Kevin Rudd says Malcolm Turnbull's rejection of UN bid a 'monstrous intrusion'

Former PM says Julie Bishop championed compromise for cabinet to decide on bid to be secretary general of United Nations

Kevin Rudd has given an account of his bid to become the UN secretary general, heaping praise on the foreign affairs minister, Julie Bishop, for championing a compromise for cabinet to consider the bid after the prime minister withdrew his support.

Rudd told the Australian newspaper that Bishop gave him assurances Malcolm Turnbull supported a plan to have cabinet decide his nomination for UN secretary general after the election, despite Turnbull telling Rudd he had no support on 1 May.

Rudd also warned the handling of the nomination would diminish Turnbull’s standing because the international community would see it as a “monstrous intrusion” of domestic politics into the process.

In the interview, Rudd said he respected the right of the prime minister to make the decision to reject his bid but he did not respect the fact he had pursued the nomination in good faith only to have that good faith “dishonoured and trust broken”.

On Friday last week Rudd released a number of letters he sent Turnbull documenting his account that Turnbull had supported his bid before a phone call on 1 May, in which the prime minister reneged on that support.

Senior government players have contested a claim that Turnbull gave Rudd an explicit undertaking of support during a meeting in December 2015 but Turnbull has not denied he encouraged the bid before May.

According to Rudd, Turnbull told him in a phone call on 1 May that if he took the bid to cabinet it would be defeated. Rudd said he challenged Turnbull to take it to cabinet immediately and warned that, if defeated, he would go public and defend his actions in campaigning for the job, which would have revealed Rudd’s account Turnbull had encouraged him.

Rudd said that after the call Bishop played the role of conciliator and made a “remarkable proposal” for cabinet to consider the nomination after the election and assured him the compromise had Turnbull’s “genuine support”.

As a result, Rudd continued his global campaign for the UN job despite Turnbull telling him on 1 May his candidacy was not supported.

Bishop wrote a cabinet submission knowing the prime minister had some reservations about Rudd but she proceeded, with consultation, in the expectation that he would follow the bipartisan practice of elevating former prime ministers to international roles.

Rudd criticised Turnbull’s eventual decision not to support him, saying it was “no small thing” for the prime minister to say his predecessor was unsuitable.

“I think, though, in the counsels of the world, that will reflect poorly on him,” he said. “I’m no perfect candidate. I’ve got skills, I’ve got background, I’ve got experience. So do a lot of other candidates.

“But what the international community finds difficult to understand is when you have such a monstrous intrusion of domestic politics so as to prevent one of your own from actually competing on the international stage.”

By contrast, Rudd praised Bishop for her professionalism and consistency throughout.

“If at any stage foreign minister Bishop had reached a judgment that the candidature was no longer capable of being supported in Australia, I know her well enough to know she would simply have told me in black and white,” he said.

On 3AW on Friday, Turnbull said Rudd knew at all times it was a matter for the cabinet and there was no guarantee he would be nominated.

“[Rudd] was certainly told in absolutely unequivocal terms in May, and he doesn’t deny this, that my estimation was if it went to the cabinet he would not be supported and I told him why.”

Asked about Rudd’s account of the compromise devised by Bishop, Turnbull said: “I am not going to get into a debate about Kevin Rudd and his various assertions.

“The decision was clear and the decision was the correct one.”

Turnbull said he would not dispute Rudd’s account that he cited Rudd’s interpersonal skills and temperament as the reason for the decision.

Senior cabinet minister Christopher Pyne told Channel Nine’s Today program cabinet opposed Rudd “mostly because of the character reference given to him by the Labor party over a very long period of time and his behaviour since just confirms why he is not suitable”.

“Everyone needs to move on, including Kevin,” he said.

The opposition leader, Bill Shorten, said on Friday he could understand that Rudd was frustrated because “he appears that he thought he had a deal, an agreement with Mr Turnbull”.

“Clearly there’s been some almighty upheaval and division in the Liberal party and now Mr Turnbull’s had to change his position,” Shorten said.

“If Mr Turnbull can do a deal with someone and then has to come back and say sorry, I couldn’t convince all my rightwing sort of minders to do it, well what sort of stability does that promise us on all the other big issues in Australia?”


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull refuses to nominate Kevin Rudd as UN secretary general
Australian prime minister’s decision follows lengthy cabinet meeting on Thursday in which objections to Rudd’s candidacy were aired

Katharine Murphy Political editor

29, Jul, 2016 @2:13 AM

Article image
Bill Shorten: Turnbull 'danced to string-pulling' of right wing on Rudd UN bid
Opposition leader says Malcolm Turnbull bowed to the wishes of conservative colleagues by opposing Kevin Rudd’s bid to become UN secretary general

Paul Karp

01, Aug, 2016 @10:58 PM

Article image
Australia's PM fails to endorse predecessor Kevin Rudd for UN job
Rudd was hoping to succeed Ban Ki-moon as UN secretary general but PM Malcolm Turnbull says he is not suited to the role

Elle Hunt

29, Jul, 2016 @10:16 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull rejects Julie Bishop's argument on Kevin Rudd's UN bid
PM agrees with Alan Jones that a nomination for secretary general amounts to indirect support for former Labor leader

Gabrielle Chan

28, Jul, 2016 @12:56 AM

Article image
Kevin Rudd outlines 10-point plan to reform UN in response to globalisation
Former Australian prime minister who has not been nominated for role of secretary general says United Nations is in danger of drifting into irrelevance

Katharine Murphy, Political editor

08, Aug, 2016 @2:02 AM

Article image
Hurt feelings: why did Malcolm Turnbull send Kevin Rudd mixed messages? | Katharine Murphy
The PM was given the final call on Rudd’s candidacy for the UN job and he lined up with conservatives. It’s quite the flip

Katharine Murphy Political editor

29, Jul, 2016 @11:03 AM

Article image
Today's campaign: calls for 'the old Malcolm' mount, putting pressure on Turnbull
Election 2016: voters and News Corp alike are lamenting the apparent change in the PM’s persona after he won the leadership

Melissa Davey

23, May, 2016 @9:23 PM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull to 'humbly' re-examine policies after byelection losses
Labor’s Super Saturday victories will put leadership speculation to bed, Tanya Plibersek says

Amy Remeikis with Australian Associated Press

29, Jul, 2018 @3:00 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull gives Coalition wiggle room on company tax cuts
Prime minister commits to seeking ‘competitive’ rate rather than specifics

Katharine Murphy Political editor

29, Jul, 2018 @8:37 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull insists Coalition is still behind him after 30th Newspoll loss
Prime minister regrets Newspoll remark as Bill Shorten attacked by Kevin Rudd over 2010 ‘coup’

Amy Remeikis

09, Apr, 2018 @2:31 AM