Labor urges Coalition to reverse plan to cut jobkeeper as economy worsens

Exclusive: Shadow treasurer Jim Chalmers says tapering of wage subsidy no longer makes sense due to coronavirus’s affect on Victoria

Labor has called on the Morrison government to reverse its plan to cut the jobkeeper wage subsidy in September, because economic conditions have deteriorated since the announcement.

Ahead of the resumption of federal parliament next week, where the economy and aged care will be a major focus, the shadow treasurer, Jim Chalmers, told Guardian Australia the government needed to rethink its plan to taper the jobkeeper payment in the light of the Victorian outbreak.

Chalmers said the government needed to tailor income support to the current economic conditions “and we know the jobs crisis has been getting worse, not better”.

“The extension of jobkeeper was welcome, but it makes sense for the tapering to be reconsidered now, given it was announced just as the situation in Victoria was deteriorating,” he said.

According to a spokesman for the treasurer, Josh Frydenberg, the government is able to proceed with tapering the payment without having to secure parliamentary approval until the end of this year. Any changes in 2021 would have to come back to the parliament for approval.

But Chalmers said the government needed to consider the impact of reducing the wages subsidy next month given the prolonged second wave of Covid-19 infections in Victoria and the risks of an outbreak in New South Wales.

“Winding back jobkeeper will remove a fair bit of support from the economy, which is more alarming in the absence of any comprehensive jobs plan,” he said.

“If they are winding back jobkeeper, and the economy is not recovering as fast as we like, then what is going to fill the hole? Economists and peak groups we speak to are increasingly worried about this new September cliff."

“The Reserve Bank and others are already warning that withdrawing support too soon risks compromising recovery, and we can’t afford a generation of lost and discarded workers left out and left behind.”

The latest labour force data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics says more than a million Australians are now out of work.

The prime minister, Scott Morrison, and Frydenberg in July announced an extension of the income support rolled out to support Australians during the pandemic, but it foreshadowed cuts to both the jobkeeper and jobseeker payments on the rationale that the government could not keep “burning cash”.

As well as lowering the rate of the jobkeeper wage subsidy and the $550 coronavirus supplement in jobseeker after September, the government proposed to tighten the eligibility requirements for both payments – including retesting businesses in October.

But three weeks later, the government changed tack, overhauling the new eligibility requirements for the jobkeeper wage subsidy in the light of the deterioration in Victoria.

The government’s adjustments in early August mean that businesses and not-for-profits will only have to show a fall in turnover in the September quarter compared with a comparable period in 2019, rather than having to show declines in the June and September quarters to requalify for the subsidy after 28 September.

After 4 January 2021, businesses and not-for-profits will have to show a fall in the December quarter compared to a comparable period the year before instead of having to demonstrate a fall in turnover in the June, September and December quarters to access the payment.

The comments from Chalmers follow a declaration at the weekend by the former Labor leader, now shadow minister for government services, Bill Shorten, that the government should not cut either jobkeeper or jobseeker in September.

Shorten told the ABC Labor would “arrive at its position” but “I live in Victoria – it’s pretty bloody obvious that we should be extending jobseeker and jobkeeper into the next year”.

“As a Victorian, I see the hardship,” he said. “Jobkeeper has, on balance, done more good than harm. Let’s just get on with it.”


Katharine Murphy Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labor to pass government's jobkeeper 2.0 despite concerns for workers' conditions
ALP says it didn’t want to stand in way of extending wage subsidies despite fears bill will allow companies to shift liability for recovery on to workers

Paul Karp

25, Aug, 2020 @5:49 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison dismisses calls for Josh Frydenberg to front Covid-19 inquiry over jobkeeper
Penny Wong says treasurer should have ‘the courage’ to take responsibility for the ‘$60bn black hole’ in the program

Daniel Hurst

24, May, 2020 @5:16 AM

Article image
Labor and the Greens push to extend eligibility for jobkeeper scheme
Bids to broaden scheme come as Liberal backbenchers debate ending it early and employers and unions unite in warning against cuts

Paul Karp

12, May, 2020 @10:07 AM

Article image
Retailers caution Coalition against cutting jobkeeper in September as economy flounders
National Retail Association urges government to rethink reducing the wages subsidy, arguing only 80% of retailers have reopened

Paul Karp and Katharine Murphy

19, Aug, 2020 @11:12 PM

Article image
Labor demands coronavirus supports remain as figures show 13 jobseekers per vacancy
Opposition seizes on new data arguing Coalition has been ‘demonising unemployed people’

Paul Karp

12, Jul, 2020 @6:44 AM

Article image
Labor calls on Coalition to do more for hard-hit areas of Australian economy as jobkeeper cuts kick in
Government is withdrawing critical support when it is most needed and has no proper plan for jobs, federal opposition says

Daniel Hurst

03, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Coalition defends robodebt process as Labor applies pressure – as it happened
Government services minister Stuart Robert apologises for $7,000 demand sent to dead man. This blog has now closed

Amy Remeikis

30, Jul, 2019 @7:44 AM

Article image
Unions urge Morrison government to lift minimum wage as jobkeeper ends
Sally McManus says rise would stimulate the economy as up to 150,000 people expected to lose their job as pandemic support measure ends

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

28, Mar, 2021 @3:02 AM

Article image
Pandemic leave is just Victoria's hardship payments rebadged, Labor says
Employer groups split on plan, with some calling for it to be extended to other states

Paul Karp

04, Aug, 2020 @2:21 AM

Article image
Morrison government stares down push to end jobkeeper scheme early
Coalition delays a Labor and Greens push to expand the $1,500 fortnightly wage subsidy and insists it will be delivered until September

Paul Karp

13, May, 2020 @11:03 AM