Tamil family from Biloela fight fresh deportation appeal

Federal government denies that requesting a briefing on the family days before the 2019 election indicated minister was considering allowing Tharunicaa to apply for a visa, court hears

The federal government has argued that the fact the immigration minister sought a briefing on the Tamil family from Biloela days out from the 2019 election did not indicate he was considering allowing the youngest daughter to apply for a visa.

The full bench of the federal court on Wednesday heard the Coalition’s appeal in the long-running case involving Tamil asylum seekers Priya and Nades and their Australian-born daughters, Kopika and Tharunicaa, who have been detained on Christmas Island since late last year.

The Queensland family is awaiting the outcome of legal proceedings surrounding a visa application for Tharunicaa.

In April, Justice Mark Moshinsky ruled that Tharunicaa had been denied procedural fairness, with evidence showing a brief was prepared for the immigration minister, David Coleman, by the home affairs department in May 2019 outlining he had the power to intervene and lift the bar to allow Tharunicaa and her family to make an application.

Coleman never acted on that brief that was prepared just days before the 2019 federal election.

In appealing Moshinsky’s decision, counsel representing the minister, Stephen Lloyd, told the full bench of the federal court that requesting the brief did not indicate the minister was thinking of lifting the bar and that at the time the brief was requested “the family was the focus of press attention”.

“One might expect that a responsible minister may wish to be apprised of the circumstances pertaining to a family likely to get press coverage,” Lloyd said. “So that may be why he was asking for a full brief.”

Part of the reason it is unclear why Coleman did not act on the brief is he had been on personal leave since the end of last year and was not called to give evidence as to his reasoning in the first trial.

The court heard that while Coleman was still a member of parliament and the minister for immigration he has not voted in parliament since the end of October 2019. Alan Tudge has been acting immigration minister for nearly a year.

Counsel representing the family, Angel Aleksov, said the briefing was “unambiguous” and “the best evidence in this case”. Lloyd objected to the late filing of the claim in February just days before the case was heard but Aleksov said it was obvious at the time where the case was headed once the brief came to light.

“Our opponents are advised by a national law firm, one of the country’s leading juniors and easily one of the country’s leading silk who won a case in the high court not only just today,” Aleksov said. “For them to suggest that they did not understand where the case was going, in our respectful submission, is an ostrich turning her eggs in the nest.”

The appeal had been set down for hearings over two days but was heard in half a day, with justices Geoffrey Flick, Richard White and Natalie Charlesworth insisting both sides not retread over arguments made in written submissions before the hearing. The court reserved its judgment.

Contributor

Josh Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Biloela Tamil family deportation case: removal delayed until at least Friday
Federal court in Melbourne extends injunction preventing asylum seeker family being deported from Christmas Island to Sri Lanka

Josh Taylor and Helen Davidson

04, Sep, 2019 @2:57 AM

Article image
Coalition says community detention not a pathway to resettlement for Biloela family
Campaigners say minister’s decision must be ‘first step’ in returning Murugappans to Queensland

Katharine Murphy and Sarah Martin

15, Jun, 2021 @7:46 AM

Article image
Biloela family to reunite on Australian mainland but visa status expected to remain unchanged
The immigration minister, Alex Hawke, is set to announce the Murugappan family will be released from detention on Christmas Island

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

14, Jun, 2021 @9:53 AM

Article image
Biloela Tamil family to remain on Christmas Island after federal court upholds ruling on daughter's visa
Court denounces government’s ‘Kafkaesque’ handling of visa application for youngest Australian-born daughter, who is being detained indefinitely with her family

Josh Taylor

16, Feb, 2021 @1:01 AM

Article image
Biloela Tamil family deportation case: asylum seekers can stay until final hearing
Federal court rules the family has a prima facie case to stay, and government cannot deport them to Sri Lanka until a final hearing

Josh Taylor

19, Sep, 2019 @4:56 AM

Article image
Three members of Biloela family granted temporary bridging visas
Immigration minister Alex Hawke grants visas, meaning family will be released from community detention in Perth

Daniel Hurst , Josh Taylor and Paul Karp

23, Jun, 2021 @6:44 AM

Article image
Biloela family may soon be released into community detention on Christmas Island
Home affairs minister Karen Andrews says she is considering the ‘welfare of that family’ and is discussing accommodation options

Josh Taylor

05, May, 2021 @2:32 AM

Article image
Biloela Tamil family separated as mother flown to Perth for medical treatment
Priya Murugappan moved after doctors on Christmas Island unable to identify cause of pain, but she says ‘the greater pain’ is separation from young children

Hannah Ryan

20, Jul, 2020 @2:43 AM

Article image
Keeping Biloela family locked up on Christmas Island cost Australia $1.4m last year
Detention of Tamil family denounced as ‘morally disgraceful and obscenely expensive’ as visa case for Australian-born daughter remains locked in federal court

Josh Taylor

07, Jan, 2021 @4:49 AM

Article image
High court rejects bid to appeal Biloela child Tharnicaa Murugappan protection visa case
Court’s decision compels immigration minister to review the four-year-old’s eligibility for assessment as an asylum seeker

Josh Taylor

12, Aug, 2021 @2:13 AM