “cold-hearted” and “nasty” for the government’s refusal to allow a Canberra woman to attend her father’s funeral. The same day the Courier-Mail in Brisbane ran an opinion piece that said the premier had a “black heart”.

The pile-on has kept coming. The state’s well-regarded chief health officer, Jeannette Young, has been subject to death threats and is now under police protection.

Queensland premier Annastacia Palaszczuk (right), deputy premier Steven Miles and Queensland chief health officer Dr Jeanette Young (back) arrive at a press conference to give an update on the state’s Covid-19 border controls.
Queensland premier Annastacia Palaszczuk (right), deputy premier Steven Miles and Queensland chief health officer Dr Jeanette Young (back) arrive at a press conference to give an update on the state’s Covid-19 border controls. Photograph: Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images

How deeply these attacks will resonate in the community is unclear. Salisbury says they will have had some impact, but that they also carry significant risk.

“It was quite a concerted campaign, not only from high-profile LNP members. The Courier-Mail ran with these emotive headlines, echoing the very emotive language used about the premier.

“It will have started to bite a little in terms of the sentiment in the electorate. But by the same token there’s risks on both sides.

“There were always risks with the government sticking very hard to its strict border regime and promoting the premier as the face of the government’s successful handling. That carried with it a degree of electoral risk and it can come back and be very damaging for the premier.

“The very emotive way the prime minister went about calling into questions the premier’s approach can carry risk as well, like we have seen with the criticism that Morrison was using the episode to advance his political agenda.”

Palaszczuk’s response on Monday reinforced the single faultline that will define the campaign: an all-or nothing gamble that voters will continue to back the coronavirus response, and by extension the government.

“If it means I have to lose the election, I will risk all that if it means keeping Queenslanders safe,” she said.

“I will stand on my record, I will hold my head up high. And I will stare down those people who are trying to tear Queensland apart.

“I am going to bat for the Queenslanders, all of the families out there. Their health, and the economy of this state, and their jobs, is more important than these relentless political attacks.”


Ben Smee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Queensland election: Annastacia Palaszczuk wins historic third term
Labor holds on to regional Queensland seats and strengthens grip on south-east of state in result that could see increased majority

Ben Smee, Graham Readfearn and Amy Remeikis

31, Oct, 2020 @2:02 PM

Article image
Queensland reports eight new local Covid cases; NT chief minister in self-isolation – as it happened
Follow all the latest developments

Luke Henriques-Gomes (now) and Matilda Boseley (earlier)

30, Mar, 2021 @7:24 AM

Article image
Queensland to enforce hard border closure with NSW and ACT from Saturday
Annastacia Palaszczuk made the surprise announcement as border closures shape up as key battle ground for the Queensland election in October

Ben Smee

05, Aug, 2020 @1:21 AM

Article image
Queensland election: George Christensen blames Turnbull after poor LNP result
Federal Nationals MP apologises to One Nation voters for the LNP failing to ‘stand up more for conservative values’

Paul Karp

26, Nov, 2017 @2:35 AM

Article image
Queensland election: party insiders say minority government is increasingly likely
Labor and the LNP expect wildly different results from different parts of the state, with only a narrow path to outright victory

Ben Smee

29, Oct, 2020 @3:16 AM

Article image
Shifting sands: Queensland sees red in blue-ribbon seats as election draws near
The appeal of the state border closure among pensioners along with changing demographics in traditional LNP strongholds has changed the dynamic of the campaign in Labor’s favour

Ben Smee

21, Oct, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Has anyone seen Pauline? 10 things we learned from the Queensland election campaign
A campaign that seemed likely to be dominated by the pandemic turned into something more conventional, but with a highly uncertain outcome

Ben Smee and Graham Readfearn

29, Oct, 2020 @9:03 PM

Article image
Northern Territory declared Covid-19 free – as it happened
Annastacia Palaszczuk says she won’t be lectured to by NSW, ‘a state that has the highest number of cases in Australia’, while Joel Fitzgibbon opens new front in China row. This blog is now closed

Josh Taylor (now), Elias Visontay and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

21, May, 2020 @9:32 AM

Article image
Victoria reports 35 new cases and seven deaths as NSW records four cases – as it happened
Victoria to turn roads and footpaths into dining spaces to help hospitality industry as Queensland border row deepens. Follow all today’s news

Luke Henriques-Gomes (now), and Amy Remeikis and Graham Readfearn (earlier)

14, Sep, 2020 @8:57 AM

Article image
Palaszczuk says Abbott has rediscovered Queensland after election banishment'
New premier says it is ‘amazing’ the prime minister had resumed visiting the state after a campaign which he was reportedly barred from by his LNP state counterparts

Joshua Robertson

18, Feb, 2015 @5:06 AM