Ron Mueck: 25 Years of Sculpture; The Gaze review – size isn’t everything

Thaddaeus Ropac; TJ Boulting, London
Tiny woman beats giant skull in the inscrutably hyperreal sculptures of Ron Mueck. And Moroni’s handsome tailor inspires a look at the male gaze

Dead Dad – naked, ashen and piteously half-sized – looks more poignant than ever after quarter of a century. Ron Mueck’s most famous figure lies on its slab like a body in the morgue, dead and yet so lately alive. Time has deepened its pallor, and given it a new significance – this poor bare forked animal might now be another victim of Covid.

Twenty-five years of sculpture doesn’t amount to very many at Thaddaeus Ropac. Mueck’s punctiliously super-real beings take an age to make, from their liver spots and silver stubble to the downy hair on forearm or cheek, and there are only nine works in this selected survey. But they vary in scale from the tiny Man in Blankets – a big bruiser reduced to the size of a newborn, curled in pink swaddling as if trying to return to the womb – to the gigantic skull titled Dead Weight. Every stage of life lies in between.

Youth, 2009/11.
Youth, 2009/11 by Ron Mueck. Photograph: © Ron Mueck/ courtesy Thaddaeus Ropac gallery

Some figures have been shown before. The black teenager incredulously touching the knife wound in his side, like a contemporary doubting Thomas. The woman lying on her back immediately after birth, staring at the strange infant on her chest, fists clenched as if stricken or dumbfounded. The elderly couple in their fading swimwear, sheltering from the sun beneath an outsize umbrella.

This is an art of narrative and whole-hearted emotion. You are not supposed to be baffled by these obvious staging posts in our common existence. Humanity is Mueck’s entire theme, as openly declared as his special effects are inscrutable. You can look into these faces and wonder how on earth he gets that red-rimmed exhaustion into a woman’s eyes, or that blankness in a boy’s dazed expression, while at the same time absolutely receiving and sharing those feelings.

The illusions remain immaculate. Mueck started out as a model-maker, and the accompanying photographs by Gautier Deblonde show the artist working on a miniature maquette or perfecting the discolouration of a colossal toenail with a diminutive paintbrush. There are anatomical toys, books of yoga positions and try-out models. You see the emergence of Woman With Shopping, from grey fibreglass and painted polyurethane to the finished figure in the gallery.

Sentinel-still, in her Dr Martens and old overcoat, she holds two carrier bags filled with baby wipes and teabags and a (not quite to scale) bottle of cheap sauvignon. The baby buttoned inside her coat, against the cold, stares up at its exhausted mother, searching for her absent gaze. Yet there is a snag: the woman is herself no bigger than a little child. The pull towards sentiment is too overt and strenuous.

And the latest works here turn out, for all their size, to be the least of this show. A big head glowers back at you from the shadows of a black chamber. It’s a confrontation. Or it would be if the eyes were not deliberately oblique beneath the overhanging brows. Dark Place is the too-obvious title of a work fit for spectres and Halloween.

The prodigious skull, cast in iron, weighs in at over a ton. No matter what it is intended to represent, it looks like what it is: a muckle lump of dark metal. Without the advantage of Mueck’s spectacular hyperreal art, this 2021 sculpture is no more than a particularly large feat of old-fashioned casting. It may be bigger than an elephant’s skull, yet it has almost no impact at all.

The Tailor, 1570 by Moroni.
‘Steady intent’: The Tailor, c1570 by Moroni. Photograph: Alamy Stock Photo

Giovanni Moroni painted his tremendous portrait The Tailor around 1570. The tailor looks up from his work with steady intent, shears in hand, about to cut the cloth. We see him and he sees us: the exchange is startlingly mutual. It has captivated viewers for centuries, and now inspires the writer and curator Louis Wise to put on a contemporary art show, The Gaze, in response.

He has photographs, drawings and paintings: a come-hither Moroni, a teasing thumb in the mouth Moroni, a masturbating Moroni. That is to say, in these images men are looking back at you with something of the same electrifying gaze. A few are not looking at you but each other, as in the American artist Gilbert Lewis’s tantalising painting of one young man looking through a doorway at another. Some simply resemble Moroni’s darkly handsome tailor. It is in both respects a show of looks.

All of these men are gay. Wise believes, quite plausibly, that Moroni was himself homosexual. Art history absolutely resists such guesses, where there is no documentary evidence. But I can see why. It is not just Wise’s own personal response to the picture, deep as this obviously is (and who hasn’t fallen for a person in a portrait: these are living beings, very often depicted at their beautiful best). It is also that the tailor is so unusual, almost the only one of Moroni’s sitters who is not an aristocrat, intellectual or courtier. The look he gives the artist is piercingly intense. Why did Moroni paint him – was it love?

Star ratings (out of five)
Ron Mueck
★★★
The Gaze
★★★

  • The Gaze is at TJ Boulting, London, until 20 November

Contributor

Laura Cumming

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Chris Ofili: Weaving Magic; Mat Collishaw: The Centrifugal Soul – review
Chris Ofili’s watercolour-tapestry is a marvel of the weaver’s craft, but the concept is ill-defined. And Mat Collishaw conjures an apparition of nature in full flutter

Laura Cumming

30, Apr, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Robert Rauschenberg review – the combine master, uncut
This thrilling retrospective gives us Rauschenberg whole, from his collages to his ballets to his own wild performances

Laura Cumming

04, Dec, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Sophie Taeuber-Arp review – the great overlooked modernist
Tate Modern, London
Dadaist, textile designer, teacher, dancer… the prodigiously gifted Swiss artist makes the spirits soar in this big reveal of a show

Laura Cumming

18, Jul, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
Soul of a Nation review – the extraordinary art of the black power era
Civil rights meet aesthetics in a riveting survey of 20 crucial years of black American art and struggle

Laura Cumming

16, Jul, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
It’s Me to the World review – you may have seen it here first
The gallery celebrates 50 trailblazing years with new work and old favourites by Richard Long, Marina Abramović and more

Laura Cumming

28, Aug, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Edinburgh art festival 2016 review – where Lothian meets utopian
Christian Boltanski, Damián Ortega and Alice Neel impress in this year’s strongly international show

Laura Cumming

31, Jul, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Edinburgh art festival review – the dark side of Robert Burns
A Pablo Bronstein folly, Rabbie in ruins and a fond Māori farewell are among this year’s standouts, while Inverleith House is sorely missed…

Laura Cumming

30, Jul, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Peter Doig; Jasmine Thomas-Girvan & Chris Ofili review – tall tales on distant shores
Peter Doig’s new paintings are typically mysterious and entrancing, but a joint show from his Trinidadian neighbours glitters less for all its gold

Laura Cumming

08, Sep, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
Dorothea Tanning; Tracey Emin review – from the sublime to the miserabilist
A show full of surprises reveals Dorothea Tanning as so much more than the last surrealist, while Tracey Emin delivers a monotone lament in 100 works

Laura Cumming

03, Mar, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Ruth Asawa: A Line Can Go Anywhere; Benode Behari Mukherjee: After Sight – review
Posthumous celebrations of two undervalued but extraordinary 20th century artists give them both the recognition they deserve

Laura Cumming

19, Jan, 2020 @9:00 AM